State of Umpiring [merged]

[Chuck17]

I don’t know about that delightful young lass that Dusty gave a cuddle to but I sure feel violated by the umpires tonight

[Broadsword]

 

I don’t know about that delightful young lass that Dusty gave a cuddle to but I sure feel violated by the umpires tonight

[TigerLand]

Been disgusting tonight.

The 50m for not hearing stand call when walking backwards.
The 50m not allowed Baker to NOT take advantage
The non holding the ball to Andrews in our F50.
The original non 50 to us then central ump called it
Missed jumper pull on Dusty.
Random ruck free kicks against Miller.

Just stinkers.

[Owl]

Just the one jumper pull on dusty, dude was all over him like sex pest in a Thai bar

[Andyy]

They gave us plenty of good frees at the end and evened it up.

Not their fault we lost. Not ARC fault we lost.

Lynch needs to nail that goal. Rioli and Baker need to find a team mate and not turn it over. Backline needs to kill that Daniher ball.

All stuffing night nobody playing close on Neale or standing in front of him.

[Andyy]

Let's talk about the ARC although we didn't lose because of it.

Why is it that Tennis and Cricket can track a balls flight path but we can't? Is it because wind etc plays a factor more?

F1 slow mo shows debris coming off tyres you can see individual specs of it but in the AFL we can't see if a finger or two bend off a ball. It's pathetic.

[Owl]

The umps were poo, broke momentum when we started getting a run on,especially that free kick, play on, bs fiasco, wtf was that?  Idiocy.  Our own screw ups are for the other thread, this is the umpires bashing therapy room

[TigerLand]

Let's talk about the ARC although we didn't lose because of it.

Why is it that Tennis and Cricket can track a balls flight path but we can't? Is it because wind etc plays a factor more?

F1 slow mo shows debris coming off tyres you can see individual specs of it but in the AFL we can't see if a finger or two bend off a ball. It's pathetic.

Agree with this 100%.

I believe it's a time thing. The super slow mo I believe takes a long time to render.

Ball tracking no idea why we can't have that.

[Damo]

Let's talk about the ARC although we didn't lose because of it.

Why is it that Tennis and Cricket can track a balls flight path but we can't? Is it because wind etc plays a factor more?

F1 slow mo shows debris coming off tyres you can see individual specs of it but in the AFL we can't see if a finger or two bend off a ball. It's pathetic.

Agree with this 100%.

I believe it's a time thing. The super slow mo I believe takes a long time to render.

Ball tracking no idea why we can't have that.

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

[Fluffy Tiger]

I have never seen a umpires call of a goal overruled from those sort of camera shots. He may of missed it but where is the "undisputable" evedince. I don't see it.

[one-eyed]

[one-eyed]

AFL position re goal review

‘The arc reviewed all the camera angles and its viewed as a definitive behind. The correct call was made.’

11:46 PM · Sep 1, 2022

https://twitter.com/TomBrowne7/status/1565335220941131780

[Tigeritis™©®]

How far is that footage?

Depth perception on a 2D screen / like the Toyota logo that’s looks great on tv but at the ground looks squished together. Why?

The angles they showed was vision from the other side of the ground or at least 150 metres away. You’d need at a minimum an angle from either the goal line but to get proper perspective or from the other goal post.

From each angle they showed it was impossible to see when the ball was in relation to the actual goal line.

Ridiculous perspective.

There’s no way of knowing how far it’s over the goal line or not from that angle.
It could’ve been 2 metres or 2 inches either side of it but impossible to know without a view from the actual goal line itself so we all can see if it past the goal line or was right on it.

The goal umpire had perfect position and actually called it a goal from his position under the post looking up.

Unless the vision showed otherwise then how can it the goal umpires decision be overruled?

The vision must be MORE decisive which it clearly wasn’t.

That isn’t why we lost though. We lost because we can’t defend or pressure or tackle like we used to.

[one-eyed]

Here's the vision of Lynch's shot and the overrule:

https://www.afl.com.au/video/833617/huge-drama-as-goal-review-overrules-late-lynch-shot



Tom Browne added after the game that the ARC reviewer also goes by the player's reaction. That shouldn't be the case otherwise you'll get players from now on deliberately celebrating to try and fool the umps.

[georgies31]

Here's the vision of Lynch's shot and the overrule:

https://www.afl.com.au/video/833617/huge-drama-as-goal-review-overrules-late-lynch-shot



Tom Browne added after the game that the ARC reviewer also goes by the player's reaction. That shouldn't be the case otherwise you'll get players from now on deliberately celebrating to try and fool the umps.

Gez what was Lynch thinking mate a simple shot into the impossible silly.