Jackson is a far better footballer at his best than Edwards at his best.
But really this year it was like watching dumb and dumber.
Edwards year was summed up by one piece of play in the second Bumbers game. Great mark in the back pocket followed by a beautiful kick into the man on the mark. He is like a learner driver trying to fit into a tight parallel park you don't want to watch, can't look away, and it takes him forever to it right.
Not good enough, prefer others.
What about the piece of play when he marked played on and delivered in the 1st bumbers game.. Selective memory
People need to remember that he was K.O'd during the season and also carried an injury in the second half of the year.. Shane is a bloody good player and that is why he is playing in the side each and every week.
i left a different forum because i was so sick and tired of players being bagged out each and every week. i am hoping this one isnt the same. i dont mind a player being criticised but to just mindlessly dump on a player isnt what supporting a team is about to me..
Jackson is poo compared to Edwards, and that's saying something. Edwards has the ability to be a good solid serviceable player, but for whatever reasons (injury, no pre season etc) his 2011 was backward on his 2010. Needs to get back to the 2010 form and improve on that and then WAT will shut his mouth.
Shane should be the first to admit he has shown very little in the 5 odd years he has been at the club, if he is satisfied with his performances to date than that is a worry indeed. I dont think that would be the case though.
