One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on February 06, 2008, 03:09:37 AM
-
Richmond is in an excellent position on the injury front, with only No. 2 draft pick Trent Cotchin out long-term.
The midfielder is still recovering from a broken ankle suffered in the TAC Cup finals.
Link (http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,23166845%255E19742,00.html)
On BF they are saying Cotch is 9 weeks away.
Trent is yet to fully run, end of this week, and is expected to spend 4 weeks running before contact and is expected to spend another 5 weeks of contact before being considered available for AFL selection.
source - family, captain and dr. pink
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?s=69c16eaa3126f065ebf0c66e89020f14&p=10018224&postcount=1
-
9 weeks still?!
Sheesh that's some injury to the young lad.
Hope he doesn't have ongoing concerns.
-
As long as Cotchin is 100% right when he finally plays then it doesn't matter if that's 9 weeks away. Mid-April still gives him most of the season to play.
-
From the Age
Trent Cotchin is recovering from the broken ankle that ruined his pre-season, while Angus Graham (ankle) also is likely to miss the start of the pre-season competition. Luke McGuane, according to Bowden, is also in doubt to line up against St Kilda next week.
"Trent's had a little bit of trouble with his ankle (and) subsequently with his Achilles, so not going great," Bowden said.
"He has good days and bad days, so I'd say he won't play (in the NAB Cup), barring a miracle."
Link (http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/rainstorm-dampens-tigers-camp-but-not-desire/2008/02/05/1202090421632.html)
-
as he is an investment in the future no need to rush him into the action, unlike some other club who shelled out millions for his signature.
-
As long as Cotchin is 100% right when he finally plays then it doesn't matter if that's 9 weeks away. Mid-April still gives him most of the season to play.
Yes, though he must have done bugger all in pre-season, so he'd be a chance to play some senior games late in the season at best.
-
yes ... no need to rush Cotchin at all ... just get his ankle 100% ...
i don't think he needs to do any skills or ball work ...
already made player ... just needs to put on the muscle like all 17 year olds ...
-
Well Cotchin is at least kicking the footy up in Echuca...
(http://www.gspimages.com.au/images/thumbs/150/47730.jpg)
-
Cotchin won't be risked in NAB Cup
2:55 PM Wed 6 February, 2008
By Catherine Murphy
richmondfc.com.au
RICHMOND’S first pick in the2007 NAB AFL National Draft, Trent Cotchin, will not feature during the club’s NAB Cup campaign.
The 17-year-old, who underwent ankle surgery before the draft, has suffered achilles soreness and assistant coach David King says the club won’t be risking him.
“He’s so young so we’re taking a careful approach with him. He’s the youngest player at the club and we just don’t want to regress with him at all,” King said.
“He won’t feature early in our games and he certainly won’t play through the NAB Cup. We just want him completely free of any issues before we push him.”
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/6301/Default.aspx?newsId=55012
-
“He won’t feature early in our games and he certainly won’t play through the NAB Cup. We just want him completely free of any issues before we push him.”
Good.
-
yes ... no need to rush Cotchin at all ... just get his ankle 100% ...
i don't think he needs to do any skills or ball work ...
already made player ... just needs to put on the muscle like all 17 year olds ...
exactly, why risk injurying him in a season that won't really mean much in the end. Would much prefer to see him play fewer games but at 100% rather than all the season but with an injury cloud
-
exactly, why risk injurying him in a season that won't really mean much in the end. Would much prefer to see him play fewer games but at 100% rather than all the season but with an injury cloud
100% spot on bluey_21
-
yes ... no need to rush Cotchin at all ... just get his ankle 100% ...
i don't think he needs to do any skills or ball work ...
already made player ... just needs to put on the muscle like all 17 year olds ...
exactly, why risk injurying him in a season that won't really mean much in the end. Would much prefer to see him play fewer games but at 100% rather than all the season but with an injury cloud
Exactly. 2009 and beyond is when we'll need Cotchin. There's no rush.
-
5 days old but here's the latest injury list....
As of February 4th 2008:
Trent Cotchin Foot
Luke McGuane Shoulder
Angus Graham Ankle
Danny Meyer Hip
Daniel Connors Calf
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2007/InjuryList/tabid/9411/Default.aspx
-
5 days old but here's the latest injury list....
As of February 4th 2008:
Trent Cotchin Foot
Luke McGuane Shoulder
Angus Graham Ankle
Danny Meyer Hip
Daniel Connors Calf
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2007/InjuryList/tabid/9411/Default.aspx
no mention of how far away they are
-
Connors played in the intra-club so he's fine.
First I've heard about Luke having a shoulder. I thought it was him still recovering from the OP he carried last year. Hopefully another goalpost didn't fall and land on him again lol.
-
5 days old but here's the latest injury list....
As of February 4th 2008:
Trent Cotchin Foot
Luke McGuane Shoulder
Angus Graham Ankle
Danny Meyer Hip
Daniel Connors Calf
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2007/InjuryList/tabid/9411/Default.aspx
no mention of how far away they are
That's as obvious they can be after the Nathan Brown (or Simmo) debacle last year.
Pretty sure it was one of those. Was 2 weeks away for about 9 weeks. ;D :rollin
-
McGuane is a little behind in his pre-season as he chose to play with Coburg in the finals last year which in turn put off his post season opp.
I believe he may be playing this weekend in Coburg's practise match which will be played on Saturday at Geelong as a curtain raiser for the NAB cup game down there.
-
I believe he may be playing this weekend in Coburg's practise match which will be played on Saturday at Geelong as a curtain raiser for the NAB cup game down there.
Yes should be a good hit out for all the young Cubs - both RFC & CFC. :thumbsup
-
Injury update from the Herald-Sun today:
Cotchin foot 8 weeks
Thursty knee 1-2 weeks
McGaune shoulder 1-2 weeks
Graham ankle 1-2 weeks
Meyer hip 1-2 weeks
-
Injury update from the Herald-Sun today:
Cotchin foot 8 weeks
Thursty knee 1-2 weeks
McGaune shoulder 1-2 weeks
Graham ankle 1-2 weeks
Meyer hip 1-2 weeks
McGuane and Gus would be closer to 1 week especially McGuane who did most of the main training yesterday. The other 3 weren't sighted.
