Who is your official whipping boy for 2012?

[Dubstep Dookie]

Time to officially declare your hand, prior to the kicking off of the NAB cup and season proper.

Who is your official whipping boy for 2012, or, should we support all of our players irrespective of how they play?

Vote and discuss.

[Coach]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

[Eat_em_Alive]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

 

[MADTIGER2010]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

Of course. Nothing more embarrassing for our supporters to see some of our other supporters bag our own players at the footy and giving opposition supporters a massive head while laughing at us. Not to mention annoying all our other supporters who support every one of our players on game day. If I see constant abuse from one of our own supporters I'll snap em out  . They probably show up to 3 games a year anyway

[Phil Mrakov]

Jackson. Would have happily sent him off to Sydney instead of Morton.

But I'd happilly send him off for absolutely no compensation aswell.

[Dubstep Dookie]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

Of course. Nothing more embarrassing for our supporters to see some of our other supporters bag our own players at the footy and giving opposition supporters a massive head while laughing at us. Not to mention annoying all our other supporters who support every one of our players on game day. If I see constant abuse from one of our own supporters I'll snap em out  . They probably show up to 3 games a year anyway

As opposed to supporters who dont verbalise what they are thinking at the game, and then come home and tee off at players on forums like this?

It's still whipping, just a different method.

And often, the criticism is on the money. It's just whether it's constructive and a shared view that irks do gooder supporters at the end of the day.

[The Mole]

Why do we need one?

[tigs2011]

Voted other. Cotchin for me. 

[Smokey]

Edwards will frustrate me the most with his ability to do the impossible followed straight up by the absurd.
Jackson will annoy me the most with his stupidity under pressure.
Graham will disappoint me the most with his complete inability to do anything good in spite of his physique.

[MADTIGER2010]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

Of course. Nothing more embarrassing for our supporters to see some of our other supporters bag our own players at the footy and giving opposition supporters a massive head while laughing at us. Not to mention annoying all our other supporters who support every one of our players on game day. If I see constant abuse from one of our own supporters I'll snap em out  . They probably show up to 3 games a year anyway

As opposed to supporters who dont verbalise what they are thinking at the game, and then come home and tee off at players on forums like this?

It's still whipping, just a different method.

And often, the criticism is on the money. It's just whether it's constructive and a shared view that irks do gooder supporters at the end of the day.

I'm as vocal as anyone. Standing with a pumped fist after every goal. But I rarely whinge about umpiring or players. 95% of the time the ump makes the right decision. Many supporters just make noise when they are whingeing about the umps or players but when we kick a goal they are as quiet as a mouse. Are they at the game just to get away from the wife? 

[The Big Richo]

Can we please have Hardwick and Riewoldt added to this thread.

[Dubstep Dookie]

Should support them on game day and then talk about how they played after the game. Whipping boys are for idiots

Of course. Nothing more embarrassing for our supporters to see some of our other supporters bag our own players at the footy and giving opposition supporters a massive head while laughing at us. Not to mention annoying all our other supporters who support every one of our players on game day. If I see constant abuse from one of our own supporters I'll snap em out  . They probably show up to 3 games a year anyway

As opposed to supporters who dont verbalise what they are thinking at the game, and then come home and tee off at players on forums like this?

It's still whipping, just a different method.

And often, the criticism is on the money. It's just whether it's constructive and a shared view that irks do gooder supporters at the end of the day.

95% of the time the ump makes the right decision.

I was with you until this little beauty popped up. 

Can we please have Hardwick and Riewoldt added to this thread.

Request denied. 

[gerkin greg]

[Mr Magic]

Cotchin

[Phar Ace]

Not going to whip him but I don't have big expectations of Gus Graham.