Media articles - Cats dish out 72-point hiding to Tigers

[WilliamPowell]

Just spoken to an independant ""observer"" at the game.. Said that Richmond were a rabble and Geelong should have won by a lot more.
Game plan was non-existent and players were arguing with each other.
Not good!

 

Independant that's very funny

[Little Jackie]

Just spoken to an independant ""observer"" at the game.. Said that Richmond were a rabble and Geelong should have won by a lot more.
Game plan was non-existent and players were arguing with each other.
Not good!

 

Independant that's very funny

Its not very funny actually.
The person was there in an offical compacity

[WilliamPowell]

Its not very funny actually.
The person was there in an offical compacity

Jack it is funny ... From where I am sitting at least it is... and I'll explain why

Where were your independant observers the last 2 weeks when we won  ??? Deafly silent it would seem

It seems you only quote them when they independantly report the bad, never hear a word when there maybe something good and the best example has to be the Sydeny game (who had a very strong side in BTW) but we hear nothing ...

So as a result of this lop sided "independant observing" I just have to laugh because it is so blatantly biased it is funny

[WilliamPowell]

an umpire.
And he didnt umpire the other games

Don't care who he is or what he does.....point is we only hear about these "observers" when we lose not when we win

Fact is (I had to throw it in somewhere ) is that when you only chose to use info when it is in the negative the argument doesn't carry as much weight. Why? Because it can only be viewed as being biased not balanced and lacks credibility.... which I find very funny indeed.

[Little Jackie]

Oh,  did have feedback against Melb, the dees were disgraceful

[WilliamPowell]

Oh,  did have feedback against Melb, the dees were disgraceful

And Richmond were......

That's the point Jack....

Richmond win.. there's nothing from you apart from the Dees were disgraceful....

What about the game against Sydney ??? Let me guess the Swans were disgraceful

[Little Jackie]

Swans played ok.
What was of interest that they didnt push players back as they usually do.
And they didnt rotate there high forwards through the corridor.
Can tell you that as I have a tape of the game

[WilliamPowell]

Swans played ok.
What was of interest that they didnt push players back as they usually do.
And they didnt rotate there high forwards through the corridor.
Can tell you that as I have a tape of the game

Yes great not interested in the Sawns what about the Tigers Jack ???

You have no hesitation in putting the boots in when they lose how about something about them when they win.. I would have thought they would have had to have done something right or did the Swans tank 

Were there any positives in that game 

[Little Jackie]

Yep  there was.
Thought Newman Tambling and King were good.
Jordon McMahon was terrible.
best game from Tambling for ages, although he will need to put three or four games together and to take guys on.
They actually experiemented with a few players which was good( for once)

[rogerd3]

Just spoken to an independant ""observer"" at the game.. Said that Richmond were a rabble and Geelong should have won by a lot more.
Game plan was non-existent and players were arguing with each other.
Not good!

ah Jackstar you are so transparent it isnt funny, you and your comments always pop up on cue.
well from my sources within the club and the playing group, as i was at the game on friday i can assure you there wasnt any arguing.

you independant observer perhaps likes to fabricate things. , just to get a response from certain people.

[WilliamPowell]

Yep  there was.
Thought Newman Tambling and King were good.
Jordon McMahon was terrible.
best game from Tambling for ages, although he will need to put three or four games together and to take guys on.
They actually experiemented with a few players which was good( for once)

So why has it taken 2 weeks to get you to say something ???

As I said a couple of posts back you have absolutely no hesitation, none in putting the boots in when they lose but when something goes right you disappear....

[Little Jackie]

Just spoken to an independant ""observer"" at the game.. Said that Richmond were a rabble and Geelong should have won by a lot more.
Game plan was non-existent and players were arguing with each other.
Not good!

ah Jackstar you are so transparent it isnt funny, you and your comments always pop up on cue.
well from my sources within the club and the playing group, as i was at the game on friday i can assure you there wasnt any arguing.

you independant observer perhaps likes to fabricate things. , just to get a response from certain people.

Rubbish, can tell you fact that Richo gave 2 of the best sprays ever heard.

[Little Jackie]

Yep  there was.
Thought Newman Tambling and King were good.
Jordon McMahon was terrible.
best game from Tambling for ages, although he will need to put three or four games together and to take guys on.
They actually experiemented with a few players which was good( for once)

So why has it taken 2 weeks to get you to say something ???

As I said a couple of posts back you have absolutely no hesitation, none in putting the boots in when they lose but when something goes right you disappear....

Why you ask
I was reporting on the swans, not RICHMOND!

[rogerd3]

Just spoken to an independant ""observer"" at the game.. Said that Richmond were a rabble and Geelong should have won by a lot more.
Game plan was non-existent and players were arguing with each other.
Not good!

ah Jackstar you are so transparent it isnt funny, you and your comments always pop up on cue.
well from my sources within the club and the playing group, as i was at the game on friday i can assure you there wasnt any arguing.

you independant observer perhaps likes to fabricate things. , just to get a response from certain people.

Rubbish, can tell you fact that Richo gave 2 of the best sprays ever heard.

FACT...when has the great lug never done what you stated on the previous thread, if thats the best your "independant observer" can throw up then then he aint seen mnay of richo's games.

you and your tired old 33's need a new needle.

[Little Jackie]

I will buy a new needle as long as I can buy you a new wooden spoon