Shane Edwards [merged]

[Francois Jackson]

Open your eyes pal

Pfft. The irony. He's been good up forward for us this season but I wasn't impressed one bit yesterday. Struggled when asked to fill Conca's role.

I said 75% of games

I agree his quick  hands is very good but I've seen too many times against good opposition revert back to the Edwards of old. Missed handballs from 1 metre away, slipped tackles.

We differ cause you see him part of a premiership team, I don't.

Would love for the RFC to show some balls and trade one of he or Nahas but they wont

[WA Tiger]

Honestly what another insiped performance.

Easy games, easy goals and some of you think he is the juice.....WAKE UP!

He is pathetic, trade him now, Tambling was better FFS...

 

[Big Papa Bear]

Poor game yesterday after a string of consistent ones. Needs to stand up in the games against better opposition. Still year has been good overall

[TigerTimeII]

he still was better than half 3/4 our other players and our pathetic captain

[tigercub2012]

he still was better than half 3/4 our other players and our pathetic captain

  x52,809

[camboon]

LOL  - Crack that whip , I vote we recruit another whipping boy for next year - ours just have improved too much, ( well maybe not all of them - but Titch and Rancey have)  - I hear that theres a couple of small forwards that can be played in the midfield that would suit the position beautifully!

If your hungry have a snack on your own - very satisfying - mmm yum

[the claw]

had a shocker imo. can forgive one bad one in 10 or 12, in the past the bad ones have become the norm lets hope that doesnt happen again.

[Yeahright]

Honestly what another insiped performance.

Easy games, easy goals and some of you think he is the juice.....WAKE UP!

He is pathetic, trade him now, Tambling was better FFS...

 

You've been surprisingly quiet about Edwards lately

[Frustrated]

Honestly what another insiped performance.

Easy games, easy goals and some of you think he is the juice.....WAKE UP!

He is pathetic, trade him now, Tambling was better FFS...

 

You've been surprisingly quiet about Edwards lately

 

Edwards has at least taken a few steps forward not like Graham, McGuane and co. 

[Loui Tufga]

Honestly what another insiped performance.

Easy games, easy goals and some of you think he is the juice.....WAKE UP!

He is pathetic, trade him now, Tambling was better FFS...

 

You've been surprisingly quiet about Edwards lately

 

Edwards has at least taken a few steps forward not like Graham, McGuane and co. 

FFS! Even Frustrated can see it

[one-eyed]

VIDEO: Titch interviewed in the rooms after the game yesterday ...

http://bigpondvideo.com/RichmondTV/486414/In%20the%20rooms:%20Edwards/

[Big Papa Bear]

Positives - goal kicking, tackling(?), endurance, pace, forward pressure

Negatives - strength, accuracy

Assessment: Retain - still in the red for ROI, so needs to keep improving this year and provide a consistant effort. Also needs to get more of the ball in midfield to provide back up option

[Stripes]

I'm very interested to see who we keep in our best 22 next year in the small forward role. Assuming we get Knights that would mean we have Nahas, King, Edwards and Knights fighting for 2 spots (Maric will be delisted surely). King has so far claimed the defensive small forward role so who will be able to fill this role of King is missing and who will be our crumber/midfielder?

Nahas is the most in danger here. Knights and Edwards are much more capable of rotating through the midfield than Nahas who is till far too slight. Maybe Edwards and Knights will rotate between the midfield/wing and forwardline going forward?

[Loui Tufga]

I'm very interested to see who we keep in our best 22 next year in the small forward role. Assuming we get Knights that would mean we have Nahas, King, Edwards and Knights fighting for 2 spots (Maric will be delisted surely). King has so far claimed the defensive small forward role so who will be able to fill this role of King is missing and who will be our crumber/midfielder?

Nahas is the most in danger here. Knights and Edwards are much more capable of rotating through the midfield than Nahas who is till far too slight. Maybe Edwards and Knights will rotate between the midfield/wing and forwardline going forward?

Knights is a Half Forward Flanker/Midfielder, not a small forward. Would play a completely different roll to any of those three.....

[JVT]

Positives - goal kicking, tackling(?), endurance, pace, forward pressure

Negatives - strength, accuracy

Assessment: Retain - still in the red for ROI, so needs to keep improving this year and provide a consistant effort. Also needs to get more of the ball in midfield to provide back up option

Positive: positioning/crumbing packs