Chris Scott sooking thread [merged]

[taztiger4]

In the coaches votes, looks like Chris Scott couldn't help himself and refused to give the 5 votes to any Tiger. Had Kelly ahead of Lynch, Prestia & Houli. Sorry Scotty but the game goes longer than a half  .

Hardwick                                        Scott                               Total

5. Lynch                                  5. Kelly                                9. Lynch
4. Prestia                                 4. Lynch                               8. Kelly
3. Kelly                                    3. Houli                                6. Prestia
2. Houli                                   2. Prestia                              5. Houli
1. Kolodjashnij or Selwood        1. Kolodjashnij or Selwood     1. Kolodjashnij, Selwood

how do you know who voted what ?, was it announced as the above ?

[mightytiges]

In the coaches votes, looks like Chris Scott couldn't help himself and refused to give the 5 votes to any Tiger. Had Kelly ahead of Lynch, Prestia & Houli. Sorry Scotty but the game goes longer than a half  .

Hardwick                                        Scott                               Total

5. Lynch                                  5. Kelly                                9. Lynch
4. Prestia                                 4. Lynch                               8. Kelly
3. Kelly                                    3. Houli                                6. Prestia
2. Houli                                   2. Prestia                              5. Houli
1. Kolodjashnij or Selwood        1. Kolodjashnij or Selwood     1. Kolodjashnij, Selwood

how do you know who voted what ?, was it announced as the above ?

The only combination given the total votes above (link in Geelong game thread). Lynch got one of the '5-vote' so Kelly had to get the other '5-vote'. The rest follows. I can't see Dimma not giving Lynch the 5 votes given what he said about Tom in the post-match presser. Scott also has history in not crediting opposition forwards who kick a bag against Geelong. He dismissed Charlie Cameron and his 5 goals after they played and lost to Brisbane.

[mightytiges]

Lucky Richmond weren't as good as last year, Scotty .

Might have won the Granny by 20 goals instead of 'only' 15  .

[one-eyed]

“They’re not Hawthorn”: Chris Scott’s latest dig at Richmond

By SEN
14 March 2020

Geelong coach Chris Scott believes Richmond’s recent success doesn’t compare to other dominant sides of previous eras.

The Tigers won premierships in 2017 and 2019 – beating Scott’s Cats in last year’s preliminary final - and are favourites to make it a third flag in four years in 2020.

But speaking on Damian Barrett’s In The Game podcast, Scott stoked the fire by saying Hawthorn's trophy-laden years are superior to Richmond's.

The Hawks shocked Geelong in the 2008 Grand Final before winning a three-peat of premierships in 2013, 2014 and 2015.

“We’re really clear, and have been for a long time, on what our deficiencies are. Every team in the comp has deficiencies,” Scott said.

“We’re in an era where Richmond are a really good team and I think West Coast are going to be really strong, Collingwood (also).

“But with the greatest respect to them (Richmond), they’re not Hawthorn in the multiple premiership years in a row, I don’t think.

“I don’t think they’re Geelong, St Kilda or Collingwood through that sort of 2009/10 period either.

“I think it’s a lot more even than that. Everyone has their deficiencies.”

Geelong and Richmond clash in a Friday night blockbuster in Round 9 at the MCG.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2020/03/14/theyre-not-hawthorn-chris-scotts-latest-dig-at-richmond/

[Rampsation]

Jealousy is a curse, this professional finals losing coach is so envious he cant control himself.

[Diocletian]

That Hawthorn side that we used to regularly beat?

[georgies31]

The part about not being the saints or pies lol lost me  .

[Diocletian]

Well he was right there ...they only won one flag between them...

[Knighter]

He’ll go to his grave bagging us. Lost 2 critical finals to us in 3 years has the salty one.

[Francois Jackson]

Wow
What a loser this guy is

Not as good as stkilda ?

[Diocletian]

#RDS

[one-eyed]

https://twitter.com/Tigers_of_Old/status/1238706140415811585

[WilliamPowell]

Thanks for letting me know Chris, appreciate it 

[mightytiges]

We have a 9-2 record against Geelong in finals.

Then add ...

1934
1967
1969
1980
2017
2019

as years we've won the flag after beating Geelong along the way in a final.

No wonder they are bitter after 86 years .

[mightytiges]

Wow
What a loser this guy is

Doesn't he realise he is just saying he sucks as a coach if he can't beat what he claims is an inferior premiership team compared to other eras?

Not as good as stkilda ?

That was the clincher that he is just jealous and bitter.

St Kilda under Lyon had to choke games against top sides and turn them into a grind to try and win them. It worked at Docklands (their home ground) but at the MCG their scoring ability was terrible (except for the rare time they beat up on a bottom side).

2008 ................ (5 games at the MCG)
18.11-119 vs Carl R15  W.............. Carl 11th
12.11-83   vs Coll R19  L
8.13-61     vs Geel QF  L
17.4-101   vs Coll SF    W ............... still only 21 shots.
9.10-64     vs Haw PF   L

2009 ................ (4 games at the MCG)
17.12-114 vs Melb R22 W......... Melb was the wooden spooner.
12.8-80 vs Coll QF        W
9.6-60   vs Dogs PF       W
9.14-68  vs Geel GF      L

2010 ............... (6 games at the MCG)
10.10-70 vs Geel R13   W
6.16-52   vs Coll R16    L
12.11-83 vs Geel QF    W
13.10-88 vs Dogs PF    W
10.8-68   vs Coll GF     D
7.10-52   vs Coll GFR   L

St Kilda's 2008-10 record
Total: 53 wins 21 losses 1 draw .... 71% win rate
MCG:   8 wins 6 losses 1 draw ...... 53%
Finals: 5 wins 4 losses 1 draw ...... 50%   "
GFs:    0 wins 2 losses 1 draw ......  0%   "
No flags.

https://afltables.com/afl/teams/stkilda/season.html

Now compare that to us:

Richmond's 2017-19 record
Total: 56 wins 18 losses .............. 76% win rate
MCG: 40 wins 5 losses ................ 89%
Finals: 7 wins 1 loss .................... 88%     "
GFs:    2 wins 0 losses ................ 100%    "
2 flags.

https://afltables.com/afl/teams/richmond/season.html

It's not even close .

Scott ignoring facts and just deflecting from knowing deep down his Geelong side is on the way down.