One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Ramps on August 10, 2008, 06:06:08 PM
-
Whose your pick to takeover as Richmond coach. Discuss!
-
Whose your pick to takeover as Richmond coach. Discuss!
Time for one of our own.
Lambert or Cambo with Sheeds in a mentoring role.
-
Is our coach being sacked a season short of contract? Does this mean we have to pay out his contract as well as pay his replacement? Am i missing something?
-
Whose your pick to takeover as Richmond coach. Discuss!
Time for one of our own.
Lambert or Cambo with Sheeds in a mentoring role.
Sheeds will be at Punt Road next year.'
Who coaches ? Buckley ? Campbell ? Leon Cameron ?
-
Is our coach being sacked a season short of contract? Does this mean we have to pay out his contract as well as pay his replacement? Am i missing something?
No nothing official, just asking for peoples opinions on who should takeover in the event of a Wallace resignation or sacking.
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
-
To gain him would be great and to lose Wallace would even be greater. And i was one of those who thought Wallace was right for us. So lets hope you are right Jackstar
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Can we draft him as well and put him on the bench for three matches?
:cheers
-
Whoever takes over has a big job indeed fixing up the playing list.
I think these blokes played today.
Chris Newman, should be offered up for trade
Will Thursfield, is a handy 3rd defender
Luke McGuane, should be replaced be traded to GC17, Alex Rance is the readymade replacement
Joel Bowden, Never been a big fan, I think its time to retire
Kelvin Moore, hasnt been bad in 2008, he can be kept
Jordan McMahon, anyone seen Callan Ward today or Scott Selwood lol. We should have kept the pick
Matthew Richardson,Great player, wont see success at Richmond, should retire and save his body
Shane Tuck, tries hard, wont take us to any great heights though.
Brett Deledio, Star- one of afew. May ask to be traded if we dont make finals in 2009.
Trent Cotchin, see Brett Deledio
Adam Pattison, Not happening with Adam, should be shopped around end of 2008
Richard Tambling, Some good, mostly not so good, should be shopped around end of 2008. Disappointing, I really wanted Richie to succeed.
Nathan Brown, wasted his career coming to Richmond, should be shopped around end of 2008
Jack Riewoldt, hes a keeper but has a long long way to go.
Mitch Morton can play but has been disappointing the last few weeks
Troy Simmonds, he needs to be kept coz we have no other ruckman
Kane Johnson, should retire at seasons end.
Nathan Foley, should be kept overall a good season.
Shane Edwards, shows potential, very small, who knows
Jake King, sorry Jake, Id be trading you at seasons end
Daniel Jackson, I think Daniel is 25 to 30 ranked player on a list
Matt White, has improved this year so Id keep
In: Brown, Cartledge, Tivendale
Out: Nil
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Can we draft him as well and put him on the bench for three matches?
:cheers
Funny thing is that he could still probably get a kick, we were disgraceful today.
Wallace will walk ;)
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Can we draft him as well and put him on the bench for three matches?
:cheers
Funny thing is that he could still probably get a kick, we were disgraceful today.
Wallace will walk ;)
Wallace never had a chance with the players we recruited in 2004, 2005, 2006 and so on. The 2004 has proven a 95% failure.
-
Whoever takes over has a big job indeed fixing up the playing list.
I think these blokes played today.
Chris Newman, should be offered up for trade
Will Thursfield, is a handy 3rd defender
Luke McGuane, should be replaced be traded to GC17, Alex Rance is the readymade replacement
Joel Bowden, Never been a big fan, I think its time to retire
Kelvin Moore, hasnt been bad in 2008, he can be kept
Jordan McMahon, anyone seen Callan Ward today or Scott Selwood lol. We should have kept the pick
Matthew Richardson,Great player, wont see success at Richmond, should retire and save his body
Shane Tuck, tries hard, wont take us to any great heights though.
Brett Deledio, Star- one of afew. Should ask to be traded if we dont make finals in 2009.
Trent Cotchin, see Brett Deledio
Adam Pattison, Not happening with Adam, should be shopped around end of 2008
Richard Tambling, Some good, mostly not so good, should be shopped around end of 2008. Disappointing, I really wanted Richie to succeed.
Nathan Brown, wasted his career coming to Richmond, should be shopped around end of 2008
Jack Riewoldt, hes a keeper but has a long long way to go.
Mitch Morton can play but has been disappointing the last few weeks
Troy Simmonds, he needs to be kept coz we have no other ruckman
Kane Johnson, should retire at seasons end.
Nathan Foley, should be kept overall a good season.
Shane Edwards, shows potential, very small, who knows
Jake King, sorry Jake, Id be trading you at seasons end
Daniel Jackson, I think Daniel is 25 to 30 ranked player on a list
Matt White, has improved this year so Id keep
In: Brown, Cartledge, Tivendale
Out: Nil
Agree 99.9% Ramps.
Would play Tivendale next 3 weeks.
We have little run and carry through the corrdidor
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Can we draft him as well and put him on the bench for three matches?
:cheers
Funny thing is that he could still probably get a kick, we were disgraceful today.
Wallace will walk ;)
Wallace never had a chance with the players we recruited in 2004, 2005, 2006 and so on. The 2004 has proven a 95% failure.
Just like Spud left TW a train wreck our next coach will get a very similar list.
We are a very average outfit and one must wonder why apart from lids(week in week out) can any other player not hit a target from 20 metres out.
even the games we win we see this pathetic disposal. is it Mccrae? i mean who is to blame apart from Solarium face.
-
hi all, long time reader of this site, may as well put my 2 bobs in. Terry should be sacked at years end. He clearly has not put this club in the position it should be after 4 seasons. It is as plain and clear as a sunny day, Terry has failed the club , its players and all its fans.
We have made a profit this year, time to pay him out , send him off , just like miller, and start all over again. how many times do we have to rebuild, and we have to do it all over again.
MOOSE
-
what a pack of old moles :rollin
-
what a pack of old moles :rollin
Fact :thumbsup
Campbell FFS! :banghead
-
MOOSE
Just for numbers sake,eh?
LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Still he comes under a different moniker
-
MOOSE
Just for numbers sake,eh?
LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Still he comes under a different moniker
LMAO @ his trademark illiteracy surfacing every time.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0042747/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCXxKMIdLHU
Might just call him Morris from now on.
-
Give the gig to Gary Ayres, his a hard man & will sort out the rot
-
rolol Jakey.
MMM.
LMAO@trademark illiteracy
-
Did Shannon get the stuff?
-
what a pack of old moles :rollin
Fact :thumbsup
Campbell FFS! :banghead
Thats how little you know Moi, Wayne Campbell will make a terriffic coach.
Very well spoken and is extremely well respected in the footy world. I would prefer Bucks actually.
Buckley will be the next big thing, RFC have to make quick decisions in moving the playing group forward. Bucks will be snapped up.
Bucks will inspire the players, the current clown couldnt inspire anthing but a suntan and today just proved what a farce he is as a coach.
And as for his assistants, he has Gordon Casey sitting next tim advising him( he went our with black and white TV ::) ::)) and Brian Royal and David King, both have proved they have little idea with King out of contract in 3 games time. THANK GOD! ::) ::)
-
what a pack of old moles :rollin
Fact :thumbsup
Campbell FFS! :banghead
Moi open your eyes. we need a change and Bucks is our man.
i could be wrong but im sure you are a TW lover, so do you think its right when one of your players makes a mistake you are seen laughing in the coaches box. Well thats what leather face was doing today, so if thats your idea of good coaching then maybe your following the wrong game.
-
What's Buck's and Campbell's coaching record?
It's a relevant question
-
What's Buck's and Campbell's coaching record?
It's a relevant question
What was Alistair Clarkson coaching record when he took over Hawthorn ;)
Who according to our coach, didnt have a the list we had. :banghead :banghead
Its an irrelevant question.
Nathan Buckley inspires people.