-
that basically means besides cotchin we have a full list, wow :gotigers
-
that basically means besides cotchin we have a full list, wow :gotigers
Provided Danny doesn't have a Razor-like 1-week hip injury that lasts all year.
-
From training today:
Rance - ankle done in the Coburg practice match. He said he'll be fine so I don't think it's too serious. Basically stood on the boundary and encouraged his teammates training then stuck his right foot in a bucket of ice water.
Edwards has a minor quad. Still trained fully today but iced up his thigh afterwards.
Thursty copped a minor cut to his leg in a marking contest with Richo so he should be okay.
Kingy hardly trained today but there wasn't anything noticably wrong.
Cotchin is still the only long-term injury according to the trainers.
-
From training today:
Rance - ankle done in the Coburg practice match. He said he'll be fine so I don't think it's too serious. Basically stood on the boundary and encouraged his teammates training then stuck his right foot in a bucket of ice water.
Edwards has a minor quad. Still trained fully today but iced up his thigh afterwards.
Thursty copped a minor cut to his leg in a marking contest with Richo so he should be okay.
Kingy hardly trained today but there wasn't anything noticably wrong.
Cotchin is still the only long-term injury according to the trainers.
Anything on Foley? Word on BF is that he might have shin splints?
-
Anything on Foley? Word on BF is that he might have shin splints?
Trained fully for 2 1/2 hours today and finished first in every run - 200m, 400m. Sounds like someone over there is talking crap.
-
apparantly an umpire is the alleged souce lol
if he had shin splints, he would not have trained as weel s mt has said
-
Trained fully for 2 1/2 hours today and finished first in every run - 200m, 400m. Sounds like someone over there is talking crap.
What :gobdrop
Crap on Big Footy...
Never :rollin
-
foley is FINE. :whistle
-
At the moment having a full squad minus one is one positive we can take out of preseason so far. Let's hope it stays that way by round 1.
-
Player Injury Onset Estimated Return
Trent Cotchin foot stress fracture Pre-season Rnd 4
http://www.injuryupdate.com.au/afl.php
Did I miss something or is this the first time it's been publicly stated Cotchin has stress fracture(s) of the foot ???. I notice this was also mentioned in Karen Lyon's Age article.
-
Spoke to a Richmond trainer today at training. He said the report in the paper about Cotchin having foot stress fractures was crap. He's only a couple of weeks away and will be right by round 3. He said Cotchin was having shots at goal with his right foot today whereas before it was only his left foot.
Meyer may be close to playing either this weekend or if not then next weekend. I presume starting at Coburg.
Rance thinks he is a chance to play for Coburg this week. He trained for a large part of today but finished off sticking his foot and ankle in a bucket of ice water for 20 minutes. They think he'll be right by Thursday.
Petts looked like he picked up a niggle. Nothing serious as he was still able to run a lap with a trainer but he pulled out of main training.
-
Thanks for the update mt, just a question though did the trainer mean that trent will be ready for full training come rd 3?
-
Thanks for the update mt, just a question though did the trainer mean that trent will be ready for full training come rd 3?
The impression I got bluey was Cotchin will be back training in 2-3 weeks and will play for Coburg come round 3.
We got talking amongst ourselves about Cotch spending most of the year at Coburg due to him lacking a full preseason and one of the trainers chipped in and said he's got the talent so why not use him as a pinchhitter off the bench for 10 minutes at a time so he doesn't tire out. He could be the difference in some games.
-
thanks MT :thumbsup
-
We got talking amongst ourselves about Cotch spending most of the year at Coburg due to him lacking a full preseason and one of the trainers chipped in and said he's got the talent so why not use him as a pinchhitter off the bench for 10 minutes at a time so he doesn't tire out. He could be the difference in some games.
Boy that's a big call for an injured first year player who hasn't played a game yet. I hope that trainer is right, wouldn't it be nice to have recruited a youngster capable of that. Personally I'd be happy if he just showed something this year and settled in, I don't expect him to be a match winner.
-
I actually quite like this idea, as long as he is not carrying any injuries. If match fitness is the only prob then I think it is a brilliant idea to give Trent a pinch-hitting role.
-
It is a big call but if Cotch's ankle/achilles gets right then IMO he could still show some value as a pinch-hitter this year. He was a freak at U18 level.
-
Other injuries:
WP: Rotator Cuff :'( :'(
;D
-
rot cuffs take a while to heal, take ur rehab seriously and try not to rush it
-
rot cuffs take a while to heal, take ur rehab seriously and try not to rush it
well they've given me this big rubber band thingee to tie to a door handle and do "range of mevement" exercises 3 times a day :o
It is certainly feeling better but I look very stupid doing it ;D
-
dont worry about how stupid it looks, if you do them right and give it time it will heal
-
dont worry about how stupid it looks, if you do them right and give it time it will heal
I know
Have to say that the improvement over the pass fortnight since I've started this exercise prgram thing is amazing :thumbsup
-
Miller on SEN today (courtesy of Y&B):
Cotchin is 1 month away with a problem with tendonitis in his achillies. After round 2 he is confident he will be back and playing with Coburg. He is extremely keen to start.
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=146367&postcount=7
-
Miller on SEN today (courtesy of Y&B):
Cotchin is 1 month away with a problem with tendonitis in his achillies. After round 2 he is confident he will be back and playing with Coburg. He is extremely keen to start.
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=146367&postcount=7
thanks for the update mr one eyed :thumbsup
also brilliant to hear that cotch is keen to start
-
Bluey - did you end up getting into medicine?
-
Injury update from training today:
Alex Rance seems to have re-hurt his ankle. Went to ground holding his ankle which didn't look too good initially. He walked off and then with the trainers did a run up and back saying the problem is when he changes direction.
(http://www.gspimages.com.au/images/thumbs/150/67279.jpg) (http://www.gspimages.com.au/images/thumbs/150/67278.jpg) (http://www.gspimages.com.au/images/thumbs/150/67277.jpg)
Jordy only did laps. Wouldn't kick the footy either. Not sure if it was here or on Y&B but I remember someone giving us game updates saying they thought Jordy had strained a hammy. Perhaps it that.
