Deledio vs Roughead - who have performed better over their careers so far?

[one-eyed]

Plough this arvo/evening asking the question on his twitter page - http://twitter.com/thelistmanager


Who has been better performed out of Brett Deledio or Jarryd Roughead over their careers so far?


Stats comparison:
http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=15&pid1=1484&tid2=11&pid2=1485&type=A&fid1=C&fid2=C

[Hard Roar Tiger]

No doubt lids - compare roughie to griffin

[10 FLAGS]

This is a no contest. Deledio by the length of 2 flemington straights.

[tony_montana]

No contest, roughead has had one very very good season. Thought he was shot up to 4-5 weeks ago but has been reinvented as a L.Brown type 2nd ruck. Lids is bordering on A-grade and going to a new level this season

[The Big Richo]

May as well compare Terry Wallet to Ron Barassi.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Lids easily.

This preoccupation of Terry's about our players is quite disturbing. As if he is trying to justify his five years provided the nucleus of the current crop.

Next weeks edition Jack Riewoldt vs Lachie Hansen
Fortnights  Trent Cotchin vs Chris Masten

[Go Richo 12]

Lids easily.

This preoccupation of Terry's about our players is quite disturbing. As if he is trying to justify his five years provided the nucleus of the current crop.

Next weeks edition Jack Riewoldt vs Lachie Hansen
Fortnights  Trent Cotchin vs Chris Masten

Or Cotchin versus Kruezer, although they are different sizes in different positions!
Next year- Martin versus Scully, Trengrove

[Hellenic Tiger]

I only put Cotchin vs Masten and not Kruezer as Kruze went before Trent that way he can harp on and on.

He'll speak more about Cotch than Dusty b/c ultimately Dusty was selected after his regime was dismissed.

I want him to bring up the McMahon vs Ward match up and run us through that.

[bojangles17]

You'd think Lids eaily, my guess is Hawks fan would drag out the old chestnut that JR has played in a flag. Id fire abck they might have won two with Lids. he has turned into a more complete exceptionally talented layer. Still room for improvement. the test of just how good both Lids and cotch will be if they can drag the team into finals action sooner rather than later...show us the way boys

[Tigeritis™©®]

Facts are that hawthorn only picked roughead first because they knew we wanted him with our next pick. The stupid brainstrust at Richmond didn't think Franklin was worth our 4th pick so we were always going to pick roughead.
Hawthorn knew this and snapped him up so they could secure the 2 best talls in the draft they new Franklin was a superstar and roughead was the next best tall. They also knew that we were picking lids first and the bulldogs were picking that other guy. 

The question should really be Deledio v Franklin.

[Oiafi]

Facts are that hawthorn only picked roughead first because they knew we wanted him with our next pick. The stupid brainstrust at Richmond didn't think Franklin was worth our 4th pick so we were always going to pick roughead.
Hawthorn knew this and snapped him up so they could secure the 2 best talls in the draft they new Franklin was a superstar and roughead was the next best tall. They also knew that we were picking lids first and the bulldogs were picking that other guy. 

The question should really be Deledio v Franklin.

The thing your story forgets is the Hawks expected us to pick Franklin and when we took Tambling it caused them a stir and it took them quite a while and a fair amount of talking before they called Franklin's name. It would seem they rated Roughead over Franklin and they were fortunate we picked Tambling. Only in hindsight though.

[gerkin greg]

Wallet is sharking for a new job 

[Dice]

Question:    Who has been better performed out of Brett Deledio or Jarryd Roughead over their careers so far?

Roughead has perfomed better with the ladies 

[Infamy]

Facts are that hawthorn only picked roughead first because they knew we wanted him with our next pick. The stupid brainstrust at Richmond didn't think Franklin was worth our 4th pick so we were always going to pick roughead.
Hawthorn knew this and snapped him up so they could secure the 2 best talls in the draft they new Franklin was a superstar and roughead was the next best tall. They also knew that we were picking lids first and the bulldogs were picking that other guy.  

The question should really be Deledio v Franklin.

I am so sick of this bullcrap story being told. It DID NOT happen like this at all.
Even Gary Buckenara (their recruitment manager at the time) in a video interview after the draft admitted as such.

[Mr Magic]

Why didn't he ask Jordan McMahon vs anyone?