What was Sheeds coaching record when he took over at Essendin in 1981. ;) ::)
Paul Roos, similar.
I dont why I even reply to your posts Moi, you are deluded.
-
What's Buck's and Campbell's coaching record?
It's a relevant question
What was Alistair Clarkson coaching record when he took over Hawthorn ;)
Who according to our coach, didnt have a the list we had. :banghead :banghead
Its an irrelevant question.
Nathan Buckley inspires people.
What was Sheeds coaching record when he took over at Essendin in 1981. ;) ::)
Paul Roos, similar.
I dont why I even reply to your posts Moi, you are deluded.
Whoever takes over Jack, I will expect success from day one
Nothing less
A premiership in their first year.
You don't like my posts.
You'll like 'em very less when your mates take over.
-
What's Buck's and Campbell's coaching record?
It's a relevant question
What was Alistair Clarkson coaching record when he took over Hawthorn ;)
Who according to our coach, didnt have a the list we had. :banghead :banghead
Its an irrelevant question.
Nathan Buckley inspires people.
What was Sheeds coaching record when he took over at Essendin in 1981. ;) ::)
Paul Roos, similar.
I dont why I even reply to your posts Moi, you are deluded.
Whoever takes over Jack, I will expect success from day one
Nothing less
A premiership in their first year.
You don't like my posts.
You'll like 'em very less when your mates take over.
There not my mates, you are deluded.
I want what is best for the RFC.
I have said all year we are going no where with Wallace and his clowns.
Get rid of them and start again, but no, we have to honor is contract and waste another year.
We wasted a year sticking with Spud and we are going to through another $600,000 down the drain with Wallace, yep, money grows on trees does it.
Wallace will walk in 3 weeks anyway, reason being that the club will take away his safeguard of friends , and Terry doesnt want to work with anyone but his mates. fact!
Also
Mail is that Lids wants out as well, The would have to offer him capatin next year to stay. Irrelevant of what contracts are in place. ;)
Answer this Moi, where is the improvement on what you seen today ?????? And last week as well when we should have got beaten by 20 goals as we were HOPELESS as well,.
-
We were absolutely hopeless today, Jack.
Great example.
But one week doesn't make a season
If you can't see that from coming last last season to where we are this year isn't an improvement, then I feel sorry for you. You're so biased, you cannot see straight.
Just remember Tim Watson was held in high esteem as well when he became coach of the Saints
Ended up being one of the greatest jokes of all time.
Be careful what you wish for :banghead
-
We were absolutely hopeless today, Jack.
Great example.
But one week doesn't make a season
If you can't see that from coming last last season to where we are this year isn't an improvement, then I feel sorry for you. You're so biased, you cannot see straight.
Just remember Tim Watson was held in high esteem as well when he became coach of the Saints
Ended up being one of the greatest jokes of all time.
Be careful what you wish for :banghead
We havent improved.
You have all been lured into a false sense of security. WE were lucky to win a few games and thanks to Richo, we did.
Tell me where we have inproved.?
I am not biased at all, I only look at results. Finishing 10th or 11th as we will isnt any difference to finishing 16th.
Keep in mind that all bottom 4 clubs rested players this week and are planning for next year already. Even Freo has forced how many players to retire so they can get games in younger players etc.
Anyway, we will be Wallace free next year, thank god!
-
We were absolutely hopeless today, Jack.
Great example.
But one week doesn't make a season
If you can't see that from coming last last season to where we are this year isn't an improvement, then I feel sorry for you. You're so biased, you cannot see straight.
Just remember Tim Watson was held in high esteem as well when he became coach of the Saints
Ended up being one of the greatest jokes of all time.
Be careful what you wish for :banghead
We havent improved.
You have all been lured into a false sense of security. WE were lucky to win a few games and thanks to Richo, we did.
Tell me where we have inproved.?
I am not biased at all, I only look at results. Finishing 10th or 11th as we will isnt any difference to finishing 16th.
Keep in mind that all bottom 4 clubs rested players this week and are planning for next year already. Even Freo has forced how many players to retire so they can get games in younger players etc.
Anyway, we will be Wallace free next year, thank god!
Lets hope we're not Deledio free :help
-
I would like to see Nathan Buckley coaching at Richmond, assistant coaching that is :) Nathan shouldn't be given a coaching gig without learning the ropes as an assistant elsewhere.
TW has another year and will not be going anywhere after challenging for the finals especially considering we finished on the bottom last year. A little perspective and objectivity from posters on this board regardless of our immediate situation would be great from time to time. :pray
We had a bad game and I'm $%@%^$ disappointed like the rest of you! We had a real shot at the finals for the first time in years and we peeed it up the wall. I thought the weather would esculate the potenency of the Crows Style of play and hinder ours. Our comparitive size deficency killed us with Adelaide outmuscling us in the wet conditions.
We struggle against defensive teams such as the Crow and Sydney where we have no room to move, run or deliver.
But we can't be turning over our whole list and suggesting to Lids and Cotch to ask to be traded at the end of next year! :help Daniel this is just your disappontment talking. Yes it was hard to find a good player today with perhaps only Lids and Tuck the only players to stand up. Kingy has been ordinary since his return and Morton playing poorly lately (I wonder if Cleve's absence has anything to do with this).
I remember writing a thread about the deficencies in our style of play and how we needed to shepherd and block more for the ball carrier rather than run further ahead and look for the recieve. At the moment if we have two players running together and an opponent approaches the players without the ball usually runs forward to look to recieve the ball. The defender could intercept the handball, tackle the ball carrier causing the ball to spill or at best pressure the handball wasting time.
If instead we have two players running with the ball one should shepherd to create space for the ball carrier which reduces pressure and opportunities to turn the ball over. It also creates space ahead of the contest which frees up time. Teams such as Geelong and the Doggies (when they are on song) are masters of it.
That is my biggest grievance and perhaps getting an assistant coach who believes in this type of physical style of play would be a great addition to our coaching staff.
Stripes
-
Whoever takes over has a big job indeed fixing up the playing list.
I think these blokes played today.
Chris Newman, should be offered up for trade
Will Thursfield, is a handy 3rd defender
Luke McGuane, should be replaced be traded to GC17, Alex Rance is the readymade replacement
Joel Bowden, Never been a big fan, I think its time to retire
Kelvin Moore, hasnt been bad in 2008, he can be kept
Jordan McMahon, anyone seen Callan Ward today or Scott Selwood lol. We should have kept the pick
Matthew Richardson,Great player, wont see success at Richmond, should retire and save his body
Shane Tuck, tries hard, wont take us to any great heights though.
Brett Deledio, Star- one of afew. Should ask to be traded if we dont make finals in 2009.
Trent Cotchin, see Brett Deledio
Adam Pattison, Not happening with Adam, should be shopped around end of 2008
Richard Tambling, Some good, mostly not so good, should be shopped around end of 2008. Disappointing, I really wanted Richie to succeed.
Nathan Brown, wasted his career coming to Richmond, should be shopped around end of 2008
Jack Riewoldt, hes a keeper but has a long long way to go.
Mitch Morton can play but has been disappointing the last few weeks
Troy Simmonds, he needs to be kept coz we have no other ruckman
Kane Johnson, should retire at seasons end.
Nathan Foley, should be kept overall a good season.
Shane Edwards, shows potential, very small, who knows
Jake King, sorry Jake, Id be trading you at seasons end
Daniel Jackson, I think Daniel is 25 to 30 ranked player on a list
Matt White, has improved this year so Id keep
In: Brown, Cartledge, Tivendale
Out: Nil
You dont have anything positive to say about our footy club, so FO back to Collingwood
-
We challenge for the finals, your kidding arent you. :banghead :banghead
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Yeah Campbell coaching would be a great move. Who better to teach Lids how to kick the ball 5 metres forward and 50 metres high.
You've now got zero credibility
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
-
I really couldn't see Buckley moving anywhere apart from the Pies. And wouldn't Leon Cameron be a mini Wallace seem to me he has followed him all over the place. So this leave Campbell and he's a good one as a replacement. He's a tough nut just what we need.
