What's our best 22 now?

[Bird Man]

ROUND ONE
B Grimes, Chaplin, Griffiths
HB Morris, Vlas, Rance
C Cothcin Lids, Conca
HF Martin, Knights, Nahas
FF Vickery, Riewoldt, S. Edwards
R Jackson, A. Edwards, Foley Ivan Maric

Int: Ellis, Newman, Batch Sub: King     

NAB
I wanna see
Elton Arnot, Mctosh and Bean and if we get Toy as wellm

Also play griffiths in full forward and see how he gose 

[Fluffy Tiger]

Grimes appears to be the only definite long-term query at this stage. So Griffs will need to remain in defence. Foley is probably the next one in doubt as to whether his achilles can hold up. So at the moment I think our best 22 in the Club's eyes is:
,
B:    Rance       Chaplin      Morris
HB:  Houli        Griffiths    Batchelor
C:    Grigg        Deledio      Conca
HF: S.Edwards  Riewoldt   Knights
F:    Vickery     A.Edwards  Martin
R:    Maric    Tuck    Cotchin
Int: Ellis, Newman, Jackson
Sub: Vlastuin

I wouldn't have Jacko and Aaron Edwards in the side but the coaches love Jacko and I've got a feeling, as they did with Miller, the Club will play Edwards to begin with until his form drops away and one of the young talls pushes him out.

That I do beleive is the team that will run out unless there are futher injuries. I personally want Griffith to be a foward but I agree he will have to stay back for now until sombody steps up. I would also like sombody to step up and take Jacksons and S.Edwards spot, that would make it a very good team IMHO.

[Phil Mrakov]

Grimes appears to be the only definite long-term query at this stage. So Griffs will need to remain in defence. Foley is probably the next one in doubt as to whether his achilles can hold up. So at the moment I think our best 22 in the Club's eyes is:
,
B:    Rance       Chaplin      Morris
HB:  Houli        Griffiths    Batchelor
C:    Grigg        Deledio      Conca
HF: S.Edwards  Riewoldt   Knights
F:    Vickery     A.Edwards  Martin
R:    Maric    Tuck    Cotchin
Int: Ellis, Newman, Jackson
Sub: Vlastuin

I wouldn't have Jacko and Aaron Edwards in the side but the coaches love Jacko and I've got a feeling, as they did with Miller, the Club will play Edwards to begin with until his form drops away and one of the young talls pushes him out.

That I do beleive is the team that will run out unless there are futher injuries. I personally want Griffith to be a foward but I agree he will have to stay back for now until sombody steps up. I would also like sombody to step up and take Jacksons and S.Edwards spot, that would make it a very good team IMHO.

Riewoldt can't play CHF

[Coach]

Tigger at CHB???

[Bird Man]

Tigger at CHB???

yeh i have been thinking about that and trying ask is he the BEST option at CHB

people for that spot
Houli
Griffiths
Ellis
astbury
batch (but i think he will play on teh wing )
Morris
Tigger

All are in compition for that those spost and its a problem we havent ahd in years .. its GREAT 

[Yeahright]

Tigger at CHB???

I think having 5 people at the centre bounce is a genius move, so I back Bird Man with his idea of playing someone probably 10cm shorter on the CHF, it may just work.

[Fluffy Tiger]

Grimes appears to be the only definite long-term query at this stage. So Griffs will need to remain in defence. Foley is probably the next one in doubt as to whether his achilles can hold up. So at the moment I think our best 22 in the Club's eyes is:
,
B:    Rance       Chaplin      Morris
HB:  Houli        Griffiths    Batchelor
C:    Grigg        Deledio      Conca
HF: S.Edwards  Riewoldt   Knights
F:    Vickery     A.Edwards  Martin
R:    Maric    Tuck    Cotchin
Int: Ellis, Newman, Jackson
Sub: Vlastuin

I wouldn't have Jacko and Aaron Edwards in the side but the coaches love Jacko and I've got a feeling, as they did with Miller, the Club will play Edwards to begin with until his form drops away and one of the young talls pushes him out.

That I do beleive is the team that will run out unless there are futher injuries. I personally want Griffith to be a foward but I agree he will have to stay back for now until sombody steps up. I would also like sombody to step up and take Jacksons and S.Edwards spot, that would make it a very good team IMHO.

Riewoldt can't play CHF

Wont catch a Tiger with that sort  of bait 

[Tigeritis™©®]

I highly doubt A "lockup" Edwards will play round 1.

If we have a great run without injuries I'd be very suprised if we will see him play at all.

[rogerd3]

foley wont be in the side.

[Judge Roughneck]

Foley is in our best 10-12

[Phil Mrakov]

Foley is in our best 10-12

He'll play 5-12 games next year

[Eat_em_Alive]

Foley is in our best 10-12

I don't believe that's his point

[torch]

torch's Best 22 ...

B: Morris, Chaplin, Newman

HB: Houli, Rance, Grimes

C: Grigg, Cotchin, Deledio

HF: Griffiths, Vickery, Knights

F: A.Edwards, Riewoldt, S.Edwards

R: Maric, Martin, Foley

I: Tuck, Conca, King

S: Nahas


What I like about Richmond NOW is that we have players that are fighting for positions.

Where do you fit: Jackson, Ellis, Batchelor, Astbury, White, McGuane, Vlastuin???

Dea, Derickx, Elton ... just to name a few are in that third group that are a long way from playing in our team.

Daniel Jackson will always be in Richmond's 22 as long as Hardwick is coach.

So who would come out of my team if that's the case???

No idea ...

[Judge Roughneck]

torch's Best 22 ...

B: Morris, Chaplin, Newman

HB: Houli, Rance, Grimes

C: Grigg, Cotchin, Deledio

HF: Griffiths, Vickery, Knights

F: A.Edwards, Riewoldt, S.Edwards

R: Maric, Martin, Foley

I: Tuck, Conca, King

S: Nahas


What I like about Richmond NOW is that we have players that are fighting for positions.

Where do you fit: Jackson, Ellis, Batchelor, Astbury, White, McGuane, Vlastuin???

Dea, Derickx, Elton ... just to name a few are in that third group that are a long way from playing in our team.

Daniel Jackson will always be in Richmond's 22 as long as Hardwick is coach.

So who would come out of my team if that's the case???

No idea ...

A Edwards
King
Nahas

Stiff on Nahas but cant fit everyone in. Id have Newman and Houli in the gun. You left out Helbig, hopefully he can give headaches to the selection panel. I have left out Jackson for discussion sake.  Everyone drops back a spot if Jacko continues to get game without merit. I would argue this is not good for the long term development of some players on our list.

[Stripes]

torch's Best 22 ...

B: Morris, Chaplin, Newman

HB: Houli, Rance, Grimes

C: Grigg, Cotchin, Deledio

HF: Griffiths, Vickery, Knights

F: A.Edwards, Riewoldt, S.Edwards

R: Maric, Martin, Foley

I: Tuck, Conca, King

S: Nahas


So who would come out of my team if that's the case???

Sadly, I believe Foley won't be ready (or Grimes for that matter) so I would bring in Eliis. Batchelor in for Grimes (if he's still injured). I would like to see Nahas drop out of the team, Dea into the HB line and Houli the sub - just my take of course.