Also in rehab were Simmo, Kingy, Polak, Collard, Cotchin and Meyer. Cotchin was kicking the footy on both feet so the round 3 return prognosis seems right. Not sure what's wrong with Collard. He joined the rehab group about halfway through training. Polak was still limping so I'd doubt he'll play against Geelong. Why risk him.
-
Rance trained fully today although he was still discussing his ankle with the trainers after training had finished.
On the other hand Danny looked to be limping again so I guess his hip is still giving him trouble :(.
Polak still looks to be limping too from that bruised heel so he must be doubtful for tomorrow.
Cotchin was kicking again today with his right foot so fingers crossed he is on schedule for a round 3 start.
McMahon, Collard and Kingy, who all didn't train on Tuesday, trained fully today.
-
Bluey - did you end up getting into medicine?
:nope :lol
not too fussed, will give it another shot in 3 years :thumbsup
-
On the other hand Danny looked to be limping again so I guess his hip is still giving him trouble :(.
how unfortunate for him. it must be so fraustrating thats for sure. does anybody know exactly what is the matter with his hip?
i mean is it bone rubbing? cracked? deteriorating ball and socket joints? nerve problem? muscle related? WTF is going on!
Send him to germany for treament or at least get someone who knows WTF they're doing !!!
i have grave fears that this injury is being mis-diagnosed and mis-treated.
-
Cameron Howat (Richmond) concussion - Concussed on Thursday night but should make a full recovery.
POSSIBLE RETURNS THIS WEEK
Mark Coughlan (Richmond) knee
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/the-injury-report/2008/03/23/1206206928444.html
-
Just a question, is Connors still injured?
-
Just a question, is Connors still injured?
Nope played for Coburg on Saturday Bluey :thumbsup
Was OK but needs to tighten up defensively
-
Thanks WP :thumbsup
Hoping to see Connors in the senior side soon :pray
-
Injury list as of March 25 2008:
Daniel Jackson Cut Ear (available)
Angus Graham Hip (test)
Trent Cotchin Foot (3-4 weeks)
Danny Meyer Hip (TBA)
-
Injury list as of March 25 2008:
Daniel Jackson Cut Ear (available)
Angus Graham Hip (test)
Trent Cotchin Foot (3-4 weeks)
Danny Meyer Hip (TBA)
You forgot
Kane Johnston Brain Malfunction (1 week)
-
Injury list as of March 25 2008:
Daniel Jackson Cut Ear (available)
Angus Graham Hip (test)
Trent Cotchin Foot (3-4 weeks)
Danny Meyer Hip (TBA)
Why didn't Coghlan play on the weekend then - or did he?
-
Why didn't Coghlan play on the weekend then - or did he?
Nup didn't play. David King said Cogs is still a fair few weeks away from playing seniors.
-
I heard he didn't play for Coburg the other day (on the radio, I think) due to hamstring tightness.
-
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=152086&postcount=29
-
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=152086&postcount=29
lol! :thumbsup
-
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=152086&postcount=29
lol! :thumbsup
;D
-
Injury list as of March 31 2008:
Andrew Raines (Knee) test
Angus Graham (Hip) test
Trent Cotchin (Achilles) 2-3 weeks
Danny Meyer (Hip) TBA
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2008/InjuryList/tabid/9411/default.aspx
-
Is Cotch still on the long-term injury list or what.
-
Is Cotch still on the long-term injury list or what.
Till the end of round 3 wasn't it?
-
Well do I believe this injury report or not... :-\
-
Injury list as of March 31 2008:
Andrew Raines (Knee) test
Angus Graham (Hip) test
Trent Cotchin (Achilles) 2-3 weeks
Danny Meyer (Hip) TBA
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/Season2008/InjuryList/tabid/9411/default.aspx
So Casserly & Coughlan don't count or will they play this week?
-
I did read someware that Cog's is right to go this weekend. Not sure about Cass though.
-
TFL said in his Coburg report that Cogs may play this weekend against the Bullants. Cass trained last week so he can't be too far away.
-
Injury list as of April 7 2008:
Mark Coughlin (Knee) Available
Trent Cotchin (Achilles) Available
Angus Graham (Hip) test
Andrew Raines (Knee) 2 weeks
Danny Meyer (Hip) TBA
-
You know we expect so much from our cubs, its sad really. I was looking at this list and thinking how good it would be for Cotchin to play but then pulled myself up. We already desperately expect so much of our this kid, like the rest of our new recruits and even all the way up to our 21/22 year old developing players and it is unrealistic.
I think the reason for this is because we don't have any senior stars to rely upon so we look to our young promising and 'potential' players to compete with other teams seasoned players and beat them barely a heartbeat after they have moved from the TAC Cup. I do it too. When there is no hope with what you have then you look for a miracle.
Cogs is the only player who could come in and make an impact but I just don't hink his fitness, confidence or skills are up to it as yet otherwise they would have played him or a least taked him up.
Meyer is a potentially good player but he is always injured. I don't hink he will every don the yellow and black again. :'(
Graham will play again and I expect him tostep into our senior line up soon. we need a ruckman with height to compete against the other monsters of the league.
Raines has been missed. His attack on the ball in the first two games had me believing he may well have remembered what made him a good football in 2006!
I hope we don't see any of this years draft picks this season. They need time to develop in the reserves just like Gellong has done with their young players in the past. Whether we can afford to do this is the biggest question of all...
Stripes
-
You know we expect so much from our cubs, its sad really. I was looking at this list and thinking how good it would be for Cotchin to play but then pulled myself up. We already desperately expect so much of our this kid, like the rest of our new recruits and even all the way up to our 21/22 year old developing players and it is unrealistic.
I think the reason for this is because we don't have any senior stars to rely upon so we look to our young promising and 'potential' players to compete with other teams seasoned players and beat them barely a heartbeat after they have moved from the TAC Cup. I do it too. When there is no hope with what you have then you look for a miracle.
Cogs is the only player who could come in and make an impact but I just don't hink his fitness, confidence or skills are up to it as yet otherwise they would have played him or a least taked him up.
Meyer is a potentially good player but he is always injured. I don't hink he will every don the yellow and black again. :'(
Graham will play again and I expect him tostep into our senior line up soon. we need a ruckman with height to compete against the other monsters of the league.
Raines has been missed. His attack on the ball in the first two games had me believing he may well have remembered what made him a good football in 2006!
