Shane Edwards [merged]

[WA Tiger]

Since when do you not like Shane Edwards? Geez you flip flop 

 

[yellowandback]

Edwards was one of few highlights from our performance last night.
I hope he makes it because he brings others into the game. We don't have enough players who can do that

[WA Tiger]

Ok round 1 .........stuffing useless, 1 good tackle, 1 good pass! This guy is stuffing pathetic..... I have waited all preseason, well he tore up the preseason track.....

stuffing worse player in the team!!!

[Judge Roughneck]

Whatd we make o jacksons game

[Dubstep Dookie]

Whatd we make o jacksons game

*toilet flushes*

[TigerTimeII]

Edwards was not the problem
Foley tuck Jackson.nahas vickery and miller all did sweet fa
Foley tuck and Jackson should never play again.... Bad disposal bad decision makers they are poo

[Hellenic Tiger]

Foley was much better than you think.

Jackson and Edwards are the whipping boys.

Edwards is this. When the game is hot and in dispute he is fumbly, indecisive with poor disposal and critically turns the ball over. A classic example set shot from 40 in the first quarter misses. If we were 8 goals up against Freo at the G 28 mins into the last quarter he kicks it and those Edwards admirers say but he has great skills and composure. For them I say take a look at the first and third quarters of our game against Collingwood last year and let the prosecution finally rest please.

[Francois Jackson]

Foley our problem?? Gee I've heard it all now

The margin would've been 100 if weren't for him and Cotch

Get your glasses of X. Bottom tier of Edwards, Jackson, Tuck, Post etc are our problem

They are collectively as good as my white ass after a bout of diarrhea.

[TigerLand]

Foley our problem?? Gee I've heard it all now

The margin would've been 100 if weren't for him and Cotch

Get your glasses of X. Bottom tier of Edwards, Jackson, Tuck, Post etc are our problem

They are collectively as good as my white ass after a bout of diarrhea.

Bottom tier is shortening each year.

3 years ago Jackson was one of our more important players, the list is improving talent wise, slowly.

[Smokey]

Whatd we make o jacksons game

Crap.

[WA Tiger]

Foley was much better than you think.

Jackson and Edwards are the whipping boys.

Edwards is this. When the game is hot and in dispute he is fumbly, indecisive with poor disposal and critically turns the ball over. A classic example set shot from 40 in the first quarter misses. If we were 8 goals up against Freo at the G 28 mins into the last quarter he kicks it and those Edwards admirers say but he has great skills and composure. For them I say take a look at the first and third quarters of our game against Collingwood last year and let the prosecution finally rest please.

Thank God someone else see's this, he was a disgrace last night, he bad very far outweighs his.......well he doesn't have a best.

Bag Jackson yes, but gee have a real good look people at this guy too. He will not be part of a GF team at this club.

[WilliamPowell]

Did Edwards play? 

Noticed him about half a dozen times for the entire game.

He was poor like so many others

We continue to rely on too few needing to do too much

But like Jackson, Edwards wasn't the worst as that had to be Post & Vickery

And as I said that is an indictment on last nights game

[Stripes]

Really there were very few standouts last night. The ball was hard fought and contested almost the whole game so few players could be sighted. There were a few acts of individual brilliance Yarran's and Jack's goals but most players were swallowed up in the packs.

I can't remember seeing Edwards do much and Jackson did a few ordinary kicks. Miller started with a bang but our forwards weren't really given a chance because of midfielders couldn't get any space  close to the 50 to deliver it to them. It was mostly all long bombs from out the back of a pack. This gave the defenders more than a=enough time to spoil and congest the forward arc. Vickery was anyother who suffered from this.

[Willy]

Vicks had a stinker. He had numerous oopporutnities to impose himself but just couldn't clunk em. Needs to lift.

[tony_montana]

cant keep carrying edwards and Jackson as part of the midfield rotations, they are super bad.

Who can replace them? Conca and Batchelor straight in. Who else? Helbig needs to come on, hopefully Arnott builds up his tank and can start getting some games as a sub. We need more foot soldiers!