Welcome everyone to One-Eyed Richmond's Tiger Forum Cheers from mightytiges and WilliamPowell.
Quote from: Mrakov on November 21, 2013, 08:24:21 PMWhat do people think of Carlton's first selection ?Why are you so obsessed with other clubs? WGAF..............
What do people think of Carlton's first selection ?
Why can't we discuss other club's picks? It's a draft thread not an RFC selection thread.
Quote from: one-eyed on November 21, 2013, 07:21:02 PM4. Doggies - BontempelliMight rue that selection according to their supporters
4. Doggies - Bontempelli
Freeman is a gun Melbourne. You have to take him!
no complaints from me. we gave a couple state league players a go with latish picks. ive been asking we do that sort of thing for awhile now. my only gripe is i think there was a super talent available in marsh and i would have liked us to use either 50 or 66?? on him.12/ lennon was not one of my picks but hes highly rated by most. acres or dunstan for me. 50/ would have liked to take jonathon marsh or james sicily here. i think there was a few here who have shown enough and had enough talent to use this pick on.66??/ geez marsh was still there and so was cameron darcy. cant work out what went wrong with marsh. all i can think of is he must have interviewed very poorly. with basically the last pick in the draft collingwood imo potentiallly got the biggest steal of it.the thing i would have liked us to do is not promote petterd and use the extra pick on what imo are some talented kids still available.the other thing i ask and question is would lloyd and gordon have still been available even later or as rookie picks. id say the odds are good they would have been.i worry that we have added just one 18 yr old. would have thought at least two picks could have gone to youth. im now hoping we address that with a few 18yr olds in the rookie draft.it seems in many ways they are locked and loaded to borrow a frawleyism.finally good luck to all three recruits i really hope the state leaguers do well in particular and open peoples eyes to how valuable players from these leagues can be.so for me straight after the draft i would have gone12 acres50 marsh66 darcy cameron80 ish gordon and not promoted petterd. rookie lloyd. i think the last two is where we should have taken them or tried to.
Quote from: the claw on November 21, 2013, 09:33:43 PMno complaints from me. we gave a couple state league players a go with latish picks. ive been asking we do that sort of thing for awhile now. my only gripe is i think there was a super talent available in marsh and i would have liked us to use either 50 or 66?? on him.12/ lennon was not one of my picks but hes highly rated by most. acres or dunstan for me. 50/ would have liked to take jonathon marsh or james sicily here. i think there was a few here who have shown enough and had enough talent to use this pick on.66??/ geez marsh was still there and so was cameron darcy. cant work out what went wrong with marsh. all i can think of is he must have interviewed very poorly. with basically the last pick in the draft collingwood imo potentiallly got the biggest steal of it.the thing i would have liked us to do is not promote petterd and use the extra pick on what imo are some talented kids still available.the other thing i ask and question is would lloyd and gordon have still been available even later or as rookie picks. id say the odds are good they would have been.i worry that we have added just one 18 yr old. would have thought at least two picks could have gone to youth. im now hoping we address that with a few 18yr olds in the rookie draft.it seems in many ways they are locked and loaded to borrow a frawleyism.finally good luck to all three recruits i really hope the state leaguers do well in particular and open peoples eyes to how valuable players from these leagues can be.so for me straight after the draft i would have gone12 acres50 marsh66 darcy cameron80 ish gordon and not promoted petterd. rookie lloyd. i think the last two is where we should have taken them or tried to.Here you say 'no complaints from me' but in the other thread you say our ND 'left a lot to be desired' and that you were 'certain we could have done better'.You happy or not, bra?
