Richmond interested in Dylan Shiel [merged]

[scjhammo]

greenwood hard to say didn't watch many if any north games so cant really comment.... Shields would be great he is hard nut powerful left foot and can run al day last year I remember we were going to land that hoskin Elliott form GWS but nothing he had a break out year....
Higgins wouldn't touch with a ten foot pole he plays what 8-10 games a year if lucky has an awesome pre season and breaks down....

[tony_montana]

All the talk is Shiels isnt going anywhere..

North are going hard to try and pinch a premiership in the next year or 2 (lol) Waite is a done deal and strong mail that Higgins is close too. I hope they get them both - that will squeeze out Greenwood $$ wise, the offer is in the $200's and he wants more. North have an abundance of strong inside mids(Swallow, Cunnington and Zieball) so as much as they like Greenwood, he's not a major loss if he walks and they get reasonable compensation for him

What do people think is a fair offer? I reckon a pick around 20 is fair, our first rounder is too much, our second rounder is not enough.

[yellowandback]

All the talk is Shiels isnt going anywhere..

North are going hard to try and pinch a premiership in the next year or 2 (lol) Waite is a done deal and strong mail that Higgins is close too. I hope they get them both - that will squeeze out Greenwood $$ wise, the offer is in the $200's and he wants more. North have an abundance of strong inside mids(Swallow, Cunnington and Zieball) so as much as they like Greenwood, he's not a major loss if he walks and they get reasonable compensation for him

What do people think is a fair offer? I reckon a pick around 20 is fair, our first rounder is too much, our second rounder is not enough.

Probably fair, would be great to off load Vickery to the Bulldogs for their 2nd rounder - keep that but give our second round pick for Greenwood.
So
Out
Vickery, pick 27-29
In
Greenwood, pick 21-23

[Judge Roughneck]

All the talk is Shiels isnt going anywhere..

North are going hard to try and pinch a premiership in the next year or 2 (lol) Waite is a done deal and strong mail that Higgins is close too. I hope they get them both - that will squeeze out Greenwood $$ wise, the offer is in the $200's and he wants more. North have an abundance of strong inside mids(Swallow, Cunnington and Zieball) so as much as they like Greenwood, he's not a major loss if he walks and they get reasonable compensation for him

What do people think is a fair offer? I reckon a pick around 20 is fair, our first rounder is too much, our second rounder is not enough.

Probably fair, would be great to off load Vickery to the Bulldogs for their 2nd rounder - keep that but give our second round pick for Greenwood.
So
Out
Vickery, pick 27-29
In
Greenwood, pick 21-23

Ouch

[Francois Jackson]

green who? Isn't he slow? and also only had a good year when his contract was up.

he is out contract is he not? so make him an offer to take in the PSD and keep all our picks for Shiel.

Obtaining second round picks shouldn't be an option for the RFC because 95% of our picks are wrong so we might as well throw it down the toilet.

[Judge Roughneck]

hasn't he been the whipping boy at north for three years now

[Francois Jackson]

Its pretty funny one breakout year and we are all over him like a wet suit but then when our players have a descent years  like Nahas, Edwards, Grigg, most on here are like yeah na good depth players must keep.

Please

[tony_montana]

He wins his own football, is a hard in and under type, would take heaps of pressure off cotch and Miles and wouldnt cost an arm and a leg. Bit of a no brainer if he's available.

[Andyy]

Evidently a lot of you didn't watch many north games this year.

Bloke is a contested ball winner. Need players like him now that Jackson is gone.

[tiga]

I once heard Bruce say in commentary "Greeenwoood....cleverrrrr" so we must get him purely based on this. 

[Chuck17]

I once heard Bruce say in commentary "Greeenwoood....cleverrrrr" so we must get him purely based on this. 

x 2 Must have

[big tone]

He wins his own football, is a hard in and under type, would take heaps of pressure off cotch and Miles and wouldnt cost an arm and a leg. Bit of a no brainer if he's available.

He isn't worth our second rounder IMO. Not even close. And more to the point he isn't worth $350K.
Straight swap for Batch, or Bacha.

[tony_montana]

He wins his own football, is a hard in and under type, would take heaps of pressure off cotch and Miles and wouldnt cost an arm and a leg. Bit of a no brainer if he's available.

He isn't worth our second rounder IMO. Not even close. And more to the point he isn't worth $350K.
Straight swap for Batch, or Bacha.

lol pee-er bt

[Diocletian]

Martin's best mate at the club Edwards has just been delisted, Martin's off contract next year and Greenwood is another of Martin's good mates but also a half-decent player who fills a specific need and is off contract. No surprise we'd be into him.

[rogerd3]

So some are get excited over Greenwood after one half decent year.
I wouldn't be giving up much for him.

I'm sure the red carpet is been saved for clangerfields arrival.