Wayne wants to Coach :thumbsup
Yeah Campbell coaching would be a great move. Who better to teach Lids how to kick the ball 5 metres forward and 50 metres high.
You've now got zero credibility
What sort of goose are you.
Wallet already has taught Cotchin to go sideways 10metres by foot when he is sitting at the 50 arc,
Lids leads the short kicks doesnt he :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
You are a complete MORON
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Ramps, dont waste your time with D/ Heads.
He hasnt been to the footy this year and obviously didnt see the game against Geelong where we continually chipped sideways and turned the ball over by foot :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
I felt sick today when I seen Cotchin kicking 10 metres sideways
-
I think hes upset that I mentioned that Deledio may want out eventually if he cant see success coming shortly. Richmond must keep Deledio at all costs imho. Make him captain in 2009 is a good start.
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Today none.
But we've seen enough over the season.
1. Reiwoldt showed he is going to be a leader at this footy club
2. Cotchin - see Reiwoldt
3. Deledio's best season
4. Tuck's best season
5. Moore's best season
6. Thursfield is going to be better than Gaspar
7. Tambling gaining confidence
8. Morton showed he can kick goals
9. Games against Dogs and Lions
10. Winning 3 times interstate Freo, Eagles and Port
Save the call for going back to the drawing board for next season.
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Today none.
But we've seen enough over the season.
1. Reiwoldt showed he is going to be a leader at this footy club
2. Cotchin - see Reiwoldt
3. Deledio's best season
4. Tuck's best season
5. Moore's best season
6. Thursfield is going to be better than Gaspar
7. Tambling gaining confidence
8. Morton showed he can kick goals
9. Games against Dogs and Lions
10. Winning 3 times interstate Freo, Eagles and Port
Save the call for going back to the drawing board for next season.
so you attacked my assessment and then you posted what.... most of what you said correlates to what I said. Unfortunately, you are to quick to attack people in here. Read my assessment again, you will find you agree with most of what I have said lol.
-
1980 we've be going back to the drawing board for the last how many years. The fact is that Wallace can't coach and he has fooled us with spin for far too long.
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Ramps, dont waste your time with D/ Heads.
He hasnt been to the footy this year and obviously didnt see the game against Geelong where we continually chipped sideways and turned the ball over by foot :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
I felt sick today when I seen Cotchin kicking 10 metres sideways
You're putting Campbell forward as a supercoach?
A guy that made a career out of finishing 9th?
This club's given him enough, he go off and stuff another club up.
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Today none.
But we've seen enough over the season.
1. Reiwoldt showed he is going to be a leader at this footy club
2. Cotchin - see Reiwoldt
3. Deledio's best season
4. Tuck's best season
5. Moore's best season
6. Thursfield is going to be better than Gaspar
7. Tambling gaining confidence
8. Morton showed he can kick goals
9. Games against Dogs and Lions
10. Winning 3 times interstate Freo, Eagles and Port
Save the call for going back to the drawing board for next season.
1/ Reiwoldt, needs to do more. Looks okay in patches
2/ Cotchin, going to be a gun, needs a good coach though, not someone who wants him to kicks sideways 10 metres
3/ Lids, agree although he is a NO 1 draft pick, he is expected to perform
4/ Agree, although will find it hard to repeat next year, has had an excellent year.
5/ Agree
6/ Has had a good year, needs to find body strength. Got chopped up badly by Bradshaw. Dont know about being better than Gas though ?
7/ TOTALLY disagree, today just proved he has no idea in what he is doing out there, repeatedly gets caught, needs to be traded while there is some value there
8/ Morton, been patchy, last 3 weeks have been TERRIBLE! Coburg next week
9/ Dont get too carried away, I like the win against Brisbane, thanks for the memorys Richo and Joel, it was there game
10/ TOTALLY DISAGREE, three out of bottom 4 clubs lol your kidding
-
the truth hurts 1980. I understand your disappointment, but the reality is the reality. You tell us... what were the positives today :help
Ramps, dont waste your time with D/ Heads.
He hasnt been to the footy this year and obviously didnt see the game against Geelong where we continually chipped sideways and turned the ball over by foot :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
I felt sick today when I seen Cotchin kicking 10 metres sideways
You're putting Campbell forward as a supercoach?
A guy that made a career out of finishing 9th?
This club's given him enough, he go off and eff another club up.
Once again your not reading properly 1980, the title has 3 names Buckley, Hardwick and McCrae, others have suggested others
like campbell
-
1980 we've be going back to the drawing board for the last how many years. The fact is that Wallace can't coach and he has fooled us with spin for far too long.
I disagree. Wallace hasnt coached because he hasnt needed to. We only need to have one good year (next season) for him to be a hero.
And thats when we'll decide whether we're going back to the drawing board. And the footy gods better help us because another rebuild will be a lot to take
-
the club needs to ensure that it doesnt lose its best young players, it needs to draft smart this year and trade smart, we dont need a full rebuild we just need to create the 2nd layer of young talent to go with the first, but if we start losing our best young kids then we will be a rabble for the next 20 years.
Deledio, Cotchin et al, they will all want to see the side improve and give them a chance for the ultimate reward, if they cant see a chance to win a premiership at Richmond they may do an Ottens and tonight atleast 2 posters have said that we will lose atleast 1 good young player that supposedly wants out. I dont know who that is but it better not be Deledio.
-
2/ Cotchin, going to be a gun, needs a good coach though, not someone who wants him to kicks sideways 10 metres
FFS Jack is this gonna be the next one you use ad nauseum. It's about the sixth time I've read you use this one tonight.
You have something like 4 lines and you repeat them 200 times a day...looks like you now have five...
-
Hardwick would be a very good get as coach
-
2/ Cotchin, going to be a gun, needs a good coach though, not someone who wants him to kicks sideways 10 metres
FFS Jack is this gonna be the next one you use ad nauseum. It's about the sixth time I've read you use this one tonight.
You have something like 4 lines and you repeat them 200 times a day...looks like you now have five...
FFS Fwoy3, its the truth isnt it.
-
1980 we've be going back to the drawing board for the last how many years. The fact is that Wallace can't coach and he has fooled us with spin for far too long.
I disagree. Wallace hasnt coached because he hasnt needed to. We only need to have one good year (next season) for him to be a hero.
And thats when we'll decide whether we're going back to the drawing board. And the footy gods better help us because another rebuild will be a lot to take
Pretty simple, too many ""light weights"" on the list, we are going no where
-
You're putting Campbell forward as a supercoach?
A guy that made a career out of finishing 9th?
This club's given him enough, he go off and eff another club up.
funny you should say that, his been working at another club all year. stay in touch with footy
-
Pretty simple, too many ""light weights"" on the list, we are going no where
agree
-
I think hes upset that I mentioned that Deledio may want out eventually if he cant see success coming shortly. Richmond must keep Deledio at all costs imho. Make him captain in 2009 is a good start.
If we lose lids ill seriously consider not renewing my membership next year.
I will be so gutted. I really think Otto has set an example that if u want success u have to leave the rfc, especially with a dud like leather face as coach.
Make lids captain right now. newman goodbye!! Its our only hope at getting some descent draft picks.
-
Lids has to be captain.
Foley VC
-
2/ Cotchin, going to be a gun, needs a good coach though, not someone who wants him to kicks sideways 10 metres
FFS Jack is this gonna be the next one you use ad nauseum. It's about the sixth time I've read you use this one tonight.
You have something like 4 lines and you repeat them 200 times a day...looks like you now have five...
FFS Fwoy3, its the truth isnt it.
Jack, I don't necessarily disagree with stuff you say, but the incessant spamming got tiring sooooooooooo long ago. You have your views. Do you have to repeat them and hit refresh every three minutes. Some of us read each post, not just the last entry :banghead
-
Lids has to be captain.
