Shane Edwards [merged]

[Mr Magic]

Some people just like to complain about everything and usually those that do are miserable sacks in real life.

[Francois Jackson]

Some people just like to complain about everything and usually those that do are miserable sacks in real life.

nice deflection pal but not everyone just spuds like the following

Tambling Edwards
Graham
Grigg
Newman

remove them from our list now and we are sorted.

[🏅Dooks]

He owes nobody nothing.

Give him a break guys there are plenty of guys which the blowtorch should be crqnked up on and Titch is not one of them. FACT

think you need to get off the shawitzi mate.

The only facts in this subject are

1. I am right
2. Tambling has done SFA apart from 26 out of a possible 130 games.

1. Incorrect.
2. Incorrect again.

[Smokey]

The only facts in this subject are

1. I am right

   POTY Dan!  Spoken like a true OERite.   

[WA Tiger]

Edwards was good yesterday his work away from the ball was very good

However, let's not get carried away the Giants were non competitive yesterday, everyone looked good 

Truest comment to date!! Stupid to take anything out of this IMO. Beat Nth and the Bombers by the same (well at least win) and I will be a bit more satisfied, lose are we are no better than we have been all year and that's pooe.

[Chuck17]

Edwards was good yesterday his work away from the ball was very good

However, let's not get carried away the Giants were non competitive yesterday, everyone looked good 

Truest comment to date!! Stupid to take anything out of this IMO. Beat the Bombers next week by the same and I will be a bit more satisfied, lose are we are no better than we have been all year and that's pooe.

Well let's hope the boys pull through for you then

[🏅Dooks]

Stupid to take anything out of this IMO. Beat Nth and the Bombers by the same (well at least win) and i will be s bit more satisfied.

This is the last time im going to say it. Please watch the replay before you make comment on Edwards game.

[Francois Jackson]

Stupid to take anything out of this IMO. Beat Nth and the Bombers by the same (well at least win) and i will be s bit more satisfied.

This is the last time im going to say it. Please watch the replay before you make comment on Edwards game.

which part was i supposed to be watching?

[Judge Roughneck]

Is shredder worse than

Houli
Jackson
Thomas
Grigg

?

I believe this to be a more pertient question as opposed to "Edwards is shyte end of delist and replace with draft pick 200"

[Francois Jackson]

yes he is by a fair margin. He is equal to Angus Hampson as the worst player i have seen wear the jumper.

[Diocletian]

Dreamtime over for this year, got to toss the coin, no further reason to pick him now.

[mat073]

He will be the worst Richmond player to ever reach 150 games .

[Hellenic Tiger]

He will be the worst Richmond player to ever reach 150 games .

After he retires having played 300 games in 2022 coincidentally the year prior to our next finals window is open the club will award a medal at the Jack Dyer Medal to the player on the list who will clog the list like a bronchial 75 year old more than any other but remain on the list.

They will call it the Phlegm Award and it will have Titch image on it.

The Skata Cycle. 32 years and counting. Plop Plop Plop.©

[Willy]

Love how we defend our players these days.. "well we have others who are even pooer"

[the claw]

yes he is by a fair margin. He is equal to Angus Hampson as the worst player i have seen wear the jumper.

i agree.

how many are we going to cut both list proper and rookies. to me at least 6 from the list proper 3 rookies.
 for me list proper
newman retire
azza retire.
king retire,
batchelor delist.
vickery/griffiths  trade. one of.

leaves one to go from
edwards,ohanlon, helbig, petterd, knights, foley,
would have cut edwards here if he was uncontracted.

rookies
stephenson
darrou
thomas.
banfield.

sad thing is theres another 10 i would not be surprised to see cut at some stage. the thing that nags me though is why cut anyone unless we get better with our recruiting.