Welcome everyone to One-Eyed Richmond's Tiger Forum Cheers from mightytiges and WilliamPowell.
Was super keen on Vlastuin, but reading Wines could slip? Man that gives me a chub.
Quote from: Rampstar on November 21, 2012, 10:43:15 AMJaksch seems to be a really quality young tall. At about 195cm and a good weight mid 80's, I think he could be a very good. We really dont have a tall CHF at all. Vickery seems like someone who will play the ruck/fwd role but a true CHF is a real benefit IMHO. I prefer us to go tall with pick 9 and then take mids at 32, 34 and 43. Jaksch could be a really good pick if Brisbane dont take him.People seem to have forgot on about Todd Elton. Just because he only played the one game last year doesn't mean he's not going to play more down the track I really rate this kid, he will play across the HF line and float through the Ruck, expect bigger things from him this season . I don't see why we would use pick 9 on a tall in exactly the same mould as one we allready have........
Jaksch seems to be a really quality young tall. At about 195cm and a good weight mid 80's, I think he could be a very good. We really dont have a tall CHF at all. Vickery seems like someone who will play the ruck/fwd role but a true CHF is a real benefit IMHO. I prefer us to go tall with pick 9 and then take mids at 32, 34 and 43. Jaksch could be a really good pick if Brisbane dont take him.
Quote from: dwaino on November 21, 2012, 12:05:01 PMWas super keen on Vlastuin, but reading Wines could slip? Man that gives me a chub.I would be happy with either. Vlastuin has better foot skills on both sides than Wines but wins is an awesome extractor of the ball, puts his body on the line in the same mold as Joel Selwood. If Wines is available I think the way he attacks the footy will get him over the line but in saying that the club may believe the Vlastuins disposal is more superior and go in that direction instead. Its gunna be a 50/50 call!!
Quote from: Tiger-From-Tas on November 21, 2012, 10:57:36 AMQuote from: Rampstar on November 21, 2012, 10:43:15 AMJaksch seems to be a really quality young tall. At about 195cm and a good weight mid 80's, I think he could be a very good. We really dont have a tall CHF at all. Vickery seems like someone who will play the ruck/fwd role but a true CHF is a real benefit IMHO. I prefer us to go tall with pick 9 and then take mids at 32, 34 and 43. Jaksch could be a really good pick if Brisbane dont take him.People seem to have forgot on about Todd Elton. Just because he only played the one game last year doesn't mean he's not going to play more down the track I really rate this kid, he will play across the HF line and float through the Ruck, expect bigger things from him this season . I don't see why we would use pick 9 on a tall in exactly the same mould as one we allready have........Havent forgotten Elton at all. I just believe that you can never have enough of this type of player. Jaksch can also play down back and at 195cm and 87kg he is exactly the right size for a KPP. If I had the choice of Jaksch, Wines, Vlastuin or Lonergan, I would pick Jaksch every time.
Don't need Jaksch, but I'd be wrapped if we managed to get Grundy.Wines is a better option than Vlastuin, both will be good.What's peoples thoughts on Menzel? Is he worth taking the risk on with pick 9, as there seems to be the growing possibility that he'll be there.The other one I'd like to pick up is Stringer.
Quote from: JVT on November 21, 2012, 01:30:05 PMDon't need Jaksch, but I'd be wrapped if we managed to get Grundy.Wines is a better option than Vlastuin, both will be good.What's peoples thoughts on Menzel? Is he worth taking the risk on with pick 9, as there seems to be the growing possibility that he'll be there.The other one I'd like to pick up is Stringer.You we do need a Jaksch type player. When you consider the injury concerns on Griffiths, Grimes, when you consider that Elton is just a kid as well, that Astbury needs to massively improve in the next 12 months, that McGuane was played up forward and that we still have Derrickx on our list then yeah I reckon we need a Jaksch type player.
I think I have mentioned it before, but word down here in Traralgon is that GWS want Membrey and he has apparently been told that he'll end up there. Things could change I guess.