Foley VC
Jack l dont think Foley has what it takes to be Captain or Vice Captain in the future.
he struggles now to break tags & with added preasure would destroy him
l reckon just let him play good football for a few seasons then access
-
I just wanna hear from MOOSE again :lol
-
A think some people around here need to take a breath and stop sensationalizing things.
Apparently Lids and Cotch are leaving and we need to rebuild or the earth will explode or something like that...I'm probably missed some of the finer points with that summary. :)
Take a step back and review our situation unemotively -
1 We have moved from the bottom of the ladder last season with 3 and a half wins to still being in contention for the finals and winning 8 and a half games with three still to play. This year we actually still had a chance at this stage of the season where over the last 7 years previously I had already turned my attention to the draft camps Progress
2 We have more depth to our list with players such as Rance, Putt, Connors, Meyer, Cogs, Collard and Collins not even playing this year because spots are hard to get. In previous years players such as Tiv and Petts had to be played and our young draftees had to be rushed in. Now we actually have the luxury of giving them time and space to develop and choosing players on form. Progress
3 Our backline and forwardline structures are young developing teams instead of being reliant upon players such as Bowden and Richo. We look stronger and less predictable (Richo back at FF last game showed why he needs to now play up the ground - injury?)
I think your mail on Lids is wrong. I know someone who works directly with the players day in day out and they tell me the playing group are happy, unified and keen to stick together to achieve future success.
Stripes
-
Do I like TW or his style? NO
Has this year been an Improvement? Yes
Is he going anywhere ? NO
I dont know here some of the crap that gets stated as FACTs comes from but trying to scare poeple saying we are going to loose a player is just crazy. Fact is we have a draft/trade system and is very hard to loose a good player without getting someting good back.
As far a coaching goes, it is not going to change. There is no succuesful coach that is saying "get me now or miss out" out there so why would we change (please no Sheedy talk :banghead). Getting rid of TW for some untried coach does not appeal to me.
As far as "Kick it to me Campbell" goes as a coach, are you kidding :help. He didnt know how to win on the field how is he going to teach Kids to win. Run behind to get a handpass or bomb it on guys heads is not going to win games nowdays (and didnt win in his day either).
-
As far as "Kick it to me Campbell" goes as a coach, are you kidding :help. He didnt know how to win on the field how is he going to teach Kids to win. Run behind to get a handpass or bomb it on guys heads is not going to win games nowdays (and didnt win in his day either).
Fluffy Tiger, you cant judge a player by his onfield playing career, at a club that was in turmoil in his time, to his coaching career, its totaly 2 very different things.
Not forgetting he is a 5 times B&F winner & one of Tigerlands favorite sons, so he must have something to offer back to the game
l seen poo players become good coaches, l seen alot of players who were injured most thier careers, (example Neil Daniher ) become good coaches, & l seen B&F winners & champions crumble at coaching, some people are good senior coaches but cant coach juniors & vice versa. Its like putting someone in your company as CEO hoping they can be successful at why you placed them there or go down the tubes
l'm not convinced Campbell would be a good coach myself & until l see him coach a side in any league at senior level or TAC U18's then he shouldnot be judged harshly. He is from what l know personally & from what l been told a very tactical assistant coach at Western Bulldogs with Leon Cameron under Rodney Eade & the Bulldogs are in 3rd position so something is working out there at Western Oval cause they aint got a team of mega stars & are a small forward unit but getting the job done quietly
l personally donot want untried coaches coming into Richmond FC cause we been used as a TAFE for years, but who knows Campbell might know what our club needs & has Yellow & Black flowing through his veins. Lets hope his makes a wise choice & follows the path of coaching elsewhere & learn the ropes like others before taking on the biggest tasks
-
If I had to choose then it would be Hardwick by the length of the Flemington straight. Would be nice to get Buckley as an assistant, but I can't really see that happening unless he really wanted to coach Cotchin as he can barely say enough good things about him when commentating.
Campbell I'd have as an assistant coach at the most, questionable playing history and little coaching experience, I wouldn't want him in charge.
Hardwick is a dual premiership player at two different clubs, highly regarded coaching ability and decent success at lower levels. Was never a superstar player, but was a defender and won premierships, that's fits the same type of bio that guys like Worsfold, Malthouse & Sheedy had as players, a few others too.
-
Yep would choose Hardwick by a long long way but just can't see it happening. Why would he want to leave Hawthorn who a making a tilt for the flagto come to us? Unless he can sense he might get the top job here.
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
-
Something has got to give :help
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
& you be gobsmacked back into your corner for bagging someone who actually has a bit of knowledge of what is going on around the club ;D
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
I would think some people would be rather nervous if this move isn't successful.
I know I would be if I'd undermined the club and stabbed everyone in the back to get a coach who's passed it and a player not exactly universally admired as a tag team coaching team lol
You would have to think a grand final and nothing less would be the only way you could justify such a move.
If they got us into a grand final, that would be fantastic. If we didn't make the finals - GULP, I'd be shaking in my boots lol
Our club is a farce if all this is correct.
Hopefully sanity will prevail :pray
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
It's the Jack Daniels show...
(http://edgruberman.stuff-daniels-label-5000384.jpg)
-
Lock up the wine cabinet if Sheeds is coming back lol
:cheers
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Why would that be Moi ?
The club will offer him, he will give something back to the club.
Not rape it of $600,000 a year for no return , which is currently the case.
I reckon the rubbish us fans put up with the weekend takes the cake, low life, you kidding
The low life were seen laughing in the coaching box as all us supporters are bleeding, WAKE UP MOI
-
Lock up the wine cabinet if Sheeds is coming back lol
:cheers
You are a complete idiot MOI.
How has 2 glasses of Red a night been a crime
-
Lock up the wine cabinet if Sheeds is coming back lol
:cheers
You are a complete idiot MOI.
How has 2 glasses of Red a night been a crime
:rollin
If it was Wallace you'd be calling him a drunk!
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
Another club leak?
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
I would think some people would be rather nervous if this move isn't successful.
I know I would be if I'd undermined the club and stabbed everyone in the back to get a coach who's passed it and a player not exactly universally admired as a tag team coaching team lol
You would have to think a grand final and nothing less would be the only way you could justify such a move.
If they got us into a grand final, that would be fantastic. If we didn't make the finals - GULP, I'd be shaking in my boots lol
Our club is a farce if all this is correct.
Hopefully sanity will prevail :pray
Your funny, you want to give Wallet 5 years for what ?????? No result. :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
I would think some people would be rather nervous if this move isn't successful.
I know I would be if I'd undermined the club and stabbed everyone in the back to get a coach who's passed it and a player not exactly universally admired as a tag team coaching team lol
You would have to think a grand final and nothing less would be the only way you could justify such a move.
If they got us into a grand final, that would be fantastic. If we didn't make the finals - GULP, I'd be shaking in my boots lol
Our club is a farce if all this is correct.
Hopefully sanity will prevail :pray
your saying a player like Campbell is not admired at Tigerland your deluded
your one out of maybe 100 supporters out of 30,000+ speaking for the club :rollin
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
Another club leak?
[/quote
Nah, I just talk crap 24/7 ::)
See what Hutchy says tonight. ;)
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
I would think some people would be rather nervous if this move isn't successful.
I know I would be if I'd undermined the club and stabbed everyone in the back to get a coach who's passed it and a player not exactly universally admired as a tag team coaching team lol
You would have to think a grand final and nothing less would be the only way you could justify such a move.
If they got us into a grand final, that would be fantastic. If we didn't make the finals - GULP, I'd be shaking in my boots lol
Our club is a farce if all this is correct.
Hopefully sanity will prevail :pray
Your funny, you want to give Wallet 5 years for what ?????? No result. :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
And you want to give to a coach that no-one wanted and another from the worst era our club's seen.
Terrific :thumbsup
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
If that's the case, I think Sheeds is the biggest low life of all time.
If all the garbage you say is true, would be the biggest self-serving exercise of all time.