I hope we don't see any of this years draft picks this season. They need time to develop in the reserves just like Gellong has done with their young players in the past. Whether we can afford to do this is the biggest question of all...
Stripes
Good post. totally agree. :thumbsup
-
I don't have a problem with them playing as you don't hold back a kid if he's ready to go but you're right Stripes we expect these cubs to walk in and star because we are so desperate for hope for the future.
Danny is still "TBA". It doesn't sound too good for him.
Nice of our official club website to misspell the surname of one of our own players :wallywink
-
they are all ready, they have all had a pre season , except cotchin.
they are ready terry is just a gutless idiot
-
I don't have a problem with them playing as you don't hold back a kid if he's ready to go but you're right Stripes we expect these cubs to walk in and star because we are so desperate for hope for the future.
Danny is still "TBA". It doesn't sound too good for him.
Nice of our official club website to misspell the surname of one of our own players :wallywink
There men when they are drafted they aint no mummy boys they paid to play football with Richmond
-
I don't have a problem with them playing as you don't hold back a kid if he's ready to go but you're right Stripes we expect these cubs to walk in and star because we are so desperate for hope for the future.
Danny is still "TBA". It doesn't sound too good for him.
Nice of our official club website to misspell the surname of one of our own players :wallywink
There men when they are drafted they aint no mummy boys they paid to play football with Richmond
Few are but most ain't. If that was the case then we'd have teams full of 18 and 19 year olds.
-
Danny Meyer spoke at the Player Club Coterie pre-match yesterday and said that his hip is the best it's felt in 12 months = NO PAIN
He reckons he will back playing in about 4-5 weeks
-
when l was still playing football we had kids 15 pushing senior players out & we had no problem with that
these kids played against men who were twice there size & 4 times wider & they came to play football
there is too much weakness in football today everyone is protected so there should not be any problem
McMahon he be 75 kg wet :lol
-
Danny Meyer spoke at the Player Club Coterie pre-match yesterday and said that his hip is the best it's felt in 12 months = NO PAIN
He reckons he will back playing in about 4-5 weeks
Danny Meyer will never play another game at Richmond his finshed period
Too many better players his type have replaced him. Goodbye Meyer
-
Danny Meyer spoke at the Player Club Coterie pre-match yesterday and said that his hip is the best it's felt in 12 months = NO PAIN
He reckons he will back playing in about 4-5 weeks
Danny Meyer will never play another game at Richmond his finshed period
Too many better players his type have replaced him. Goodbye Meyer
Only passing on what the lad said TMonk
-
He reckons he will back playing in about 4-5 weeks
Well he would want to play in 4-5 weeks.
Start and then star at Coburg which should take 3-5 weeks and then play at Richmond in decent form for the rest of year to stay on our list.
We cant wait for him forever and he's right in the firing line to be considered for the trash unless the club actually has the balls to make the delistments of Tivendale and Hyde in which he might be saved.
-
Danny Meyer spoke at the Player Club Coterie pre-match yesterday and said that his hip is the best it's felt in 12 months = NO PAIN
He reckons he will back playing in about 4-5 weeks
Danny Meyer will never play another game at Richmond his finshed period
Too many better players his type have replaced him. Goodbye Meyer
Only passing on what the lad said TMonk
l know that WP its not directed at yourself, l'm stating what l think & that is his career is finished as far as players of that type
-
when l was still playing football we had kids 15 pushing senior players out & we had no problem with that
these kids played against men who were twice there size & 4 times wider & they came to play football
When was the last time a 15 year old debuted in the AFL. Timmy Watson 30 years ago?
there is too much weakness in football today everyone is protected so there should not be any problem
True 90% of possessions are uncontested these days but if you watched the Showdown there wasn't much weakness. Crows players going down left right and centre lol.
McMahon he be 75 kg wet :lol
LOL Are you playing devil's advocate :D
-
Injury list as of April 14 2008:
Mark Coughlin (Knee) Available
Angus Graham (Hip) Available
Andrew Raines (Knee) 1-2 weeks
Danny Meyer (Hip) 2 weeks
-
Injury list as of April 14 2008:
Mark Coughlin (Knee) Available
Angus Graham (Hip) Available
Andrew Raines (Knee) 1-2 weeks
Danny Meyer (Hip) 2 weeks
Hopefully this means Cogs plays this week for the Burgers :pray.
-
I spoke with Rainesy on Saturday at Coburg. He said that his knee was feeling pretty good and he had ran a few laps in the morning.
From what he said, 2 weeks sounds about right.
Having Gus back at Coburg will make a big difference also, Cartledge has been doing a great job in the ruck but once he goes off the Burgers have really struggled.
-
Having Gus back at Coburg will make a big difference also, Cartledge has been doing a great job in the ruck but once he goes off the Burgers have really struggled.
Don't know what you think TFL but I reckon Gus would probably come back through the Coburg ressies ??? Ditto Cogs
-
I would say Gus may play ones, it really depends on what the RFC conditioning staff think they are up to.
Cogs would be pretty underdone and will most likely play twos. i dont know that Gus had been upto.
I will be happy if they play two's!!!
Imagine the starting line up in the two's of Gus in the ruck with Cogs ruck rover and Cotchin rover. Pretty handy!!
-
Imagine the starting line up in the two's of Gus in the ruck with Cogs ruck rover and Cotchin rover. Pretty handy!!
yes so true.
I reckon the dude on bench with the clock thing around his neck would have a great day :thumbsup
-
Does Flavour Flav go to Coburg games? 8)
-
Imagine the starting line up in the two's of Gus in the ruck with Cogs ruck rover and Cotchin rover. Pretty handy!!
yes so true.
I reckon the dude on bench with the clock thing around his neck would have a great day :thumbsup
He will have a great day as long as the coach doesnt talk too long and listens to the 1 minute warnings :shh :lol
-
Imagine the starting line up in the two's of Gus in the ruck with Cogs ruck rover and Cotchin rover. Pretty handy!!
yes so true.
I reckon the dude on bench with the clock thing around his neck would have a great day :thumbsup
He will have a great day as long as the coach doesnt talk too long and listens to the 1 minute warnings :shh :lol
Coaches never listen to 1 minute warnings :nope lol
-
I would say Gus may play ones, it really depends on what the RFC conditioning staff think they are up to.
