Connor Menadue [merged]

[lamington]

I used to think we should play Rance a swingman but after seeing the fall of Harry Taylor I don’t ever want to see that in Rance. Not that Taylor is half the athlete or player Rance is but I think the wing is as far forward he should play

[Assange Tiger 😎]

Geez Geez he's been atrocious everywhere but the backline.

5 time AA FB, keep him there.

[yandb]

Interesting thoughts you would think towner,moore go or on the rookie list there. They have no currency so wouldn't get anything for them.

I think KMAC will stay hed like his chances on the next year I feel be a few pushing for it. Wonder would the tigers think of pushing Baker on the wing with rance coming back ? we even can play stack, graham off it

I prefer Baker back over Short, or forward if there's space. KMac to the wing.

Short to lose his spot to Rance and needs to be defensively coached to replace Houli later.

 

Defensively coached to replace Houli??????????

Short has already passed Houli defensively, how hard is it defensively to play lose man in defence?

[Diocletian]

There are kids running around in Auskick Shortsteps has still yet to pass defensively.....

[one-eyed]

Looks like we will be getting either pick 83 or a late future pick for Menadue.

Freo's picks after the latest proposed Hill deal would be 7, 10, 22, 83.

[yandb]

Why would Freo want Menadue if they are getting Aish

[mightytiges]

Why would Freo want Menadue if they are getting Aish

To replace both Hill and Langdon.

[Andyy]

Only use in pick 83 is to elevate one of our 3 good rookies.

Should ask for pick 22 in exchange for Butler + 38 haha.

[Diocletian]

Basically trading Menadue for one of Stack, Pickett, Chol or Baker...

[taztiger4]

Why would Freo want Menadue if they are getting Aish

Aish will be playing for their AFLW team

[big tone]

Interesting thoughts you would think towner,moore go or on the rookie list there. They have no currency so wouldn't get anything for them.

I think KMAC will stay hed like his chances on the next year I feel be a few pushing for it. Wonder would the tigers think of pushing Baker on the wing with rance coming back ? we even can play stack, graham off it

I prefer Baker back over Short, or forward if there's space. KMac to the wing.

Short to lose his spot to Rance and needs to be defensively coached to replace Houli later.

 

Defensively coached to replace Houli??????????

Short has already passed Houli defensively, how hard is it defensively to play lose man in defence?

I did chuckle at that too.
Houli has his strengths no doubt but defending isn’t high on that list.
I hope Dimma gives him a run on a wing come preseason.... And Rance takes that spot in our backline.

Does it get better than that!

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Don’t mind that thinking BT 

[Andyy]

Interesting thoughts you would think towner,moore go or on the rookie list there. They have no currency so wouldn't get anything for them.

I think KMAC will stay hed like his chances on the next year I feel be a few pushing for it. Wonder would the tigers think of pushing Baker on the wing with rance coming back ? we even can play stack, graham off it

I prefer Baker back over Short, or forward if there's space. KMac to the wing.

Short to lose his spot to Rance and needs to be defensively coached to replace Houli later.

 

Defensively coached to replace Houli??????????

Short has already passed Houli defensively, how hard is it defensively to play lose man in defence?

I did chuckle at that too.
Houli has his strengths no doubt but defending isn’t high on that list.
I hope Dimma gives him a run on a wing come preseason.... And Rance takes that spot in our backline.

Does it better than that!

Never said Houli is a better player defensively.

Just said Short needs to be defensively coached (so he can defend better overall) to replace Houli (as our rebounder)...

...because we don't want another rebounder who defends like Houli does.

Make sense?

Mind you, Houli steps up at the pointy end!

[Diocletian]

Geez Geez he's been atrocious everywhere but the backline.

5 time AA FB, keep him there.

Would still be an upgrade on Bellis on the wing....

Houli has his strengths no doubt but defending isn’t high on that list.
I hope Dimma gives him a run on a wing come preseason.... And Rance takes that spot in our backline.

Does it better than that!

Tipping that's what will most likely happen...

[big tone]

Interesting thoughts you would think towner,moore go or on the rookie list there. They have no currency so wouldn't get anything for them.

I think KMAC will stay hed like his chances on the next year I feel be a few pushing for it. Wonder would the tigers think of pushing Baker on the wing with rance coming back ? we even can play stack, graham off it

I prefer Baker back over Short, or forward if there's space. KMac to the wing.

Short to lose his spot to Rance and needs to be defensively coached to replace Houli later.

 

Defensively coached to replace Houli??????????

Short has already passed Houli defensively, how hard is it defensively to play lose man in defence?

I did chuckle at that too.
Houli has his strengths no doubt but defending isn’t high on that list.
I hope Dimma gives him a run on a wing come preseason.... And Rance takes that spot in our backline.

Does it better than that!

Never said Houli is a better player defensively.

Just said Short needs to be defensively coached (so he can defend better overall) to replace Houli (as our rebounder)...

...because we don't want another rebounder who defends like Houli does.

Make sense?

Mind you, Houli steps up at the pointy end!

Yes mate, it makes sense.

We are in an incredible position as a club at the moment.

With stars like Rance and Stack, and players like Graham and Higgins and evening youngsters like Ross and Bolta to play next year, I have never seen our list or any list in better shape in all my time following footy.

And with our recruiting department killing it of late, I’m sure they will be adding even more top end talent to our list.

Great time to be a Tiger!