Heaven help them and a few others if they're not successful ;)
Please explain MOI?? Low life???
It would be the best thing for this football club make no mistake about that.
One thing you can be sure of is that sheeds/campo ticket will NOT laugh at the players if they make a clanger.
That was the final straw for me seeing that. It is TW who is a low life piece of poo
I would think some people would be rather nervous if this move isn't successful.
I know I would be if I'd undermined the club and stabbed everyone in the back to get a coach who's passed it and a player not exactly universally admired as a tag team coaching team lol
You would have to think a grand final and nothing less would be the only way you could justify such a move.
If they got us into a grand final, that would be fantastic. If we didn't make the finals - GULP, I'd be shaking in my boots lol
Our club is a farce if all this is correct.
Hopefully sanity will prevail :pray
your saying a player like Campbell is not admired at Tigerland your deluded
your one out of maybe 100 supporters out of 30,000+ speaking for the club :rollin
Nah she is one of maybe 50 supporters out of 30,000.
29,950 would love to see Cambo and sheeds back at punt road.
I dont think the minority wins Monk, do you ?? :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol
-
your saying a player like Campbell is not admired at Tigerland your deluded
your one out of maybe 100 supporters out of 30,000+ speaking for the club :rollin
JohnF liked him. I'm struggling to think of too many others who did.
And you can be darn sure the honeymoon will last five seconds after the first loss lol
-
2 words.
ALISTAIR CLARKSON
-
your saying a player like Campbell is not admired at Tigerland your deluded
your one out of maybe 100 supporters out of 30,000+ speaking for the club :rollin
JohnF liked him. I'm struggling to think of too many others who did.
And you can be darn sure the honeymoon will last five seconds after the first loss lol
You would be the most narrowed mined person I have ever met.
Wayne Campbell is a champion bloke and has outstanding footy knowledge.
-
If Campbell's chosen, I'd imagine there'd be quite a few who won't like it.
We'll just have to wait and see.
-
If Campbell's chosen, I'd imagine there'd be quite a few who won't like it.
We'll just have to wait and see.
No where near the amount that dislike the snake oil skin salesman
-
If Campbell's chosen, I'd imagine there'd be quite a few who won't like it.
We'll just have to wait and see.
No where near the amount that dislike the snake oil skin salesman
I have to keep reminding myself that you are a disgruntled ex-employee with an axe to grind.
Takes away from your credibilty a little.
:sleep
-
We know what we're gonna get with Wallet. All he is, is a salesman, nothing more. This club has to move forward. Although I dont think it would smart to throw Campbell into the deep end just yet, I'm sure he would be welcomed as an assistant. Jackstar do these Willams/Hardwick whispers have any substance?
-
You're putting Campbell forward as a supercoach?
A guy that made a career out of finishing 9th?
This club's given him enough, he go off and eff another club up.
funny you should say that, his been working at another club all year. stay in touch with footy
Is he the senior coach their Mr. Football?
Is he going to take over from eade?
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
Rubbish post of the week
-
your saying a player like Campbell is not admired at Tigerland your deluded
your one out of maybe 100 supporters out of 30,000+ speaking for the club :rollin
JohnF liked him. I'm struggling to think of too many others who did.
And you can be darn sure the honeymoon will last five seconds after the first loss lol
You would be the most narrowed mined person I have ever met.
Wayne Campbell is a champion bloke and has outstanding footy knowledge.
Campbell was a tool, and an average football that only the RFC in its worst ever era would be desperate enough to idolise.
And an average bloke that conspired with Frawley to slash Knighter.
And he wanted to be drafted to North.
And he was Nick Daffy's best mate and boyfriend
Selfish footballer, had a hand in undermining several coaches, always looked out for himself first on and off the park, played for himself and his stats.
You're a joke putting him up as a Richmond football club hero
-
Nah she is one of maybe 50 supporters out of 30,000.
29,950 would love to see Cambo and sheeds back at punt road.
I dont think the minority wins Monk, do you ?? :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol
l agree with you jack
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
Rubbish post of the week
You want to have ago at Wallace for laughing in the box when Wayne Campbell was taking the pi ss his entire career.
Dont come on here acting all inside knowledge. Its a public fact for all to see Campbell was one of several players who choked on the last game of the year on more than one occasion when we needed to win to make the 8 and play in finals the following week.
Great coaching credential on his cv
Its also known to more than those that claim to be insiders that on one of those occasions, the players were debating out on the ground during the game about which pub they were going to after the siren.
Sums up perfectly the era that some supporters are yearning for us to return to.
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
Stop posting rubbish then
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
Rubbish post of the week
You want to have ago at Wallace for laughing in the box when Wayne Campbell was taking the pi ss his entire career.
Dont come on here acting all inside knowledge. Its a public fact for all to see Campbell was one of several players who choked on the last game of the year on more than one occasion when we needed to win to make the 8 and play in finals the following week.
Great coaching credential on his cv
Its also known to more than those that claim to be insiders that on one of those occasions, the players were debating out on the ground during the game about which pub they were going to after the siren.
Sums up perfectly the era that some supporters are yearning for us to return to.
Campbell bled for the RFC thats why he stayed there his whole career.
He left the club before he reached 300 games because he thought he didn't deserve to make it to 300 and that for me is a very unselfish footballer.
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
Stop posting rubbish then
just watch soon when Gary March grabs the door handle & opens the door its coming ;D can let you know there is more than one walking out that door without the club blessings, watch who walks in ;D
-
Campbell bled for the RFC thats why he stayed there his whole career.
He left the club before he reached 300 games because he thought he didn't deserve to make it to 300 and that for me is a very unselfish footballer.
& he was offered to reach the milestone but declined, very unselfish footballer indeed ;D
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
Rubbish post of the week
You want to have ago at Wallace for laughing in the box when Wayne Campbell was taking the pi ss his entire career.
Dont come on here acting all inside knowledge. Its a public fact for all to see Campbell was one of several players who choked on the last game of the year on more than one occasion when we needed to win to make the 8 and play in finals the following week.
Great coaching credential on his cv
Its also known to more than those that claim to be insiders that on one of those occasions, the players were debating out on the ground during the game about which pub they were going to after the siren.
Sums up perfectly the era that some supporters are yearning for us to return to.
Campbell bled for the RFC thats why he stayed there his whole career.
He left the club before he reached 300 games because he thought he didn't deserve to make it to 300 and that for me is a very unselfish footballer.
You're making me cry lol
What a hero ::)
:rollin
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
Stop posting rubbish then
just watch soon when Gary March grabs the door handle & opens the door its coming ;D can let you know there is more than one walking out that door without the club blessings, watch who walks in ;D
Cannot wait ;)
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
Stop posting rubbish then
just watch soon when Gary March grabs the door handle & opens the door its coming ;D can let you know there is more than one walking out that door without the club blessings, watch who walks in ;D
And lets see how many supporters turn up to games when it happens.
I was out there in the very cold outer the last time a favorite son coached this club, watching us getting flogged every week and cheering on the rare occasion some bloke like Mitchell took a mark. And there were very few out there with me.
Doesnt take much for supporters to desert this club. Graeme Richmond knew it. So should Tony Free. He played his best footy in front of 1,000 supporters wearing yellow and black in the stands
-
l agree, any coach who laughs at pathetic errors is on the chopping block.
l send a letter of my disgust to the club telling them my memberships for 2009 willnot be renewed if they going to have a clown like that coaching the Richmond football club
Nowhere near as bad as Wayne Campbell and co laughing and talking about where they were heading out that night during the last game of the season when we needed to win to make the 8.
Did you renew your membership then?
Rubbish post of the week
You want to have ago at Wallace for laughing in the box when Wayne Campbell was taking the pi ss his entire career.
Dont come on here acting all inside knowledge. Its a public fact for all to see Campbell was one of several players who choked on the last game of the year on more than one occasion when we needed to win to make the 8 and play in finals the following week.