Cogs would be pretty underdone and will most likely play twos. i dont know that Gus had been upto.
I will be happy if they play two's!!!
Gus has hardly had a preseason too so I'd reckon he'll be in the 2's too.
-
Armstrong confirmed Andrew Raines - who dislocated his kneecap against the Kangaroos in Round 2 - will return for the Round 6 clash against Hawthorn at the MCG.
Full article at:
http://sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/coughlans-comeback-on-hold-46793
-
If we play anything like last week there wont be a spot for him. :shh
-
If we play anything like last week there wont be a spot for him. :shh
A sign of improvement in our list. Last year Joel, Petts and Rainesy played all 22 games but now they are no longer walk-up starts in the side.
-
Injury list as of April 21 2008:
Mark Coughlin (Knee) Test
Danny Meyer (Hip) 1 week
Andrew Raines (Knee) 2 weeks
-
and a healthy list is reflected in the results and efforts for all teams 2s and up
-
Hope Danny gets fit, see some similarities between him and Schulz. Has an underperforming body that always seems to fail on him. Danny has all the tools to be a very very good footballer. Would be top 5 at the club in terms of kicking, fantastic athletic ability and a sharp footy brain. Yes, needs to be put on the Nathan Foley program and work harder. But needs a healthy body before any of this can eventuate. :pray
-
You're not always sure how reliable these updates are but good news about Cogs and Danny. Rainesy on the other hand has got 2 weekitis.
-
;D is Cogs ready that will make Smokey happy :lol
we just got that Cogs thread into the archives ;D dont tell me we getting it out already
whats Cogs been doing at training MT
-
;D is Cogs ready that will make Smokey happy :lol
we just got that Cogs thread into the archives ;D dont tell me we getting it out already
whats Cogs been doing at training MT
:) :) :)
And yes please MT, anything on where is he training-wise?
Without wanting or intending to re-ignite the Cogs debate, my gut feeling says that he will be available at around the same time as Cotchin - maybe rounds 10 - 12 mid season. I think he was more forward than Cotchin early on but had the hamstring tightness slow his recovery while Cotchin has been catching up unhindered since his ankle mended. Even though they are coming off 2 vastly different fitness bases, I believe that circumstances will fall so that they are both available at around the same time.
-
;D is Cogs ready that will make Smokey happy :lol
we just got that Cogs thread into the archives ;D dont tell me we getting it out already
whats Cogs been doing at training MT
:) :) :)
And yes please MT, anything on where is he training-wise?
Going by training yesterday Danny is a lot closer to a comeback than Cogs unless Cogs was being rested. At least Danny was kicking the footy.
-
Going by training yesterday Danny is a lot closer to a comeback than Cogs unless Cogs was being rested. At least Danny was kicking the footy.
Thanks MT. I actually thought Meyer was going to be the least likely to play again this year (and in his case that would have been almost certainly the end) so for his sake that's good news. At least he might get a last crack at the title.
-
Rainesy said on Ch 10 news that he hopes to be back for round 8 (if you can get into the side Andrew ;) ). He thought he had done his knee (ACL/PCL) when it first happened but there's no structural damage to the ligaments.
-
COMPLETE club-by-club injury list ahead of Round 7.
RICHMOND
Mark Coughlan (hamstring) - available
Danny Meyer (hip) - available
Matthew White (leg) - to be assessed
Andrew Raines (knee) - 1 week
ST KILDA
Michael Gardiner (calf) - test
Adam Schneider (hamstring) - test
Steven King (hamstring) - 1-2 weeks
Luke Miles (fibula) - 1-3 weeks
Luke van Rheenen (foot) - 2-3 weeks
Glenn Chivers (foot) - 5-7 weeks
Sam Gilbert (shoulder) - 5-7 weeks
Jayden Attard (knee) - 7-9 weeks
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,23618212-19742,00.html
-
COMPLETE club-by-club injury list ahead of Round 7.
RICHMOND
Mark Coughlan (hamstring) - available
Danny Meyer (hip) - available
Coburgs best 2 players this weekend. Wouldnt that be nice? :cheers
-
Mate I'm no expert, but as I said in another thread, would be very surprised if he is back playing for at least another couple of weeks.
-
Mate I'm no expert, but as I said in another thread, would be very surprised if he is back playing for at least another couple of weeks.
I heard once or twice Cogs was playing this week. I pray to Budda it happens. :pray :bow
I'd even take Cogs & Meyer in the best for the Burger 2's this week 8)
Best case of course... they proabley both won't play :D
-
They will both have to wait atleast a week possibly 2.
Coburg arent playing this week and the week after only the seniors are playing which poses a bit of a selection issue with two guys coming back from long injury breaks.
Do they risk them in the seniors of Coburg or in the reserves?
-
They will both have to wait atleast a week possibly 2.
Coburg arent playing this week and the week after only the seniors are playing which poses a bit of a selection issue with two guys coming back from long injury breaks.
Do they risk them in the seniors of Coburg or in the reserves?
If it's a practice match this week have squads of 28 or whatever and play them off the bench. Cogs and Danny both training fully today btw.
-
Injury list as of May 5 2008:
Danny Meyer (Hip) Available
Andrew Raines (Knee) 1 week
-
From the Herald-Sun
Armstrong said defender Andrew Raines was still "one to two weeks" away from returning from a dislocated kneecap.
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,23674184-19742,00.html
-
From the Herald-Sun
Armstrong said defender Andrew Raines was still "one to two weeks" away from returning from a dislocated kneecap.
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,23674184-19742,00.html
Woot we have our next bite of two-week-itis. :lol :rollin
-
Injury update as of Wed May 14
Cameron Howat (knee) test
Andrew Raines (knee) 1 week
Travis Casserly (hamstring) 1-2 weeks
-
Travis Casserly (hamstring) 1-2 weeks
Speaking of luckless tigers hampered by injury :-\. We can only hope like Moore Cass' luck changes and his body eventually learns to cope with the rigors of AFL footy.
-
Casserly cant cope with the rigors of VFL you mean ;D
-
Injury list as of May 5 2008:
Danny Meyer (Hip) Available
Andrew Raines (Knee) 1 week
Danny Meyer, great to have him back available ;D
-
1st big bump he be out injured again, another wasted space.
whos he going to push out of the senior side, ;D nobody cya Dan
-
Danny's not going to start in the seniors :wallywink. I've got a feeling he'll play Sunday in the Coburg ressies. He was moving fine at training and not shying away from contested footy.
