Gourdis, Cartledge, Collard and Howat gone / List lodgement (Friday 2pm)

[one-eyed]

Friday, October 31 (2pm) -- Club List Lodgement List 1 - maximum 35 players, rookie promotion, retained rookies, scholarship player transfer and international scholarship.


The club must be close to making their final delistings public.

[mightytiges]

Guessing Howat, Silvester and Cartledge are gone and it's whether Collard remains a rookie. Unless more go from the senior list we'll have 9-10 new Tigers by the start of next year (4 senior listed players and 5-6 rookies).

[Chuck17]

Guessing Howat, Silvester and Cartledge are gone and it's whether Collard remains a rookie. Unless more go from the senior list we'll have 9-10 new Tigers by the start of next year (4 senior listed players and 5-6 rookies).

How come Cartledge MT?

[richmondrules]

We would need to delist another senior to keep him since he is too old for the rookie list this year.

[Chuck17]

We would need to delist another senior to keep him since he is too old for the rookie list this year.

I understand that RROFO my query was more on why MT thinks Cartledge would be the one to be delisted.

Given our ruck problem just a curiosity question on why not promote him and delist someone else, eg Pettifer

[Stripes]

I will be interested to see if the either of the Petts or Collards rumours prove true. We should know by tomorrow.

I think Cartledge will stay unless we believe we have a good chance of securing a quality ruckman in this draft.

Stripes

[mightytiges]

Guessing Howat, Silvester and Cartledge are gone and it's whether Collard remains a rookie. Unless more go from the senior list we'll have 9-10 new Tigers by the start of next year (4 senior listed players and 5-6 rookies).

How come Cartledge MT?

Just a feeling. We have young ruckman Fabian Deluca training with us who is still young enough to be a rookie option whereas as mentioned Cartledge would have to be promoted to the senior list and in place of another delisting. From a financial point of view in regard to our TPP it would be cheaper to delist Cartledge than a Pettifer who we would still need to pay as far as his rehab goes (so you might as well keep him on the list).

[Stripes]

Guessing Howat, Silvester and Cartledge are gone and it's whether Collard remains a rookie. Unless more go from the senior list we'll have 9-10 new Tigers by the start of next year (4 senior listed players and 5-6 rookies).

How come Cartledge MT?

Just a feeling. We have young ruckman Fabian Deluca training with us who is still young enough to be a rookie option whereas as mentioned Cartledge would have to be promoted to the senior list and in place of another delisting. From a financial point of view in regard to our TPP it would be cheaper to delist Cartledge than a Pettifer who we would still need to pay as far as his rehab goes (so you might as well keep him on the list).

That's a good call assuming no other clubs pick Deluca up before us. If they do and we have already delisted Cartledge and have not been able to draft a quality ruckman we will be up that proverbial creek which no paddle is going to help us out of!

I hope we pick up Deluca, elevate Cartledge and delist Petts.

Stripes

[one-eyed]

The number of list changes so far for each club. Tiges have the equal fewest but rookie changes will boost it higher.

Port          12
Fremantle 11
Brisbane    9
Essendon   9
St Kilda      9
Adelaide     7
Coll'wood   7
North         7
Carlton      6
Melbourne  6
Sydney      6
Geelong     5
Hawthorn   5
Eagles        5
Richmond   4
Bulldogs     4

[mightytiges]

Guessing Howat, Silvester and Cartledge are gone and it's whether Collard remains a rookie. Unless more go from the senior list we'll have 9-10 new Tigers by the start of next year (4 senior listed players and 5-6 rookies).

How come Cartledge MT?

Just a feeling. We have young ruckman Fabian Deluca training with us who is still young enough to be a rookie option whereas as mentioned Cartledge would have to be promoted to the senior list and in place of another delisting. From a financial point of view in regard to our TPP it would be cheaper to delist Cartledge than a Pettifer who we would still need to pay as far as his rehab goes (so you might as well keep him on the list).

That's a good call assuming no other clubs pick Deluca up before us. If they do and we have already delisted Cartledge and have not been able to draft a quality ruckman we will be up that proverbial creek which no paddle is going to help us out of!

I hope we pick up Deluca, elevate Cartledge and delist Petts.

Stripes

True it's a risk but do we want two fringe ruckmen on our senior list though who most likely would be delisted at the end of next year so we'd be back to square one anyway?

I know Patto and Gus are still a long way from being up to where we need them to be (Putt has only had one year) but Cartledge and Deluca haven't set the world on fire either in their footy careers to date at AFL level.

[tigersalive]

Rance emerged as the winner of the beach challenge, followed by Cameron Howat, Andrew Collins, Cotchin and White.

WTF? WHAT? HUH? 

Just doing one last drill before the chop?

[mightytiges]

Rance emerged as the winner of the beach challenge, followed by Cameron Howat, Andrew Collins, Cotchin and White.

WTF? WHAT? HUH? 

Just doing one last drill before the chop?

Surely we are not seriously considering promoting Cam to the senior list ??? 

[Chuck17]

Rance emerged as the winner of the beach challenge, followed by Cameron Howat, Andrew Collins, Cotchin and White.

WTF? WHAT? HUH? 

Just doing one last drill before the chop?

Surely we are not seriously considering promoting Cam to the senior list ??? 

You wouldn't think so but we will see soon, I'm surprised St Kilda didn't want him to go with their other SOFA's.

To trade him dont we have to promote him to the senior list, maybe it is all part of the strategy to offload him to the Ainters

[tigersalive]

I hope we havent forgot about this.   

[mightytiges]

I hope we havent forgot about this.   

The dog ate it lol

As Blackboard would say "hurry up!"