Good call D, was touted as a gun in his draft year and was a first round pick but has not developed as expected.
Quote from Knightmares assessment of him( at the start of his TAC season) possibly gong pick 5.
" As a best available selection, Brodie would be a terrific compliment to Patrick Cripps in tight as one of this year's standout stoppage players. Brodie, 189cm, 82kg, is an immediate player who wins first possession at stoppages and displays excellent speed, agility and work-rate by position. He is a proven performer against mature VFL bodies and lifts when the game is on the line".
After four seasons you would have to call bust on him being an A grader but at the right price might end up being a solid C+ player.