-
Danny Myer is another Quentin
-
Danny's not going to start in the seniors :wallywink. I've got a feeling he'll play Sunday in the Coburg ressies. He was moving fine at training and not shying away from contested footy.
As you full well know on the track is softer to on the ground game day
every player on that ground wants to take you out at any chance just to get a edge
as OX said another Quinten :thumbsup he can stay at Coburg for the rest of his life he makes a good VFL player
-
Danny's not going to start in the seniors :wallywink. I've got a feeling he'll play Sunday in the Coburg ressies. He was moving fine at training and not shying away from contested footy.
As you full well know on the track is softer to on the ground game day
every player on that ground wants to take you out at any chance just to get a edge
as OX said another Quinten :thumbsup he can stay at Coburg for the rest of his life he makes a good VFL player
you guys crack me up.
another quentin!!!hahaha
100% agree. should have taken hawks pick 50 for him, would've been better than still having him on our list
-
Stu Dew at 45 for Hawthorn no thanks :lol
-
Mate I'm no expert, but as I said in another thread, would be very surprised if he is back playing for at least another couple of weeks.
RE: Cogs
He played, I was surprised and WTF makes the decision to play and train when you can hardly walk a flight of stairs. :banghead
-
Mate I'm no expert, but as I said in another thread, would be very surprised if he is back playing for at least another couple of weeks.
RE: Cogs
He played, I was surprised and WTF makes the decision to play and train when you can hardly walk a flight of stairs. :banghead
just save that post for another 6 weeks CUB ;D you need it again
-
Danny's not going to start in the seniors :wallywink. I've got a feeling he'll play Sunday in the Coburg ressies. He was moving fine at training and not shying away from contested footy.
As you full well know on the track is softer to on the ground game day
every player on that ground wants to take you out at any chance just to get a edge
That didn't apply to Cogs or Cass :P.
-
Injury list as of May 19 2008:
Andrew Raines (Knee) Test
Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls (Arm) 1 week
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) 1 week
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
-
Danny's not going to start in the seniors :wallywink. I've got a feeling he'll play Sunday in the Coburg ressies. He was moving fine at training and not shying away from contested footy.
As you full well know on the track is softer to on the ground game day
every player on that ground wants to take you out at any chance just to get a edge
as OX said another Quinten :thumbsup he can stay at Coburg for the rest of his life he makes a good VFL player
you guys crack me up.
another quentin!!!hahaha
100% agree. should have taken hawks pick 50 for him, would've been better than still having him on our list
Pick 50 for a former first rounder 21 year old.
Yeah, brillant move ::)
Meyer, JON (20), Casserly (20), Polo (21) should be given untill the end of 2009.
-
Injury list as of May 19 2008:
Andrew Raines (Knee) Test
Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls (Arm) 1 week
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) 1 week
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
JON's very lucky to get away with just a week off from a broken arm.
We might have to send Cass to that German sports doctor too if he does another hammy. The poor kid can't take a trick with soft tissue injuries.
-
We might have to send Cass to that German sports doctor too if he does another hammy. The poor kid can't take a trick with soft tissue injuries.
It is a fair thought but the club would have a different view on potential ROI when spending the ~$20k it did on Coughlan - untried draftee vs Jack Dyer medallist.
-
Any more news on what happened to Richo last Saturday?
-
Not sure julz. Richo didn't train on Tuesday but often the senior players have light weeks. Last week Browny and Sugar didn't train before the Geelong game yet they still played. Hopefully the big fella is fine. There's been no talk of him being in doubt.
We might have to send Cass to that German sports doctor too if he does another hammy. The poor kid can't take a trick with soft tissue injuries.
It is a fair thought but the club would have a different view on potential ROI when spending the ~$20k it did on Coughlan - untried draftee vs Jack Dyer medallist.
The club still rates Cass pretty highly for someone who hasn't yet made his debut after 3 years on our list and Cogs' B&F was a whole 5 years ago and he hasn't played a game in 2 years. The club probably thinks with Cogs they had no alternative whereas Cass is still young and his body still developing so like Moore they might think he'll eventually come good.
-
The club still rates Cass pretty highly for someone who hasn't yet made his debut after 3 years on our list and Cogs' B&F was a whole 5 years ago and he hasn't played a game in 2 years. The club probably thinks with Cogs they had no alternative whereas Cass is still young and his body still developing so like Moore they might think he'll eventually come good.
Yeah, probably right MT. FWIW I was quite impressed with Casserley in the pre-season game this year and was looking forward to seeing him this year. He looked like he was someone ready and able to step up and cope.
-
Danny Myer is another Quentin
another insightful post
such a hero
-
On the SEN VFL show they were saying JON initially fractured his arm in the 2nd quarter and then after going back on copped another knock on the same arm that broke it properly :help. Tough stuff!
-
Injury list as of May 27 2008:
Andrew Raines (Knee) Available
Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls (Arm) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
-
It must have been a very minor break to JON's arm.
Good to see he's recovered so quickly.
-
News says 'favorite doctor' injury?
WTF?
-
Richo - knee
-
Apart from Cogs virtually a full list to pick from. We're struggling to fit everyone in at Coburg let alone Richmond.
-
Apart from Cogs virtually a full list to pick from. We're struggling to fit everyone in at Coburg let alone Richmond.
In a way this is bad for devlopment reasons.
-
Apart from Cogs virtually a full list to pick from. We're struggling to fit everyone in at Coburg let alone Richmond.
In a way this is bad for devlopment reasons.
But playing with Box Hill or Bendigo and getting flogged every week in sides with poor structure is ???.
-
Andrew Raines is close to returning from his knee injury, a dislocated patella suffered in round two.
"He's coming along well. If there was a VFL game, which there isn't, this weekend he would have been a chance. But obviously with no game, he's likely to be one more week."
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/tabid/6301/Default.aspx?newsid=60403
-
Andrew Raines is close to returning from his knee injury, a dislocated patella suffered in round two.
"He's coming along well. If there was a VFL game, which there isn't, this weekend he would have been a chance. But obviously with no game, he's likely to be one more week."
