Noah Cumberland [merged]

[one-eyed]

Cumberland's stats:

10 disposals (9k, 1h, 6c, 3u, 40% eff.)
2 marks (1 contested mark)
1 tackle
1 inside 50
191 metres gained
5 score involvements
2 goals
3 behinds
71% time on ground

[Andyy]

Gonna sound like a Grinch but I was only half pleased that he managed to get into the right spots.

5 gettable goals and he managed 2.3 crap like this cost us the game

[Rampsation]

Unfortunately he cant do a townsend. Did really little after quarter time. I dont think hes a quality AFL player he'll be a fringe player, play for 2 or 3 clubs rack up 70 or 80 games and tben play at the lower levels.

[camboon]

Iii bite, who would kick more goals as a small forward for Richmond.
Could have kicked another but 2 of the shots were on the boundary , so a stretch
He has been told not to pass it if he is in range as they rate his acuratcy so I don’t know what he is meant do . He has earned the next couple of games imo.

[The Machine]

Iii bite, who would kick more goals as a small forward for Richmond.
Could have kicked another but 2 of the shots were on the boundary , so a stretch
He has been told not to pass it if he is in range as they rate his acuratcy so I don’t know what he is meant do . He has earned the next couple of games imo.

Not sure about the last line. Team first and if he can't do that- bye bye...

[camboon]

I can’t see the non team things he does, he chases, tackles , passes, gives a shepherd and spoils.
From all the games I’ve watched I can’t see the selfish acts unless you want him to pass to players like George who has 3 players on him .  He is likely being  critisised for not handballing over the top in the square so  I’m not buying it.
The club thinks he played a good game for the 3 quarter he was on so he will being picked at least for next week.

[mightytiges]

For completeness, here is Noah.

From 6 shots --> 2 goals, 3 behinds.
 
Q1 8:05 to go


Q1 26:39 min mark: From 25m out ran into an open GOAL!

Q1 28:49 min mark: From goalsquare ran into an open GOAL!

Q2 2:43 to go


Q2 0:30 to go


Q3 18:15 to go

[the claw]

they obviously prefered his scoring output potential  over Rioli's defense.

[WilliamPowell]

they obviously prefered his scoring output potential  over Rioli's defense.

Don't think that's the main reason

Very rarely do they drop debutants after 1 game. And despite being a medi sub previously and that counts as a game, he didn't play that week so really "debuted" last week. Was always going to hold his spot.

With Balta back I'd take Jnr's defensive pressure any day. Noah's defensive pressure last week was almost non existent

[georgies31]

they obviously prefered his scoring output potential  over Rioli's defense.

Don't think that's the main reason

Very rarely do they drop debutants after 1 game. And despite being a medi sub previously and that counts as a game, he didn't play that week so really "debuted" last week. Was always going to hold his spot.

With Balta back I'd take Jnr's defensive pressure any day. Noah's defensive pressure last week was almost non existent

The fact is Cumberland had 2 pressure acts and 1 less tackle than George in his first game of afl footy to much made of his defensive workrate.

[camboon]

Tend to agree , for his 1st game  I thought  he did well. If you look at 1st game of many of our current better players some may not have performed as well

[camboon]

2nd game , was even better, one of two positives

[Willy]

He was great.

[Broadsword]

Just hope it's not a Dean Polo beginning.

[Andyy]

Could still kick better for goal but hard to complain after 5.7 in two games.