Shane Edwards [merged]

[Francois Jackson]

Played a physical game well.

Needs to do the same against quality opposition who are more physical and apply pressure

what game were you watching?

He is hopeless, cant even stick a tackle if his life depended on it.

[Mr Magic]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

[Francois Jackson]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

I watched the game very closely dont worry about that.

Who played great today.

Graham
Ellis
Dusty
Conca
Chaplain
Jack
liked Hoili and Grigg today also.

Edwards is not one of those who played great as you say, so i suggest you get your mouth out of his date and watch the game again.

Your comments on the club rating him. Interesting, perhaps that's why we have won 3 games all year when we have to rely on this dud pulling out a descent game more than once a month which never happens.

[🏅Dooks]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

I watched the game very closely dont worry about that.

Who played great today.

Graham
Ellis
Dusty
Conca
Chaplain
Jack
liked Hoili and Grigg today also.

Edwards is not one of those who played great as you say, so i suggest you get your mouth out of his date and watch the game again.

Your comments on the club rating him. Interesting, perhaps that's why we have won 3 games all year when we have to rely on this dud pulling out a descent game more than once a month which never happens.

this is mad talk.

i might add the people you question here are professionals. for example Mr Magic has been around senior grade football for 22 years.

[Francois Jackson]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

I watched the game very closely dont worry about that.

Who played great today.

Graham
Ellis
Dusty
Conca
Chaplain
Jack
liked Hoili and Grigg today also.

Edwards is not one of those who played great as you say, so i suggest you get your mouth out of his date and watch the game again.

Your comments on the club rating him. Interesting, perhaps that's why we have won 3 games all year when we have to rely on this dud pulling out a descent game more than once a month which never happens.

this is mad talk.

i might add the people you question here are professionals. for example Mr Magic has been around senior grade football for 22 years.

WGAF. he has an opinion and i do also.  Just to give you an insight into some others who have been in the game for over 22 years

Spud
T Wallace
Jeff Gieschen

How was their track record at identifying talent?

Edwards is a spud only blind men cant see that. Its why we will never challenge for a flag.

[🏅Dooks]

suggest you watch the replay please

[bojangles17]

Running into a nice vein of form ye old titch, keep it up

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Opposition had some very damaged witches hats after Titchs game yesterday

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Opposition had some very damaged witches hats after Titchs game yesterday

 

[big tone]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

I watched the game very closely dont worry about that.

Who played great today.

Graham
Ellis
Dusty
Conca
Chaplain
Jack
liked Hoili and Grigg today also.

Edwards is not one of those who played great as you say, so i suggest you get your mouth out of his date and watch the game again.

Your comments on the club rating him. Interesting, perhaps that's why we have won 3 games all year when we have to rely on this dud pulling out a descent game more than once a month which never happens.

You think Ellis played well? IMO 30 odd meaningless touches.... Again. I must admit a watch him more closely than most and yesterday his efforts to tackle and more importantly HOLD a tackle were putrid. 
I prefer Grigg than this bloke. And Houli.
He will never change so get rid of him while we can.
Makes me angry even thinking about him.

[the claw]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

how many yrs have you backed this hack in for now. backed yourself so far into a corner you only see the little bit of good he does. talk about blinkered.
8 yrs in and hes basically at where he started. just one short period where he  consistently performed a role to a decent level. but boy he sure as hell reverts back to mediocrity soon enough.

i dont know what game you watched magic but it was another typical edwards game where he does one or two nice things gets plenty wrong and disappears for huge chunks of games.
the only redeeming part to his game has been him winning a bit of contested ball.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Hopefully he can play like yesterday ALL the time. Club has backed him. He has to extract the digit on a consistent basis now.

[🏅Dooks]

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

how many yrs have you backed this hack in for now. backed yourself so far into a corner you only see the little bit of good he does. talk about blinkered.
8 yrs in and hes basically at where he started. just one short period where he  consistently performed a role to a decent level. but boy he sure as hell reverts back to mediocrity soon enough.

i dont know what game you watched magic but it was another typical edwards game where he does one or two nice things gets plenty wrong and disappears for huge chunks of games.
the only redeeming part to his game has been him winning a bit of contested ball.

Suggest you watch the replay too. had a good game.

15 silk quality disposals 3 marks 2 tackles and a goal. played a physical game too with plenty of hip n shoulders, hard sheppards and many other team orientated 1 percenters.

ill take his game over a 25 odd possesion game which is ineffective that the likes of houli grigg and others keep churning out

[the claw]

Hopefully he can play like yesterday ALL the time. Club has backed him. He has to extract the digit on a consistent basis now.

he got another two yrs he doesnt have to extract a thing. if yesterday was good enough for you we are accepting mediocrity.
hes no longer a kid hes a 26yo 120 odd game player who should be serving up much more than that.

Thought he played great and showed exactly why he is rated by the club. Some need to open their eyes.

how many yrs have you backed this hack in for now. backed yourself so far into a corner you only see the little bit of good he does. talk about blinkered.
8 yrs in and hes basically at where he started. just one short period where he  consistently performed a role to a decent level. but boy he sure as hell reverts back to mediocrity soon enough.

i dont know what game you watched magic but it was another typical edwards game where he does one or two nice things gets plenty wrong and disappears for huge chunks of games.
the only redeeming part to his game has been him winning a bit of contested ball.

Suggest you watch the replay too. had a good game.

15 silk quality disposals 3 marks 2 tackles and a goal. played a physical game too with plenty of hip n shoulders, hard sheppards and many other team orientated 1 percenters.

ill take his game over a 25 odd possesion game which is ineffective that the likes of houli grigg and others keep churning out

watched it closely and his game was ordinary as i said supporters it seems are very accepting of mediocrity.

[🏅Dooks]

suggest you watch the replay please.

hes never going to win the brownlow but hes in our best 22 BY FAR and would be at any other club.

What sort of output is a pass for him in your eyes?