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/tabid/6301/Default.aspx?newsid=60403
Wasnt he meant to return in round 5 according to the medical staff? :lol
Looks like we here were right on the money. :thumbsup
-
Wasnt he meant to return in round 5 according to the medical staff? :lol
Looks like we here were right on the money. :thumbsup
As we always are!! ;D ;D
-
Wasnt he meant to return in round 5 according to the medical staff? :lol
Looks like we here were right on the money. :thumbsup
As we always are!! ;D ;D
lol. Throw enough poo at a wall and some of it is bound to stick. ;) ;D
-
Wasnt he meant to return in round 5 according to the medical staff? :lol
Looks like we here were right on the money. :thumbsup
As we always are!! ;D ;D
lol. Throw enough pooh at a wall and some of it is bound to stick. ;) ;D
lol. For once I think we all caught on that there was some 2-week-itis going on.
-
Funny though .... The whisper in Sydney is that the Swan's Kenneally (sp?) will be available this week.
That's, what? Two weeks after dislocating his kneecap?
-
Funny though .... The whisper in Sydney is that the Swan's Kenneally (sp?) will be available this week.
That's, what? Two weeks after dislocating his kneecap?
They can vary a lot when they pop out as to how long you stay out for.
Just look at Darren Creswell a few years ago. :rollin
-
Funny though .... The whisper in Sydney is that the Swan's Kenneally (sp?) will be available this week.
That's, what? Two weeks after dislocating his kneecap?
A Luke McGuane tackle will test out his knee :thumbsup
-
Injury list as of 2 June 2008:
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
Kane Johnson (Knee) 3-4 weeks
-
Injury update: round twelve
Tue 10 June, 2008
Kane Johnson (knee) 2-3 weeks
Will Thursfield (hamstring) 2-3 weeks
Mark Coughlan (hamstring) indefinite
-
Add 30,000 supporters less 10 from this website with broken hearts and crushed dreams of year that could of been
All are on the the long term injury list.
-
hahaha you crack me up Jack sometimes but your correct ;D
my doctor asked whats going on with with me, the wifes said when the Tigers are playing in footy season his BP goes up & the doctor looked at me serious & said that if the club is stressing me so much, l should pick another club like his Bulldogs cause its damaging my health he says & will cause me a heart attack
This is true, every year it goes up & the kids even said they notice my mood changes.
but out of footy season its perfect
-
Injury list as of 16 June 2008:
Will Thursfield (Hamstring) 1 week
Jake King (Hamstring) 1-2 weeks
Kane Johnson (Knee) 1-2 weeks
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
-
Hopefully that's right about Thursty and he'll be back and right for Fev.
-
Hopefully that's right about Thursty and he'll be back and right for Fev.
if not we r gawn.
could u imagine if and thats a big if we beat port this week, that game could attract 90k plus.
we need Will back, fact!!
-
Injury list as of 23 June 2008:
Will Thursfield (Hamstring) Test
Jake King (Hamstring) Test
Kane Johnson (Knee) Test
Luke McGuane (Hamstring) 2 weeks
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
-
Injury list as of 23 June 2008:
Will Thursfield (Hamstring) Test
Jake King (Hamstring) Test
Kane Johnson (Knee) Test
Luke McGuane (Hamstring) 2 weeks
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
Interesting I'm sure they all won't get up but could potential have three strong 'Ins' this week.
Cogs is a contant enigma. Did he play anywhere on the weekend? Why didn't they put him on the long term injury list an elevate someone like Collard or Cartledge? My guess is money but Collard would have benefited greatly from a small stint into the AFL. Look what happened when the TW did a similiar thing with Kingy.
Just wish I had more information about Mark as all this guessing and hoping is starting to become frustrating for all involved.
Stripes
-
Injury list as of 30 June 2008:
Matthew Richardson (Hamstring) Test
Will Thursfield (Hamstring) Test
Luke McGuane (Hamstring) Test
Mark Coughlan (Hamstring) Indefinite
Graham Polak (acquired brain injury) Indefinite
-
RICHMOND - as at July 7, 2008
Matthew Richardson (hamstring) - test
Will Thursfield (hamstring) - test
Andrew Raines (hamstring) - 2 weeks
Graham Polak (acquired brain injury) - indefinite
-
Injury list as of 14 July 2008:
Matthew Richardson (Hamstring) Test
Will Thursfield (Hamstring) Test
Jake King (Back) Test
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
Graham Polak (acquired brain injury) Indefinite
-
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
:scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
Send him to Germany. ;D But seriously. :-\
-
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
:scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
Send him to Germany. ;D But seriously. :-\
Give him time, Moore had injury troubles but has come good.
-
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
:scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
Send him to Germany. ;D But seriously. :-\
Give him time, Moore had injury troubles but has come good.
I'm willing to give him time but I just feel for the kid. Even Moore didn't have this much go against him.
-
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
:scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :scream :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
Send him to Germany. ;D But seriously. :-\
Seriously they should consider sending Cass to Germany. His season is gone after his 3rd? hammy for the year. Send him away now and hope the treatment can continue to work miracles and hope to have him back right for the start of the preseason.
-
Injury list as of 21 July 2008:
Jake King (Back) Available
Andrew Raines (Leg) Available
Matthew Richardson (Hamstring) Test
Daniel Connors (Hamstring) 2 weeks
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) TBC
-
Daniel Connors (Hamstring) 2 weeks
Dropped unluckily so Thursty could come in and now a hammy :(.
-
Good news on Tiger’s injury front
richmondfc.com.au
By Mic Cullen
5:30 PM Tue 22 July, 2008
WILL Thursfield was back last weekend, Matthew Richardson is due back this weekend and Mark Coughlan is going well in the VFL.
Finally, some good-news injury stories out of Punt Rd to counter the bad-news ones of Graham Polak and Kane Pettifer.
And even the Polak story is moving in the right direction.
Thursfield has pulled up well from his first game since the round 11 clash with Adelaide, and fellow hamstring complainant Matthew Richardson (who also added knee troubles into the mix) – is a good chance to be back for this weekend's clash with Brisbane.
"He [Richardson] trained yesterday and he got through that session pretty well, had a bit of a kick around today in what was basically a skills-based session, but he's got through a couple of solid sessions," coach Terry Wallace said on Tuesday.