Great coaching credential on his cv
Its also known to more than those that claim to be insiders that on one of those occasions, the players were debating out on the ground during the game about which pub they were going to after the siren.
Sums up perfectly the era that some supporters are yearning for us to return to.
Campbell bled for the RFC thats why he stayed there his whole career.
He left the club before he reached 300 games because he thought he didn't deserve to make it to 300 and that for me is a very unselfish footballer.
Dont know you from a bar of soap mate, but you post like a 5 year old. How about you see your first premiership before you post about what it takes to be a Richmond legend. Or at least learn what bleeding for a club really means
-
Buckley or Hardwick
need a coach that wants disipline
-
Richmond will announce at seasons end a joint venture with appointment of Sheedy/Campbell as a partnership ;)
Another club leak?
[/quote
Nah, I just talk crap 24/7 ::)
See what Hutchy says tonight. ;)
What bit was I supposed to listen to?
-
get hold of yourself 1980 :rollin
Stop posting rubbish then
just watch soon when Gary March grabs the door handle & opens the door its coming ;D can let you know there is more than one walking out that door without the club blessings, watch who walks in ;D
And lets see how many supporters turn up to games when it happens.
I was out there in the very cold outer the last time a favorite son coached this club, watching us getting flogged every week and cheering on the rare occasion some bloke like Mitchell took a mark. And there were very few out there with me.
Doesnt take much for supporters to desert this club. Graeme Richmond knew it. So should Tony Free. He played his best footy in front of 1,000 supporters wearing yellow and black in the stands
haha you dont go to games if you think only 1000 supporters turn up thats delusional 1000 supporters :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
-
Been some very interesting and passionate posts in this thread, especially the more recent ones re: Campbell. Like most weeks, I prefer not to post much straight after a game - win, lose or draw, as I don't much think much good or sense comes from emotionally-heightened responses. But what I do know is that some of the comments on Campbell's character are so far off beam that those who have embarrassed themselves by writing them should be ashamed. Do I think he will make a good senior coach - maybe but more likely not. Do I think he will make a good assistant coach - probably. Do I think Richmond will benefit by him coming back in any capacity - maybe but not as senior coach. Do I think he has the positive character traits that would fit in with the culture our club is trying to build - I don't have to 'think' about it - I know it for an absolute fact.
-
Wayne Campbell is an outstanding individual, your on the money there Smokey :thumbsup
And something the club does need
-
So the Campbell bashers must think the Western Bulldogs & its supporters are stupid for employing Campbell as a assistant coach.
Aint it strange we dont hear thier supporters Campbell bashing & they were in the same hole as us a few seasons back but sit 3rd & are playing finals while Richmond can only dream. 1980 & Moi know thier football so much better than a finals contender so Campbell must be doing his job getting through down there ;D
-
Been some very interesting and passionate posts in this thread, especially the more recent ones re: Campbell. Like most weeks, I prefer not to post much straight after a game - win, lose or draw, as I don't much think much good or sense comes from emotionally-heightened responses. But what I do know is that some of the comments on Campbell's character are so far off beam that those who have embarrassed themselves by writing them should be ashamed. Do I think he will make a good senior coach - maybe but more likely not. Do I think he will make a good assistant coach - probably. Do I think Richmond will benefit by him coming back in any capacity - maybe but not as senior coach. Do I think he has the positive character traits that would fit in with the culture our club is trying to build - I don't have to 'think' about it - I know it for an absolute fact.
Which of the following comments about Wayne Campbell are embarrasing?
1) He quit the club
2) Was a senior player in a club that needed to win its last game to make the finals and didnt more than once
3) Split the player group with his feud with the club captain Knights
4) Demanded and got a huge pay increase in 95 at a club that made its first finals in 13 years
5) Hugged the boundary line his entire career
6) He was a stats bandit (I wont take credit for that nic- stole it from someone else)
7) Got injured celebrating a goal
8) Always looked over his shoulder when he got the ball because he was so scared of getting hit
9) Never put his body on the line- even daffy (finally) did his shouder for the team
I've seen 4 premeirships mate, only one of which I was too young to remember. Seen the best and worst at this footy club and know which players played for the jumper and which ones looked out for themselves. So dont go telling me i should be ashamed of myself for having a go at an average footballer who played in an average team and is being heldup on here as some kind of club savior
-
Been some very interesting and passionate posts in this thread, especially the more recent ones re: Campbell. Like most weeks, I prefer not to post much straight after a game - win, lose or draw, as I don't much think much good or sense comes from emotionally-heightened responses. But what I do know is that some of the comments on Campbell's character are so far off beam that those who have embarrassed themselves by writing them should be ashamed. Do I think he will make a good senior coach - maybe but more likely not. Do I think he will make a good assistant coach - probably. Do I think Richmond will benefit by him coming back in any capacity - maybe but not as senior coach. Do I think he has the positive character traits that would fit in with the culture our club is trying to build - I don't have to 'think' about it - I know it for an absolute fact.
Which of the following comments about Wayne Campbell are embarrasing?
1) He quit the club
2) Was a senior player in a club that needed to win its last game to make the finals and didnt more than once
3) Split the player group with his feud with the club captain Knights
4) Demanded and got a huge pay increase in 95 at a club that made its first finals in 13 years
5) Hugged the boundary line his entire career
6) He was a stats bandit (I wont take credit for that nic- stole it from someone else)
7) Got injured celebrating a goal
8) Always looked over his shoulder when he got the ball because he was so scared of getting hit
9) Never put his body on the line- even daffy (finally) did his shouder for the team
I've seen 4 premeirships mate, only one of which I was too young to remember. Seen the best and worst at this footy club and know which players played for the jumper and which ones looked out for themselves. So dont go telling me i should be ashamed of myself for having a go at an average footballer who played in an average team and is being heldup on here as some kind of club savior
I have seen 5 flags.
Wayne Campbell was far from an average football.
How many best and fairests ?????????????
More than you I bet. He bled yellow and black.
Why dont you have a go at Wallet getting $600,000 a year and delivering nothing?
And whats even worse, getting his mates to the club on inflated contracts and money.
Just jolt your memory.
Wayne Johnson.
Monkhurst
Royal
King
Amstrong( reported to be on $200,000 a year, for what, dodging press interviews and organsing accommadation for interstate trips.
King
Gordon Casey ( he went out with black and white TV )
and you bag Wayne Campbell. FFS
-
Been some very interesting and passionate posts in this thread, especially the more recent ones re: Campbell. Like most weeks, I prefer not to post much straight after a game - win, lose or draw, as I don't much think much good or sense comes from emotionally-heightened responses. But what I do know is that some of the comments on Campbell's character are so far off beam that those who have embarrassed themselves by writing them should be ashamed. Do I think he will make a good senior coach - maybe but more likely not. Do I think he will make a good assistant coach - probably. Do I think Richmond will benefit by him coming back in any capacity - maybe but not as senior coach. Do I think he has the positive character traits that would fit in with the culture our club is trying to build - I don't have to 'think' about it - I know it for an absolute fact.
Which of the following comments about Wayne Campbell are embarrasing?
1) He quit the club
2) Was a senior player in a club that needed to win its last game to make the finals and didnt more than once
3) Split the player group with his feud with the club captain Knights
4) Demanded and got a huge pay increase in 95 at a club that made its first finals in 13 years
5) Hugged the boundary line his entire career
6) He was a stats bandit (I wont take credit for that nic- stole it from someone else)
7) Got injured celebrating a goal
8) Always looked over his shoulder when he got the ball because he was so scared of getting hit
9) Never put his body on the line- even daffy (finally) did his shouder for the team
I've seen 4 premeirships mate, only one of which I was too young to remember. Seen the best and worst at this footy club and know which players played for the jumper and which ones looked out for themselves. So dont go telling me i should be ashamed of myself for having a go at an average footballer who played in an average team and is being heldup on here as some kind of club savior
I have seen 5 flags.
