Pick 12 - who should we draft?

[Diocletian]

Cockatoo is nothing like Tambling.
He is a big unit who will only get bigger.  The guy will be huge with a couple of preasons. He could possibly be the next Dangerfield.

Not like Tambling as a player but can see his career taking a similar trajectory if we use pick 12 on him. Would take him later for his pace & size but that's about it, has too many deficiencies to justify using a first round pick on. He'd likely be moved around everywhere trying to find his best spot just like The Witness was. Jack of all trades, master of none. There's a reason you shouldn't use first round picks on div. 2 players.

[Judge Roughneck]

scully isnt that bad and would be a significant upgrade on grigg/foley/thomas/newman types

and he sleeps with a large pillow of gold

for 1 mill a season he's that bad...

Gws don't have a salary cap so I doubt they GAF

[Judge Roughneck]

scully isnt that bad and would be a significant upgrade on grigg/foley/thomas/newman types

and he sleeps with a large pillow of gold

Significant? Not at all. Slight? Maybe on Newman and Thomas

You reckon grigg is a slightly less good player than Scilly?

Lol

[Rampstar]

doesn't matter who they pick coz it wont make any difference to the overall results the team gets. We will finish between 7th and 12th in 2015.

[Willy]

Scully is crap. There is not much difference between he and Grigg.

[Chuck17]

Scully is crap. There is not much difference between he and Grigg.

Taking money and status aside you are a 100% correct Big Willy, Scully stinks it up bad

[Judge Roughneck]

He isn one of the best runners

He can kick

Would be very handy foil for deledio/martin/cotchin

Poos on Thomas grigg winderhack greenwood armitage etc

[Chuck17]

Nope

[Willy]

He isn one of the best runners

He can kick

Would be very handy foil for deledio/martin/cotchin

Poos on Thomas grigg winderhack greenwood armitage etc

He is small, soft and he has average skills

I reckon Greenwood, Winders and Armitage are better and Thomas and Grigg are not far behind.  Agree to disagree though I guess.

[🏅Dooks]

He isn one of the best runners

He can kick

Would be very handy foil for deledio/martin/cotchin

Poos on Thomas grigg winderhack greenwood armitage etc

He is small, soft and he has average skills

I reckon Greenwood, Winders and Armitage are better and Thomas and Grigg are not far behind.  Agree to disagree though I guess.

Gee whiz

[Diocletian]

Gee whiz indeed....for once I'm in agreement with Judge....some truly laughable stuff regarding Scully.....

[one-eyed]

Phantom form guide: October update
Callum Twomey 
afl.com.au
October 7, 2014 10:34 PM

Given the evenness of this year's pool, we have extended the third Phantom Form Guide of the season from 20 players to 25.

Remember, this is simply a ranking of the players in AFL.com.au's view, and does not take into account which clubs hold certain draft selections.

1. Christian Petracca
2. Patrick McCartin
3. Isaac Heeney .... (Swans' NSW Academy)
4. Angus Brayshaw
5. Peter Wright
6. Darcy Moore ..... (Collingwood F/S)
7. Jarrod Pickett
8. Jayden Laverde
9. Jake Lever
10. Lachie Weller
11. Sam Durdin
12. Paul Ahern
13. Jordan De Goey
14. Liam Duggan
15. Tom Lamb
16. Corey Ellis
17. Caleb Marchbank
18. Jarrod Garlett
19. Hugh Goddard
20. Connor Blakely
21. Jack Steele .... (GWS's NSW Academy)
22. Kyle Langford
23. Ed Vickers-Willis
24. Zaine Cordy
25. Clem Smith

Full profiles: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-10-07/phantom-form-guide-october-edition

[Diocletian]

This why we should at least be trading back into the draft. Would love to get one of Garlett, Langford or Goddard with a second Top 20 pick.

[Yeahright]

scully isnt that bad and would be a significant upgrade on grigg/foley/thomas/newman types

and he sleeps with a large pillow of gold

Significant? Not at all. Slight? Maybe on Newman and Thomas

You reckon grigg is a slightly less good player than Scilly?

Lol

Career to date I believe Grigg has been better, ever so slightly. Now if Scully even applied himself in the slightest he'd put Grigg to shame but alas they are both nothing players

[mightytiges]

I just asked Brett Anderson if he's heard any whispers on whom we're interested in with out first pick and he replied "Laverde/Ahern/Cockatoo/Weller. Laverde first, but will be well gone." He also reckons Laverde or Marchbank will go around Carlton's pick 7.

So it looks like it will be out of Ahern, Cockatoo or Weller.