Carlton-Judd threads [merged]

[one-eyed]

This from Nick's Magpie forum 

Fraser and someone like Holland or Lonie to Richmond for their first round

[Mr Magic]

Caro is full of poo.

Don't believe a word of it.

[rogerd3]

This from Nick's Magpie forum 

Fraser and someone like Holland or Lonie to Richmond for their first round

they are dreamers those woodsmen, i would say no, no, and no.

[wayne]

This from Nick's Magpie forum 

Fraser and someone like Holland or Lonie to Richmond for their first round

OMGZzzZ!!1wtfbbq!!!1111!eftpos!!!1!one!11 lets do it yeah, we get 2 awesum playerzzz and they will only get one!!1!1! 

[mightytiges]

However unlikely it is ridiculous to say we are out of the race for Judd as we have the the 1st pick in the PSD.

Remember Lockett chose us his preferred club when he wanted to leave the Saints at the end of 1994. St Kilda wanted the like of Campbell, Knights and even Richo which we refused. Lockett then heads to wooden spooner Sydney and the Saints only end up with Robert Neill (yes who?) and a few draft picks.

From memory wooden spooner St Kilda wasn't Aaron Hamill's choice. Carlton let him go to the "rabble" when Hamill wanted out of the Blues.

Then there's the Nick Stevens scenario:

The Pies want Stevens.
Stevens nominates the Pies as his preferred option.
Stevens' club (Port) refuses to deal with Pies.
Stevens ends up at the wooden spooner via PSD.

Now substitute Judd's name for Nick Stevens in the above

The Pies want Judd.
Judd nominates the Pies as his preferred option.
Judd's club (West Coast) refuses to deal with Pies.
Judd ends up at the wooden spooner via PSD

   

[mightytiges]

If the Club even considers that Fraser trade then the Punt Rd might as well close down and everyone inside it sacked.

In any case why would we want to help another club get Judd when we have first pick in the PSD. It's in our interests for trade week to be an utter non-event as far as out of contract players go. Shake the tree by all means but we're not a charity.

[wayne]

However unlikely it is ridiculous to say we are out of the race for Judd as we have the the 1st pick in the PSD.

Remember Lockett chose us his preferred club when he wanted to leave the Saints at the end of 1994. St Kilda wanted the like of Campbell, Knights and even Richo which we refused. Lockett then heads to wooden spooner Sydney and the Saints only end up with Robert Neill (yes who?) and a few draft picks.

From memory wooden spooner St Kilda wasn't Aaron Hamill's choice. Carlton let him go to the "rabble" when Hamill wanted out of the Blues.

Then there's the Nick Stevens scenario:

The Pies want Stevens.
Stevens nominates the Pies as his preferred option.
Stevens' club (Port) refuses to deal with Pies.
Stevens ends up at the wooden spooner via PSD.

Now substitute Judd's name for Nick Stevens in the above

The Pies want Judd.
Judd nominates the Pies as his preferred option.
Judd's club (West Coast) refuses to deal with Pies.
Judd ends up at the wooden spooner via PSD

   

Could see it happening. The Pies have a habit of totally over-estimating their players worth. Rusling anyone . From memory Port wanted Didak (back when he had not shown much) and the Pies didn't want to deal.

They'd offer something like Rusling and their first round pick to the Eagles.

[wayne]

What I would want for pick 2 scenarios

Carlton
West Coast might want pick 2 and 3 for Judd
What I want - Carlton pick 1

Collingwood
They need pick 2 in my opinion
What I want - Pendlebury and Reid

Essendon
Pick 2 and 6 for Judd
What I want - Pick 6  and Gumbleton

Hawthorn
What I want - Hodge

Melbourne
Pick 2 and 4 for Judd
What I want - Nathan Jones and Brock McLean

St Kilda
Pick 2 and 9 for Judd
What I want - Armitage and Dal Santo

Kangaroos
Unlikely to get him
What I want - Hamish McIntosh and Lachlan Hansen

All unrealistic, but we can afford to be 

[mightytiges]

From SEN:

Richo is prepared to take a paycut to have Judd at Richmond.

No word as yet from us on whether we are in or out as far as Judd goes so so much for Caro's spiel last night  .

[rogerd3]

its all hearsay a.t.m. where the hell judd goes, at least it could make for an interesting trade period for a change.

hell the guy probably doesnt even know himself.

gotta love these so-called reporters they are trying to out do each other with the big scoop on where he is going, its gonna come down to who wants him the most and what they are willing to trade for him.

now whats this about mcclean wanting out of the demons?

[mightytiges]

What I would want for pick 2 scenarios

Carlton
West Coast might want pick 2 and 3 for Judd
What I want - Carlton pick 1

If the Blues won't give pick 1 to the Eagles for Judd then they definitely wouldn't give it us in a trade. Screw them anyway lol.

Collingwood
They need pick 2 in my opinion
What I want - Pendlebury and Reid

Not bad but your other options are better and it's the Pies so screw them too  .

Essendon
Pick 2 and 6 for Judd
What I want - Pick 6  and Gumbleton

Change Gumbleton to Ryder (rumour is Gumbleton is homesick). Add Rance with pick 6 and our spine problems would be basically sorted out.

Hawthorn
What I want - Hodge

LOL. Love the bias our way in these wayne .

Melbourne
Pick 2 and 4 for Judd
What I want - Nathan Jones and Brock McLean

See above.

St Kilda
Pick 2 and 9 for Judd
What I want - Armitage and Dal Santo

Dal Santo is a receiver. Not what we need.

Kangaroos
Unlikely to get him
What I want - Hamish McIntosh and Lachlan Hansen

Good for us tall wise but the Gold Coast option will turn Judd off North.

All unrealistic, but we can afford to be 

Yep just a touch unrealistic  but you're right wayne. Let's shake that tree  .

[wayne]

its all hearsay a.t.m. where the hell judd goes, at least it could make for an interesting trade period for a change.

hell the guy probably doesnt even know himself.

gotta love these so-called reporters they are trying to out do each other with the big scoop on where he is going, its gonna come down to who wants him the most and what they are willing to trade for him.

now whats this about mcclean wanting out of the demons?

I'm listening, tell me about McLean??

[mightytiges]

its all hearsay a.t.m. where the hell judd goes, at least it could make for an interesting trade period for a change.

hell the guy probably doesnt even know himself.

gotta love these so-called reporters they are trying to out do each other with the big scoop on where he is going, its gonna come down to who wants him the most and what they are willing to trade for him.

now whats this about mcclean wanting out of the demons?

I don't care who it is as long as some quality comes our way via the PSD  . About time we got a lucky break (excuse the pun). Not just another Knobel  .

[wayne]

Was McLean a Richmond supporter?

[Rodgerramjet]

Caro says Judd doesn't want to go to Richmond. He's use to good facilities so that ruled us and the Roos out.

4 clubs shortlisted - Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon and Melbourne in it.

Carey said our pick 2 for Josh Fraser and another player is rumoured 

Cary is an absolute moron pick 2 does not equate to Josh Fraser, Fraser is actually a very big disappointment ability and injury wise quite frankly.