Wayne Campbell was far from an average football.
How many best and fairests ?????????????
More than you I bet. He bled yellow and black.
Why dont you have a go at Wallet getting $600,000 a year and delivering nothing?
And whats even worse, getting his mates to the club on inflated contracts and money.
Just jolt your memory.
Wayne Johnson.
Monkhurst
Royal
King
Amstrong( reported to be on $200,000 a year, for what, dodging press interviews and organsing accommadation for interstate trips.
King
Gordon Casey ( he went out with black and white TV )
and you bag Wayne Campbell. FFS
The only bleeding Campbell has done is out of his ars. Had the long girly hair and the soft kicks to go with it.
I've been on here all year slagging Wallace, and you've clapped when I've done it. And you now want to sack and replace him with Campbell or Sheedy? Swapping one opportunist for another one
Clueless.
If they're good enough to have Buckley or Mark Williams lined up, no arguments. Campbell is just an untried/unproven Frawley and Geishen all over again.
-
On face value, I reckon Hardwick of the untried coaches seems a good candidate.Premiership player at 2 clubs, now assistant at Hawthorn under Clarkson, was assistant at Port when they won a flag. Comes across as someone who can kick the poo out of people if they step out of line. Id prefer him to Campbell. Campbell needs to do more than just have been an assistant at Footscray.
-
Footscray have been 'real' successful now, haven't they :rollin
Out of all this I would say Hardwick, just MO ....
Fig Jam is just wrong in soooo many ways, besides it aint gunna happen anyway.
-
The only bleeding Campbell has done is out of his ars. Had the long girly hair and the soft kicks to go with it.
I've been on here all year slagging Wallace, and you've clapped when I've done it. And you now want to sack and replace him with Campbell or Sheedy? Swapping one opportunist for another one
Clueless.
If they're good enough to have Buckley or Mark Williams lined up, no arguments. Campbell is just an untried/unproven Frawley and Geishen all over again.
you dont read posts
So the Campbell bashers must think the Western Bulldogs & its supporters are stupid for employing Campbell as a assistant coach. THIS YEAR ????
Aint it strange we dont hear thier supporters Campbell bashing & they were in the same hole as us a few seasons back but sit 3rd & are playing finals while Richmond can only dream. 1980 & Moi know thier football so much better than a finals contender so Campbell must be doing his job getting through down there at the WESTERN BULLDOGS in 2008 under Rodney Eade
-
The only bleeding Campbell has done is out of his ars. Had the long girly hair and the soft kicks to go with it.
I've been on here all year slagging Wallace, and you've clapped when I've done it. And you now want to sack and replace him with Campbell or Sheedy? Swapping one opportunist for another one
Clueless.
If they're good enough to have Buckley or Mark Williams lined up, no arguments. Campbell is just an untried/unproven Frawley and Geishen all over again.
you dont read posts
So the Campbell bashers must think the Western Bulldogs & its supporters are stupid for employing Campbell as a assistant coach. THIS YEAR ????
Aint it strange we dont hear thier supporters Campbell bashing & they were in the same hole as us a few seasons back but sit 3rd & are playing finals while Richmond can only dream. 1980 & Moi know thier football so much better than a finals contender so Campbell must be doing his job getting through down there at the WESTERN BULLDOGS in 2008 under Rodney Eade
Yeah I heard you the first time, I just didnt bother answering such a dumb comment.
If you wanted to be clever, you would have argued that we should have gotten Eade instead of Wallace.
I'm sure the bullies supporters are giving all the credit to a first time assistant at his first club instead of Eade.
-
1980 & Moi know thier football so much better than a finals contender so Campbell must be doing his job getting through down there at the WESTERN BULLDOGS in 2008 under Rodney Eade
My argument against Campbell is, is he the best coach available.
Not knocking his ability because I don't think many people would know how good he is.
Oh, unless of course you're Jack because he knows everything lol
-
Why dont you have a go at Wallet getting $600,000 a year and delivering nothing?
And whats even worse, getting his mates to the club on inflated contracts and money.
Just jolt your memory.
Wayne Johnson.
Monkhurst
Royal
King
Amstrong( reported to be on $200,000 a year, for what, dodging press interviews and organsing accommadation for interstate trips.
King
Gordon Casey ( he went out with black and white TV )
and you bag Wayne Campbell. FFS
I have a challenge for you Jackstar. Here it is - don't mention any coaches for one week! :pray
Can you do it?! I know it would be difficult for you.
When you speak about other topics other than TW you make a lot of sense but all of that gets lost admidst the Wallace-Hate talk. If you could just stick to discussing the topic, which you can been very good at, rather than twisting every thread into another opportunity to belittle our current coach then I for one would be keen to listen to everything you say.
At the moment though I just skim over what you write at the first mention of TW.
Give the challenge a go :thumbsup
Stripes
-
I have a challenge for you Jackstar. Here it is - don't mention any coaches for one week! :pray
Can you do it?! I know it would be difficult for you.
When you speak about other topics other than TW you make a lot of sense but all of that gets lost admidst the Wallace-Hate talk. If you could just stick to discussing the topic, which you can been very good at, rather than twisting every thread into another opportunity to belittle our current coach then I for one would be keen to listen to everything you say.
At the moment though I just skim over what you write at the first mention of TW.
Give the challenge a go :thumbsup
Stripes
It would be too easy for Jack.
He would just get his alter ego (the Daniel part of the Jack Daniels duology)to do all the yapping.
-
Why dont you have a go at Wallet getting $600,000 a year and delivering nothing?
And whats even worse, getting his mates to the club on inflated contracts and money.
Just jolt your memory.
Wayne Johnson.
Monkhurst
Royal
King
Amstrong( reported to be on $200,000 a year, for what, dodging press interviews and organsing accommadation for interstate trips.
King
Gordon Casey ( he went out with black and white TV )
and you bag Wayne Campbell. FFS
I have a challenge for you Jackstar. Here it is - don't mention any coaches for one week! :pray
Can you do it?! I know it would be difficult for you.
When you speak about other topics other than TW you make a lot of sense but all of that gets lost admidst the Wallace-Hate talk. If you could just stick to discussing the topic, which you can been very good at, rather than twisting every thread into another opportunity to belittle our current coach then I for one would be keen to listen to everything you say.
At the moment though I just skim over what you write at the first mention of TW.
Give the challenge a go :thumbsup
Stripes
Challenge accepted :thumbsup Shouldnt be too hard not being able to comment on insignificant people of this world. which he is
-
Why dont you have a go at Wallet getting $600,000 a year and delivering nothing?
And whats even worse, getting his mates to the club on inflated contracts and money.
Just jolt your memory.
Wayne Johnson.
Monkhurst
Royal
King
Amstrong( reported to be on $200,000 a year, for what, dodging press interviews and organsing accommadation for interstate trips.
King
Gordon Casey ( he went out with black and white TV )
and you bag Wayne Campbell. FFS
I have a challenge for you Jackstar. Here it is - don't mention any coaches for one week! :pray
Can you do it?! I know it would be difficult for you.
When you speak about other topics other than TW you make a lot of sense but all of that gets lost admidst the Wallace-Hate talk. If you could just stick to discussing the topic, which you can been very good at, rather than twisting every thread into another opportunity to belittle our current coach then I for one would be keen to listen to everything you say.
At the moment though I just skim over what you write at the first mention of TW.
Give the challenge a go :thumbsup
Stripes
Challenge accepted :thumbsup Shouldnt be too hard not being able to comment on insignificant people of this world. which he is
;D
-
Nuffer ;D
-
Which of the following comments about Wayne Campbell are embarrasing?
