Shane Edwards [merged]

[Gigantor]

very poor game I thought by titch/Must be getting close to spending time in the 2s

[Jackstar is back!!!]

After watching the replay for the 2nd time grrrrr
His handball which caused the turnover which caused the winning goal is enough
If he gets a game next week surely proves he is washing no only Dimmas car but Peggy..Brendan's .and Chocos cars

[flea03]

what about not 1 not 2 but 3 easy goals cotchin missed

if he just kicked one more we would have won,,, he missed all 3 .  NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR A SO CALLED GUN

[Mr Magic]

King will go before Edwards but Shane is on notice.

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Cotchin was 35 metres out running into an open goal and tries to pass to Jackson
WTF
Guy in the Herald Sun gives him 3 votes
Obviously wasn't at the game

[Smokey]

Cotchin was 35 metres out running into an open goal and tries to pass to Jackson
WTF

The neighbours thought a murder had been committed when I reacted a tad loudly at that.  I just couldn't believe what he had done and thought it showed a complete lack of confidence in his own ability.  The whole team just seems to be playing like it has no faith in itself any more; the refusal to take risk, the refusal to run forward, the refusal to take ownership of a play, and Cotchin seems to be as affected as anyone.

[Rampstar]

trade him at the end of the year. we wont get much be he aint worth much anyway on the trade market.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

trade him at the end of the year. we wont get much be he aint worth much anyway on the trade market.

Adelaide will have him. Get a Tambling deal done Richmond!

[WA Tiger]

trade him at the end of the year. we wont get much be he aint worth much anyway on the trade market.

Free agent!

[Judge Roughneck]

He is no ablett

But is he the first to go?

Not sure he worse than say Grigg pettard houli etc

[WA Tiger]

He is no ablett

But is he the first to go?

Not sure he worse than say Grigg pettard houli etc

He has bee at the club for 8 years and nothings changed, Houli and Grigg just need a kick in the arse.

[Rampstar]

trade him at the end of the year. we wont get much be he aint worth much anyway on the trade market.

Free agent!

then he can pee off ... he's not doing anything for us anyway

[Judge Roughneck]

He's not older than the Melbourne Carlton Essendon rejects

Same age group

Houli petard Grigg have also been in the system around a decade

[tony_montana]

Cotchin was 35 metres out running into an open goal and tries to pass to Jackson
WTF

The neighbours thought a murder had been committed when I reacted a tad loudly at that.  I just couldn't believe what he had done and thought it showed a complete lack of confidence in his own ability.  The whole team just seems to be playing like it has no faith in itself any more; the refusal to take risk, the refusal to run forward, the refusal to take ownership of a play, and Cotchin seems to be as affected as anyone.

Agree and this was massively exposed in the elim final last year. People went on and on about Houli's decision to pass from 60 instead of run a bit further and take a shot, but there were actually about another 5-6 other glaring incidents where players passed it off rather than have a ping from 50 including martin a couple of times and theres no one Id rather than him having a shot from there. Think the mindset of the whole team is and has been slightly wrong for a while, there is no killer instinct. We need to be more ruthless and whilst its great they want to bring each other into the game, sometimes it takes more courage for players to put their hand up to take on the responsibility (for better or worse).

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Correct
Jake King did from outside 50 in the 3rd quarter