One thing about Joel is he can certainly polarise the masses.
Serious answer I'll give him a high six 7/10 not a low 8.
Can't stand the stop and marshall the troops thing when in my opinion it does not need to be done.
Sometime it does and all teams do it, just don't like it and he and sugar moreso do it too much.
I spew when he gives away free points also, just don't find it a proper mentality of 'give them nothing'!
Believe his laconic way is just the way he is, a perfect example yesterday when he took on 3 dees in the middle of the G and looked like he was going in slow mo, but he was just too good and drove us into attack. He is a natural footballer and can get away with it most of the time.
Not that the Dees are much competition, actually they are total krape (so are their supporters for that matter)
Anyway like I said a 7 and a keeper for next year.