1) He quit the club
2) Was a senior player in a club that needed to win its last game to make the finals and didnt more than once
3) Split the player group with his feud with the club captain Knights
4) Demanded and got a huge pay increase in 95 at a club that made its first finals in 13 years
5) Hugged the boundary line his entire career
6) He was a stats bandit (I wont take credit for that nic- stole it from someone else)
7) Got injured celebrating a goal
8) Always looked over his shoulder when he got the ball because he was so scared of getting hit
9) Never put his body on the line- even daffy (finally) did his shouder for the team
I've seen 4 premeirships mate, only one of which I was too young to remember. Seen the best and worst at this footy club and know which players played for the jumper and which ones looked out for themselves. So dont go telling me i should be ashamed of myself for having a go at an average footballer who played in an average team and is being heldup on here as some kind of club savior
A more pertinent question would be how many of the following comments are known to be factually true and how many are just based on hearsay. Don't know the relevance of seeing 4 premierships - I've seen a number but it has zero to do with my comment. I said those who posted comments on Campbell's poor character should be ashamed - and they should. Do you know the guy personally? I do. And I can tell you that most of your comments above are not factual, just your opinions. Have your opinion about his footy exploits and coaching potential and voice them as loud and as passionately as you want but don't make unqualified and undignified comments about his character if you have never even met the guy. If you read my post you will notice I don't think he would be the best choice we could make as far as a coaching role goes but comments like "Campbell was a tool" and "And an average bloke" are just poor form.
-
Jack - I appreciate it. Looking forward to reading your posts.
Stripes
-
IN answer to original question by Ramps based on the crap in the media that we need Richmond people (whatever the eff that means) at the CLub none of then ames mentioned in the title of this thread are acceptable ::)
I am so angry at the moment that is isn't funny
I posted this in another thread because I did't want it get lost here:
Richmond people..... :banghead :banghead
I am Richmond person - do they want me at the Club?
I reckon they want my $$$ every year but I doubt they actually give S-hit about me.
I am sick to death of this crap and it is just absolute CRAP :banghead :banghead
This is the very reason we are joke.
Delude yourself and say it is the on field but it is the off field...
I am coterie member do I get a say? Oops sorry I am only a little fish coterie member, not one of the big fish groups so I don't get a say....
It's actually hystercial if you looked at the numbers, you'd find that the little fish coteries because of thier numbers contribute more $$$$ on a purely membership scale
Same old same old... people who think the RFC is their own personal play thing with their pathetic hidden agendas
That's why we are a bloody joke
Bloody well sick of it
PS: Apologies for the swearing folks but like Peter Fiinch said in Network "I am as mad as hell and I'm not going not take it anymore >:( :banghead
-
so williampowell, i see you are very upset, mad and frustrated. so what will you do about it?
-
IN answer to original question by Ramps based on the crap in the media that we need Richmond people (whatever the eff that means) at the CLub none of then ames mentioned in the title of this thread are acceptable ::)
I am so angry at the moment that is isn't funny
I posted this in another thread because I did't want it get lost here:
Richmond people..... :banghead :banghead
I am Richmond person - do they want me at the Club?
I reckon they want my $$$ every year but I doubt they actually give S-hit about me.
I am sick to death of this crap and it is just absolute CRAP :banghead :banghead
This is the very reason we are joke.
Delude yourself and say it is the on field but it is the off field...
I am coterie member do I get a say? Oops sorry I am only a little fish coterie member, not one of the big fish groups so I don't get a say....
It's actually hystercial if you looked at the numbers, you'd find that the little fish coteries because of thier numbers contribute more $$$$ on a purely membership scale
Same old same old... people who think the RFC is their own personal play thing with their pathetic hidden agendas
That's why we are a bloody joke
Bloody well sick of it
PS: Apologies for the swearing folks but like Peter Fiinch said in Network "I am as mad as hell and I'm not going not take it anymore >:( :banghead
Biggest joke is the coach . $2.4 million he has sucked out of the place. And we will have to pay him another $600,000 for him to walk at years end :banghead
-
yes terry is a joke, and it is very amusing how many people are unhappy with what is happening at the rfc, but so supportive of miller and wallace. well miller is gone, terry will be next. dont these angry people realise that the mess we are in now has nothing to do with spud anymore, but we are still crap thanks to miller and wallace. yet their are supporters who still buy his spin and think he is the answer. 4 years on , the "train wreck" he inherited, is still a fricken "train wreck" . so all you angry tigers, start asking the questions, why after 4 years are we still a wreck. well miller could answer that but he is gone, and wallace wont because he will just come up with more spin
-
so williampowell, i see you are very upset, mad and frustrated. so what will you do about it?
Well I wont go around sending foul mouthed SMS messages to people saying I told you so - like I received on the weekend but I digrese ......
Perhaps I should pull my $$$'s out and downgrade my membership.... would save me a lot
But then again when you think about it that would make me just as bad as the faceless ones wouldn't it.
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
and I answered it
I told you what I wouldn't do ....
Because I have no intention of holding the club to ransom like some people with their hidden agendas and threats
Does that explain it for you
-
yes and no.
but i see you are a pat benatar fan. it is good to dream, but at times one must be realistic, and admit miller failed us and it is good he is gone, and terry has failed us. but , one has his/her right to keep on dreaming
-
yes and no.
but i see you are a pat benatar fan. it is good to dream, but at times one must be realistic, and admit miller failed us and it is good he is gone, and terry has failed us. but , one has his/her right to keep on dreaming
100% correct.
our drafting under Miller and Solarium was as good as Spuds in my opinion.
Tambling, mcmahon, Patto, Meyer, JON- all first round draft picks and are all duds lets be honest.
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
X is an idiot that thinks he's not :lol
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
X is an idiot that thinks he's not :lol
for Geez sake get off X's case,
-
yes and no.
but i see you are a pat benatar fan. it is good to dream, but at times one must be realistic, and admit miller failed us and it is good he is gone, and terry has failed us. but , one has his/her right to keep on dreaming
It's funny watching X trying to use correct punctuation to hide himself. Look at all those commas. Don't forget the capital letters now X.
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
X is an idiot that thinks he's not :lol
for Geez sake get off X's case,
after u get out of his arse
-
Biggest joke is the coach . $2.4 million he has sucked out of the place. And we will have to pay him another $600,000 for him to walk at years end :banghead
Well you lasted half a day Jack :D Your hatred knows no bounds my friend.
I wonder if the next coach comes in in 5 years or so, you will be as animated and spiteful.
A waste of a clever poster I say.
Stripes
-
Campbell would be a mistake IMHO. Not becasue of personality but becasue he is untried and because of the style of game he played. I know Jack will say "Clarkson", but if pressed I am sure I could come up with two failures as first time coaches for every success.
Sheedy would be a bigger mistake. He is regraded as some sort of great thinker but I just dont see it. I never have. Anyway he is past it, look at the train wreck of a team he left behind.
Sheedy and Campbell together. All I can say is please NO.
I have no inside info about any of this but I am still entilled of my opinion on this subject.
Spin or no spin, right or wrong, I do think the Club should show that when we say we are going to give a guy 5 years to do something , we give the guy 5 years to do it. I hate seeing the crap we got dished up on the weekend just as much as anybody and I have never been a fan of TW but he got 5 years. That all there is to it. I am sure there are few here that want TW out that would be screaming if they had a contract and it got broken.
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
X is an idiot that thinks he's not :lol
for Geez sake get off X's case,
after u get out of his behind
l'm not up his ass so stop being stupid & grow up. His entitled to his opinion just like we all are.
If he changes his name or whatever who cares, his still a passionate Richmond supporter & paying for his memberships.
he comes to this site to talk about the same things & if you got a problem with him then do it via PM ;D
-
best of luck with all this. :lol
-
just asking a question, even though parts of your answer were somewhat confusing
X is an idiot that thinks he's not :lol
for Geez sake get off X's case,
after u get out of his behind
l'm not up his ass so stop being stupid & grow up. His entitled to his opinion just like we all are.
If he changes his name or whatever who cares, his still a passionate Richmond supporter & paying for his memberships.
he comes to this site to talk about the same things & if you got a problem with him then do it via PM ;D
If u call it discussion........ :wallywink