"He's been out for probably over-and-above the time of a normal hamstring – it'll be nearly four weeks before he'll step back on to the ground, so timing says that he should play.
"But he's got to get through the week."
Following his trip to Germany for treatment, Coughlan is progressing well in his recovery from hamstring issues.
"Mark's back playing footy now, he's played for a couple of weeks and played at senior VFL level on the weekend and got through the game okay.
"He needs to get a continuity of five or six games running, just to find out exactly where he's at, and until you can do that, and until you can trust your body to that degree, you don't know where it takes you.
"Look, he's still a fair way off playing form at the moment, but that can come to hand pretty quick once you start playing regular footy."
Injured tall Polak continues to improve after being struck by a tram last month.
"Graham's slowly coming along. He's spent a little bit of time at home on the weekend. I got a text message from him before the game saying he was able to go home and watch the game on Saturday, and that's another pleasing step.
"I'm not quite sure where some of the media comments come that he was running around kicking a footy, which certainly wasn't the case.
"He's growing and developing in each thing he's been asked to do, and he's able to now do some mechanical exercise and keep himself a little bit fit just from a wellbeing point-of-view, but that's about where it stands."
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/tabid/6301/Default.aspx?newsid=63904
-
Injury list as of Monday 28 July 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Test
Daniel Connors (Hamstring) Test
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
-
I hope I don't Jinx us by saying so but we have a very healthy list going into the business end of the season this year. I hope it bodes well for our run home!
Stripes
-
yes its looking good, seeing Cogs continuely off the list is really great.
maybe our good health will bring good fortunes as other clubs suffer
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
-
whats with putts knee, can they elaborate a BIT more. is his knee serious or are they still waiting on scans
-
:help
I hope Putts knee is not a season long injury! :pray
I'm with you Shannon - a bit more clarification would help alleviate my anxiety.
Stripes
-
:help
I hope Putts knee is not a season long injury! :pray
I'm with you Shannon - a bit more clarification would help alleviate my anxiety.
Stripes
the season is nearly over so a 4 week injury is pretty much the season, but i hope its not a 12 month injury :pray
-
Let's hope it's not an ACL as that would basically wipe out 2009 for Putty as well. It's not as though we are blessed with a lot of talls and with Polak's future up in the air we can't afford to have any more talls going down.
-
Is there any further news to what Putty has done to his knee?
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Is this a club release or a supporter release ??
Interesting one of the injuries is incorrect and isnt reported correctly ;) Pick which one ??
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Is this a club release or a supporter release ??
Interesting one of the injuries is incorrect and isnt reported correctly ;) Pick which one ??
hughes,
but I guarantee you don't know the truth ;)
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Is this a club release or a supporter release ??
Interesting one of the injuries is incorrect and isnt reported correctly ;) Pick which one ??
hughes,
but I guarantee you don't know the truth ;)
I guarantee I do, you obviously know as well,
I wont be posting it though , for obvious reasons.
Let the club come clean, shall we, Nah, not a hope in hell of that happening
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Is this a club release or a supporter release ??
Interesting one of the injuries is incorrect and isnt reported correctly ;) Pick which one ??
hughes,
but I guarantee you don't know the truth ;)
I guarantee I do, you obviously know as well,
I wont be posting it though , for obvious reasons.
Let the club come clean, shall we, Nah, not a hope in hell of that happening
Was Hughes in the back of Shaw's ute?
-
Cleve trained with strapping around his shoulder.
I spoke to a couple of people at training about Putty and they said he was in the gym but they didn't know the extent of his knee injury. If it was an ACL you wouldn't think he'd be in the gym.
-
Putt reported as 4-6 weeks on PRE
Sounds like a PCL
-
A PCL would be 8-10 weeks out. Putt must have done his medial ligament if it's 4-6 weeks. It ends his season anyway but on the positive side a medial will mean he'll be fine for the start of preseason. If Coburg can gain some consistency and go deep into the finals he may even have a chance to make it back for a VFL PF/GF.
-
Cleve trained with strapping around his shoulder.
I spoke to a couple of people at training about Putty and they said he was in the gym but they didn't know the extent of his knee injury. If it was an ACL you wouldn't think he'd be in the gym.
Smoke screen the taping.
He has played with taping on is shoulder
-
A PCL would be 8-10 weeks out. Putt must have done his medial ligament if it's 4-6 weeks. It ends his season anyway but on the positive side a medial will mean he'll be fine for the start of preseason. If Coburg can gain some consistency and go deep into the finals he may even have a chance to make it back for a VFL PF/GF.
Medial is the one ;D
-
Clever been a bad boy? :banghead
-
A PCL would be 8-10 weeks out. Putt must have done his medial ligament if it's 4-6 weeks. It ends his season anyway but on the positive side a medial will mean he'll be fine for the start of preseason. If Coburg can gain some consistency and go deep into the finals he may even have a chance to make it back for a VFL PF/GF.
Medial is the one ;D
Ta WP. Better it's a medial than what first sounded like Putty had done an ACL.
-
Injury list as of Monday 4 August 2008:
Cleve Hughes (Back) Available
Travis Casserly (Hamstring) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Is this a club release or a supporter release ??
Interesting one of the injuries is incorrect and isnt reported correctly ;) Pick which one ??
hughes,
but I guarantee you don't know the truth ;)
Care to ellaborate?
-
Injury list as of Monday 11 August 2008:
Andrew Raines (Leg) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
-
Injury list as of Monday 18 August 2008:
Nathan Foley (Hip) Test
Nathan Brown (Hip Test
Andrew Raines (Leg) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) Indefinite
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
-
Injury list as of Monday 25 August 2008:
Nathan Brown (Hip) Test
Andrew Raines (Leg) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) 2 weeks
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Jake King (Ankle) Season
-
Injury list as of Monday 25 August 2008:
Nathan Brown (Hip) Test
Andrew Raines (Leg) Test
Dean Putt (Knee) 2 weeks
Graham Polak (Acquired brain injury) Indefinite
Kayne Pettifer (Knee) Season
Jake King (Ankle) Season
Doesnt say "season," what a relief. :clapping
-
any info on NB's hip?
New,old or borrowed injury ?