2012 Brownlow Thread

[Ox]

I wish we didn't have Lids and Tucky now

At the end of the day it's a team sport and it's all about winning this ...



Bobby Skilton said once he would trade all 3 of his Brownlow medals for one.

Bobby talks poo

[tigs2011]

Anyone with a breakdown of the total Essendon and Hawthorn votes? Would like to compare Jobe's vote hoarding since he is surrounded by squibs to how Cotchin and Mitchell had to share their votes.

Teams totals went

Hawthorn
Sydney
Adelaide
Collingwood
Richmond, West Coast

Spot the odd one out. 


Essendon were amongst the poo teams like GC/PA/Melb.

[one-eyed]

Richmond had the 5th most votes per club with 83 in total.

Sydney     95
Hawthorn   92
Adelaide   88
Coll'wood  85
Richmond   83
West Coast 83
Geelong    77
Carlton    76
Fremantle  75
St Kilda   73
Essendon   63
North Melb 60
Brisbane   55
Gold Coast 43
Port Adel. 40
W.Bulldogs 40
Melbourne  27
GWS        22

[eliminator]

The premiership medal is far more valuable to the players. We have never been a team the umpires love. Look at how many Richmond greats never won the medal. Says it all.

[cub]

Don't mind Jobby too much! The Brownlow is held in high esteem and for that reason alone would love Cotch to win it one day. Saying that it is an umpires award and I cant stand the girly softies so meh really!

[gerkin greg]

Richmond had the 5th most votes per club with 83 in total.

Sydney     95
Hawthorn   92
Adelaide   88
Coll'wood  85
Richmond   83
West Coast 83
Geelong    77
Carlton    76
Fremantle  75
St Kilda   73
Essendon   63
North Melb 60
Brisbane   55
Gold Coast 43
Port Adel. 40
W.Bulldogs 40
Melbourne  27
GWS        22

Norf 

[WA Tiger]

R23 vs Port

3. Cotch

1. Riewoldt

Rich total

Cotch  26
Lids     14
Grigg   11
Tuck    10
Riewoldt 6
Martin  5
Foley  3
Rance  3
Edwards 2
Maric   2
Nahas 1
Conca  1

Edward made the top 10

Yeah great isn't he, Foley was in front of him and gone for most of the year..

[wayne]

R23 vs Port

3. Cotch

1. Riewoldt

Rich total

Cotch  26
Lids     14
Grigg   11
Tuck    10
Riewoldt 6
Martin  5
Foley  3
Rance  3
Edwards 2
Maric   2
Nahas 1
Conca  1

Edward made the top 10

Yeah great isn't he, Foley was in front of him and gone for most of the year..

It's a midfielders medal, Edwards did well for a forward pocket.

Other forward pockets

Rioli - 6 votes
Milne - 3
Matera - 3
Leroy Jetta - 3
Bruest - 3

Historically, forward pockets don't do that well in the Brownlow.

Congratulations Edwards! 

[dwaino]

R23 vs Port

3. Cotch

1. Riewoldt

Rich total

Cotch  26
Lids     14
Grigg   11
Tuck    10
Riewoldt 6
Martin  5
Foley  3
Rance  3
Edwards 2
Maric   2
Nahas 1
Conca  1

Edward made the top 10

Yeah great isn't he, Foley was in front of him and gone for most of the year..

It's a midfielders medal, Edwards did well for a forward pocket.

Other forward pockets

Rioli - 6 votes
Milne - 3
Matera - 3
Leroy Jetta - 3
Bruest - 3

Historically, forward pockets don't do that well in the Brownlow.

Congratulations Edwards! 

.

Nearly top 4 for small forwards 

[Loui Tufga]

R23 vs Port

3. Cotch

1. Riewoldt

Rich total

Cotch  26
Lids     14
Grigg   11
Tuck    10
Riewoldt 6
Martin  5
Foley  3
Rance  3
Edwards 2
Maric   2
Nahas 1
Conca  1

Edward made the top 10

Yeah great isn't he, Foley was in front of him and gone for most of the year..

It's a midfielders medal, Edwards did well for a forward pocket.

Other forward pockets

Rioli - 6 votes
Milne - 3
Matera - 3
Leroy Jetta - 3
Bruest - 3

Historically, forward pockets don't do that well in the Brownlow.

Congratulations Edwards! 

.

Nearly top 4 for small forwards 

Top 4-6 Under WAT's criteria he has passed 

[WA Tiger]

  ....LMFAO... "congratulations Edwards"...like he won it.... ..........Classic. Bloody hell 2 votes..... .

[dwaino]

....LMFAO... "congratulations Edwards"...like he won it.... ..........Classic. Bloody hell 2 votes..... .

Just chill out bro. Give us some bones bro

[Loui Tufga]

....LMFAO... "congratulations Edwards"...like he won it.... ..........Classic. Bloody hell 2 votes..... .

Please re read my post Where did I mention "he won it"  Just saying great effort to finish in the top 10 at the club and top 4-6 out of all the small forwards

[rogerd3]

its about time this award was scrapped
it just isnt relevant anymore.

Watson good player not GREAT.

[Phil Mrakov]

its about time this award was scrapped
it just isnt relevant anymore.

Watson good player not GREAT.

Dud kick