Deledio off to GWS in exchange for future first & third round picks [confirmed]

[Knighter]

Caddy total Brownlow votes = 8

Prestia got 13 in 2014 alone.

The computer says Caddy plodder, Prestia good and Big Tone wrong

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

People aren't happy with our deals because they suck.

So you think Lids (who wants to go) and a straight swap for Caddy isn't a good deal for us?

or would you rather the club cave into geelong's demand of Lids + pick 27 for Caddy and say that's a better deal?

Or perhaps you want them to do a Hawthorn'esq deal for Lids? Pick 50 odd?

Caddy for Lids is a win for us.

Nothing wrong with that deal it doesn't suck.

Simple facts are (1) if Geelong want him it's on our terms not their's. If they wont' accept a fair a reasonable trade then Lids comes back, re stocks his locker and we move on

And (2) we can throw up the likes of Edwards, Ellis B, Lennon, etc but if no one wants them or they don't agree to a trade then they don't go

 



Geelong not prepared to do that deal is not the Club's fault

Caddy is slightly better than Conca. He is slow and lacks endurance. Will be another list clogged in a few years bank on it

Caddy is better than that mate.
I'd take Caddy over Prestia any day.

You'd be about the only one. Caddy and Prestia both had promising early years. A few years later and Prestia was VC behind Gaz and Caddy had moved to Geel and averaged barely 20 pos per game in a very good midfield.

[The Machine]

People aren't happy with our deals because they suck.

So you think Lids (who wants to go) and a straight swap for Caddy isn't a good deal for us?

or would you rather the club cave into geelong's demand of Lids + pick 27 for Caddy and say that's a better deal?

Or perhaps you want them to do a Hawthorn'esq deal for Lids? Pick 50 odd?

Caddy for Lids is a win for us.

Nothing wrong with that deal it doesn't suck.

Simple facts are (1) if Geelong want him it's on our terms not their's. If they wont' accept a fair a reasonable trade then Lids comes back, re stocks his locker and we move on

And (2) we can throw up the likes of Edwards, Ellis B, Lennon, etc but if no one wants them or they don't agree to a trade then they don't go

 



Geelong not prepared to do that deal is not the Club's fault

Caddy is slightly better than Conca. He is slow and lacks endurance. Will be another list clogged in a few years bank on it

Caddy is better than that mate.
I'd take Caddy over Prestia any day.

 

[MintOnLamb]

Who's your Caddy?

[🏅Dooks]

Presta>Caddy >Conca

[1965]

Who's your Caddy?

Very clever, did you think that one up?

 

[Andyy]

Prestia>Caddy>>>>>Conca

EFA :



And FWIW on Brownlow votes:
Prestia - 23 from 95 games @ 0.24/game
Caddy - 8 from 95 games @ 0.09/game
Conca - 3 from 80 @ 0.04/game

All debuted the same year too...

[Stalin]

WGAF brownlow votes

[Francois Jackson]

Right GWS give us that mid teen pick for lids

Cats FO

[Willy]

Yep, SEN saying Giants now into Lids.

[tony_montana]

Right GWS give us that mid teen pick for lids

Cats FO

This was the one I felt was the right fit for both Lids and GWS. If it happens, we will get better compensation than what the cats can offer us and Lids gets a good chance to experience ultimate success.

[🏅Dooks]

Prestia>Caddy>>>>>Conca

EFA :

And FWIW on Brownlow votes:
Prestia - 23 from 95 games @ 0.24/game
Caddy - 8 from 95 games @ 0.09/game
Conca - 3 from 80 @ 0.04/game

All debuted the same year too...

Yep. Im pickin up what you're putting down 

[🏅Dooks]

Yep, SEN saying Giants now into Lids.

What picks do GWS have to offer?

[Stalin]

It's on

Forza lids

[tony_montana]

Yep, SEN saying Giants now into Lids.

What picks do GWS have to offer?

Youd get a quicker answer if you asked "which picks don't GWS have to offer?"