How did you rate the trade period from the Richmond FC

[Rampstar]

My grade

0/10

Absolutely ZERO, ZILCH, NOTHING!

that's all they deserve

and coming after last years Shaun Hampson fiasco where they deserved to get say

1/10

that makes it 1 out of 20 over 2 years

and that means it was a total and comprehensive failure.

They didn't do any work at all during the last 12 months. ZERO! They will claim they did plenty and they will make up excuses like Trengove failed a medical. Big Deal. Richmonds football staff probably only did about 2% of that, the rest was done by doctors, radiographers etc etc. Its all a load of crap.

2 years running they have failed and that begs the question

What the Fk do we pay them for? Why do members and sponsors put in money? To do what? These people at Richmond aren't good enough. Tiger Fighting Fund - lol. What a joke and the joke is on the members who give there hard earned for people to get big 6 figure salaries to do stuff all.

I wont be a member until these hacks leave the club. If it was good enough for KB its good enough for me. Why should I give these people my hard earned? They don't deserve poo.

 

[Diocletian]

n/a

[(•))(©™]

My grade

0/10

Absolutely ZERO, ZILCH, NOTHING!

that's all they deserve

and coming after last years Shaun Hampson fiasco where they deserved to get say

1/10

that makes it 1 out of 20 over 2 years

and that means it was a total and comprehensive failure.

They didn't do any work at all during the last 12 months. ZERO! They will claim they did plenty and they will make up excuses like Trengove failed a medical. Big Deal. Richmonds football staff probably only did about 2% of that, the rest was done by doctors, radiographers etc etc. Its all a load of crap.

2 years running they have failed and that begs the question

What the Fk do we pay them for? Why do members and sponsors put in money? To do what? These people at Richmond aren't good enough. Tiger Fighting Fund - lol. What a joke and the joke is on the members who give there hard earned for people to get big 6 figure salaries to do stuff all.

I wont be a member until these hacks leave the club. If it was good enough for KB its good enough for me. Why should I give these people my hard earned? They don't deserve poo.

X2

idiot of a club.
Joke of a club.
Total bullshitter of a club.

[Phil Mrakov]

0

[cub]

Not too fussed, not much around. Draft is supposed to be pretty deep this year.
Would like to see us chase a gun though!

[Judge Roughneck]

Not too fussed, not much around. Draft is supposed to be pretty deep this year.
Would like to see us chase a gun though!

Not much around?
 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

10

EFA (Bo impersonator)

[Phil Mrakov]

10

EFA (Bo impersonator)

just waiting for his response 

[Judge Roughneck]

Amazing they didn't trade player/s out for better draft position. More so whe stanley is a pick 20 - Every club has a good young list more or less. We seems to not have a point of difference. going to be hard to be in the flag on the back of picks 50 / 70.  Given the timing of the resigning announcing, I assume Elton dea, Bach , mcdonurs were those put on the table. Not bold or inspiring enough for my liking

[pmac21]

I'm glad it's all over. Goes for too long and Barrett & Wallace really bug me with their interpretations of lists and trades. 

What happened to the days where you woke up and found out you had a new recruit??

[Tiger Tragic]

1/10

lacked imagination.  I give a point for at least not trading for that lemon Trengove and the due diligence done there.

[Yeahright]

My grade

0/10

and coming after last years Shaun Hampson fiasco where they deserved to get say

1/10

This for me shows the ignorance of some people on this forum when it comes to trades (including free agency). All some people want is for them to do anything even if it is to the detriment of the club and trade for the sake of trading. Yes you must look around and see what's on offer and try and get a deal done (who knows whether Richmond did this) but you don't trade just for the sake of it. At least this year we have our draft picks in tact but last year we made a major stuff up and lost our 2nd round pick AND picked up a dud yet they get a higher rating? Please.

This year 3/10 due to no stuff ups
Last year 0/10 for a major stuff up

[Dice]

Let's hope we start our trade period for 2016 over this summer.
RFC officials need to be heading over to Adelaide in the coming months to get Dangerfield to sign up for 2016.
 If they miss him then they go after the next gun free agent. Then head up to Sydney and get a verbal agreement from one of J.Cameron , Treloar , Hoskin-Elliot or Shiel.
 Get proactive and bloody well get it done !

 That's the only way I'll forgive them for the Hampson stuff up and the inactivity of this year.

[Rampstar]

My grade

0/10

and coming after last years Shaun Hampson fiasco where they deserved to get say

1/10

This for me shows the ignorance of some people on this forum when it comes to trades (including free agency). All some people want is for them to do anything even if it is to the detriment of the club and trade for the sake of trading. Yes you must look around and see what's on offer and try and get a deal done (who knows whether Richmond did this) but you don't trade just for the sake of it. At least this year we have our draft picks in tact but last year we made a major stuff up and lost our 2nd round pick AND picked up a dud yet they get a higher rating? Please.

This year 3/10 due to no stuff ups
Last year 0/10 for a major stuff up

I gave them 1/10 last year coz they actually tried something, the result was bad but at least they had a go - not much of a go but a go nevertheless.  This year has resulted in nothing. My grading is actually a grading over 2 years = was 1/20 your grading over 2 years was 3/20. Anyway we cut it, the last two years have been nothing short of an abysmal failure.

[Yeahright]

Yep either way we should be at least trying to do better. Seemed we were never contenders for anyone and if we were mentioned and someone else was, we'd pull out of the race.