Who do you want in terms of trades and draft selections next year

[rfctigers05]

Oldman Skipper retire off
Bo Derrickx axe
King Island Brie axe
Ahole Maric axe
Pia Miller axe
Diarrhea Darrou axe
Pivotal Piva axe
Hips Moore retire sorry buddy it's a business
farmer Brown axe
The Last Post trade
Keep Jacko still tough and serviceable
Keep MCG MCguane but only as a spare parts forward

[Dubstep Dookie]

Don't be fooled by the rocks that he's got
He's still (he's still) Roy from the block
He used to have a little but now he has a lot
No matter where he goes he knows where he came from

 

[the claw]

Would pick up David Hille

que for all the experts to tell ya hes too old.
id take him too but it would have to be real cheap.

lets say pick 10 is ours

10 - caddy.
2nd  rnd -  mid
compenastion - mid
3rd  rnd -  young ruckman
4th rnd - need.
5th rnd - mature state league or recycled afl layer. best available.  eg tom lee chf/chb
6th rnd hille -  if possible.  or 189cm for/mid duffy e/freo/
psd moloney
free agency kpd  merrett carlisle chaplin type.

rookie - mature state leaugue mid.
best available  needs.

[mightytiges]

As far as types we need 2 more quality mids, another AFL standard ruck, a tall agile big-bodied defender, a quality CHF, quality small quick footy smart forward & quality lead-up footysmart midsized forward (another Nathan Brown).

I'll be quite happy with 3 picks roughly in the top 30 including our first pick at 7 (finishing 13th on the ladder).

1. GWS
2. GC
3. Melb
4. Melb
5. Dogs
6. Port
7. Rich (1st rounder)
8. Bris
9. Carl
10. Freo
...
19. Syd
20. GWS (PP)
21. GC (PP)
22. Melb (PP)
23. GWS
24. GC
25. Melb
26. Dogs
27. Port
28. Rich (compo)
29. Rich (2nd rounder)
...
47-50: Rich (3rd rounder)
Mid-late 60s: Rich (4th rounder)


7. Best available 18 y.o. draftee - which will probably be another gun ballwinner/midfielder.
28. Best available 18 y.o. draftee
29. Trade to score another decent ruckman (Swans have traded late 20s picks to poach young (21-23 y.o.) and upcoming rucks from other clubs - eg: Jolly/Mumford - to be Maric's understudy). I would then look to trade our way back into the 30s then use that on another best available 18 y.o. draftee
50?: Best available 18 y.o. draftee
68?: Top state league (VFL/SANFL/WAFL) 20-something player who has the speed and acceleration to play at AFL level. Obviously no one from Coburg!
PSD pick 6 - history says possibly slim pickings here. Pass

Free agent - key tall or clever quick midsized forward. Otherwise best available.

Newy will go onto the veterans' list freeing up a senior list spot and meaning one less rookie spot.

Need 7 senior list outs ignoring trades: Connors, MacDonald, Webberley, Derickx, White, McGuane, Graham (pay out)

Rookies:
out: Miller (retire), Heslin (gone home), Wright?
2-3 rookies in.

[rfctigers05]

Tim membrey must be picked first

[Dubstep Dookie]

Newy can go onto the seniors list but take it one step further and put him into a retirement home, with a gold watch and coupon book for cheap meals at the local RSL (Real Sh1+y Lunch).

[tigs2011]

Tim membrey must be picked first

Seriously? He's an undersized KPF.

[Judge Roughneck]

Rape gc / gws of some talent.

Trade our rubbish players for low picks.

Trade semi*rubbish for decent picks.

Sign our key players to longer contracts (cotch. Imaric. Rance)

Find a good free agent.

Draft well.

Find mature rookies late picks.

Find couple gun internationals.

Sign director of football and or steal ass coachs to help dimma.

[Big Papa Bear]

Trade:
 Jackson = too many undisciplined acts
Graham = One dimensional ruck, not mobile enough
White = not consistent enough for the amount of games played
Browne = old style ruck, too lumbering
Webberley =  something has happened but did not show desire to play
Addam Maric = Runs around looking for easy touches, cannot tackle and does not go hard
Miller = too slow and cannot kick - needed to make a bigger impact
MacDonald = been on list too long - has not cracked a game
McGuane = does not stand up in big situations

[Coach]

We should have a massive crack at Bellchambers or Hille. Hille would come cheap

[Jackstar is back!!!]

The Coach and me agreeing .mmmm

[jezza]

3 midfielders with our first 3 picks - our lack of depth in midfield is what kills us and it doesn't matter what KPPs we have if we can't get hands on the ball. Mature age ruckman as our backup with a later pick / PSD.

[WilliamPowell]

28. Rich (compo)

Pretty sure we wont be using that pick

Clubs had to nominate using their compo picks back in April/May and pretty sure we didn't so that's not an option

Also think you are more hoping we finish 13th rather than we will 

[10 FLAGS]

Tim membrey must be picked first

Seriously? He's an undersized KPF.

Yep

[Smokey]

Hille would come cheap

There's a good reason for that - he's cooked, game has gone past him.