Welcome everyone to One-Eyed Richmond's Tiger Forum Cheers from mightytiges and WilliamPowell.
Quote from: Dougeytherichmondfan on November 02, 2015, 10:47:51 AMGrimes Rance ConcaVlastuin Chaplin HouliMcIntosh Martin B EllisDeledio Reiwoldt YarranEdwards Vickery LennonMaric Cothin MilesC Ellis, Grigg, McBean, Pick 12/LambertQuote from: big tone on November 01, 2015, 10:13:25 PMGrimes Rance Vlastuin C. Ellis Chaplin McIntoshMenadue Martin EdwardsLids Vickery YarranLambert Jack LennonMaric Cotch MilesEllis Castagna Houli McBean
Grimes Rance ConcaVlastuin Chaplin HouliMcIntosh Martin B EllisDeledio Reiwoldt YarranEdwards Vickery LennonMaric Cothin MilesC Ellis, Grigg, McBean, Pick 12/Lambert
Grimes Rance Vlastuin C. Ellis Chaplin McIntoshMenadue Martin EdwardsLids Vickery YarranLambert Jack LennonMaric Cotch MilesEllis Castagna Houli McBean
mcbean, elton, astbury, griffiths, bachelor, dea, grimes, darrou, thursfeild,
Quote from: Yeahright on November 01, 2015, 11:06:55 PMTo be honest I don't take much notice of hit outs, unless you're a very dominant ruck then they are all pretty pointless. Vickerys work as a ruckman outside tapping the ball ain't too shabby.In what way. What does he consistently do well in the role. I can think of only one thing he does well as either a fwd or a ruckman he manages to kick one or two goals a game. An awful lot of em sodas that you would get.In fairness kicking goals sodas or not Its a biggie, and it is the only thing that saves him as a player.In the main and nearly every other area of the game hes been a lazy soft one way player who would struggle at times to get a kick in a footy factory.
To be honest I don't take much notice of hit outs, unless you're a very dominant ruck then they are all pretty pointless. Vickerys work as a ruckman outside tapping the ball ain't too shabby.
He'll be our best pick up ever
Quote from: the claw on November 01, 2015, 11:18:50 PMQuote from: Yeahright on November 01, 2015, 11:06:55 PMTo be honest I don't take much notice of hit outs, unless you're a very dominant ruck then they are all pretty pointless. Vickerys work as a ruckman outside tapping the ball ain't too shabby.In what way. What does he consistently do well in the role. I can think of only one thing he does well as either a fwd or a ruckman he manages to kick one or two goals a game. An awful lot of em sodas that you would get.In fairness kicking goals sodas or not Its a biggie, and it is the only thing that saves him as a player.In the main and nearly every other area of the game hes been a lazy soft one way player who would struggle at times to get a kick in a footy factory.He's quite athletic and good around the packs. Seen him step around people to set up and kick goals quite a few times.
Quote from: Yeahright on November 01, 2015, 10:43:03 PMCastagna a long way off. Honestly think he'll go down as a worse player than Morris.He's far more creative, clever & attacking than Morris, not to mention quicker and a better tackler.....unfortunately his kicking is so utterly awful it's a liabilty and undoes everything else....it's a shame really....
Castagna a long way off. Honestly think he'll go down as a worse player than Morris.
A literal best 22B: Grimes - Chaplin - BatchelorHB: Houli - Rance - Yarran. Fair dinkum its horrid Take the AA out and it is mediocre.MID: McIntosh - Martin - B Ellis. Again atm its one A grader. Ruck: Maric - Cotchin - Miles. Not too shabby but the ruckman is a concern.HF: Deledio - Vickery - Edwards. Gotta ask is there really a pure fwd amongst them.F: Lloyd - Riewoldt - Griffith. Thank god theres an A grader here becuse the other two are shiite.INT: Grigg - Conca - Hunt - Lambert. If there was a place called plodsville this would be it. We need to improve on 9 to 11 players who are supposed to be best 22.
Ah chee could be the next Cyril. Who goes out of the team for him though ? Starting to develop some really good depth. Lennon. Lambert. C Ellis. Conca. B ellis. Pick 12. Drummond. Menadue. Moore. Townsend. Grigg. Any other players really fighting for a spot next year ?
Quote from: the claw on November 04, 2015, 10:14:09 PMA literal best 22B: Grimes - Chaplin - BatchelorHB: Houli - Rance - Yarran. Fair dinkum its horrid Take the AA out and it is mediocre.MID: McIntosh - Martin - B Ellis. Again atm its one A grader. Ruck: Maric - Cotchin - Miles. Not too shabby but the ruckman is a concern.HF: Deledio - Vickery - Edwards. Gotta ask is there really a pure fwd amongst them.F: Lloyd - Riewoldt - Griffith. Thank god theres an A grader here becuse the other two are shiite.INT: Grigg - Conca - Hunt - Lambert. If there was a place called plodsville this would be it. We need to improve on 9 to 11 players who are supposed to be best 22.Don't rate Grimes? He's never going to be a pillar like Rance but I think he's one of those solid good players who really compliment a back line
Quote from: Diocletian on November 02, 2015, 12:09:42 AMQuote from: Yeahright on November 01, 2015, 10:43:03 PMCastagna a long way off. Honestly think he'll go down as a worse player than Morris.He's far more creative, clever & attacking than Morris, not to mention quicker and a better tackler.....unfortunately his kicking is so utterly awful it's a liabilty and undoes everything else....it's a shame really....I disagree. His kicking in the games I have watched has been pretty good. Not elite like say Lids and ....... Actually not that many that are elite in our side. George kicks it as well or better than half our side IMO. As you said, he does have some real attributes so I hope he gets a chance in 2016. And I guess we will see who is right.
