Jack Riewoldt - Triple Coleman medallist [merged]

[FNM]

Can he play in defence?
Does some good things, but his kicking for goal for two years has let him and the team down
To give him confidence, play him down back?

[jackstar is back again]

Good move 
Although the coach doesnt make any changes during the game it seems
 

[FNM]

I honestly think he's playing scared down there and become a real head case when he has a shot on goal.
Take him totally away from it and give him some space

[TigerTimeII]

he is a fwd, his kicking for goal last week was good, had an off nite tonite so what

he isnt the problem
nor is edwards, he was good tonite, and he was brave

ok here we go

jackson, is pathetic, sure a workhorse but cant kick should not play again
nahas, no good, goodbye
hislop, yes his tough but see jackosn
mitch farmer the past 2 weeks has shown he is just a good praccy match player not up to it
simmonds stuff off


ok we had many positives, dont look at he score board

thursty owned hall tonite

mguane was great
so was edwards
tambling is getting there was great in the congestion and packs
cotch martin nason will be guns for us and played well tonite
deledio has slipped but will be ok

our biggest worry and has been 4 yrs, we have no real system on kickouts and cant get out of defence with ease

[jackstar is back again]

Tambling was terrible X, he had 6 kicks

[TigerTimeII]

he was bashed from pillar to post in close, but he kept at it

he had a slow start last yr, im not worried about him or deledio, deledio had many touches but wasnht as good as hardwick says, cotchin and martin were our best mids and edwards was pretty damn good today i reckon

[Hellenic Tiger]

I would like to know Riewoldt's career conversion rate.
I would like to know the numbers of his conversion for 2007-08 combined against his 2009 to present. I am of the belief his conversion was better in his first two years of his career.

[FNM]

Tambling was terrible X, he had 6 kicks

Agree, he's going backwards again
Because of the salary cap and having to pay 95% of it, I'd hate to think what Tambo, as one of our experienced??? players, is on 
Whatever it is, he's not earning it 

[Danog]

I thought Tambling was good in the 1st and for parts in the 4th.  Didn't even see him otherwise.

[TigerLand]

Spot on X.

Really well said

[TigerTimeII]

Spot on X.

Really well said

cheers

some ppl just watch him play with biased eyes with preconceived judgement

he was not that bad tonite. least he puts his body in

[TigerLand]

Thought we all had a crack, even the guys that weren't up to it. Harsh reality that some have an enormous way to go but you can't ask much more from the lads they had a dip. You can only ask them to have a crack and run hard and don't back away, as bad as some of the skill errors were it's ability and polish that was the issue today not effort.

They'll improve in time just a way off it.

[Chuck17]

Jack has been developing Ok in the last few years.  Needs one big key forward to take the heat off him thats all.

[tony_montana]

nothing wrong with Jack imo,  get the poor bugger some help and structure up there

[Smokey]

nothing wrong with Jack imo,  get the poor bugger some help and structure up there

Yep, he would have gone home last night with a total understanding of what Richo went through all his career.