Jake Batchelor [merged]

[Yeahright]

Better player than Pettard.

No he's not.

Yes he is and if you don't agree your just accepting mediocrity

No. They're both mediocre but Batch is worse.

How so?

I tend to agree with MM. Petterd has shown he can dominate at VFL level. Last week he played one half and had 20 possessions. I don't think Batch has ever dominated any game.

Same player except Pettard has more athleticism and maybe work ethic (not sure if Batch is just that slow or lazy)

[Phil Mrakov]

Batchelor is a way better kick than Riccki

[Penelope]

that's debatable

[Phil Mrakov]

that's debatable

batch hits targets

[Gigantor]

Batch might hit targets,but unfortunately so do his opponents...namely the target between the big sticks

[Phil Mrakov]

Batch might hit targets,but unfortunately so do his opponents...namely the target between the bick sticks

hes not a key defender

[Gigantor]

no..but a defender he is

[Penelope]

that's debatable

batch hits targets

sometimes....

[Phil Mrakov]

no..but a defender he is

should be a running Hbf that's all. Could be good on the wing to hitting forwards on the chest

[Chuck17]

no..but a defender he is

should be a running Hbf that's all. Could be good on the wing to hitting forwards on the chest

Unfortunately by that time the balls been chipped sideways and back ways and all the opposition is camping in our forward 50

[Yeahright]

no..but a defender he is

should be a running Hbf that's all. Could be good on the wing to hitting forwards on the chest

Shanks it to much

[Mr Magic]

Well that went well.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Dimma destroyed him.
Had a good first year and started of 2012 well. Had a great game against the Pies in round 2 that year and was looking great. Could take an overhead mark, read the play and was tough with ground level skills also. Only question mark was his kicking.

Post that St Kilda game at the dome in 2012 he has gone downhill. Had a terrible game against Freo the following week and then put another stinker the following week against GWS and he has never looked back.

[tdy]

Player            Club     Kicks    Handballs    Disposals    Marks    Hit-outs    Frees For    Frees Agst Tackles    Goals    Behinds    AFL Fantasy
Jake Batchelor    RICH  5        4        9        4        0        0        1        1        0        0        36

9 possies, gee whiz.  They really have to play him elsewhere to see if he can do something better.

[Diocletian]

Played well when we were on top and poo when we weren't. Hardly Robinson Crusoe on that score.