Shane Edwards [merged]

[Chuck17]

In a rich vein of form is Edwards , handling gate pill like its on a string and showing a clean pair of heels just quietly , PA wouldn't wanna take him lightly 

Since he is about 50 kilos most other sides cant help but take him lightly

[WA Tiger]

Waste of space...wake up...

Have a look what he does with his disposals....shanks and turns them over..

I suppose Ellis is in Brownlow form based on Edwards crap..

[eliminator]

Turning 26 this year. Not been able to produce good games consistently and has struggled against the better teams. Against Brisbane was very good but the season is over and that win counts for nothing. Maybe worth trying to trade him. If we are going to succeed tough decisions need to be made and he stands out as one that consideration should be given to trading.

[WilliamPowell]

Thought it was one of his better games on Saturday

He has had a shocking year that's not in dispute but on Saturday he certainly wasn't the worse. Was in the best 6-10 IMHO

well woopty stuffin do

remind me who we played again and remind me where we are on the ladder.

These downhill skiers play descent footy when the season is shot and we go from the hunted to hunter to quote caro, because the little tamblings cant handle the pressure.

So which part of "he's had a shocking year" didn't you understand?

Thought he played well on Saturday that's all, doesn't hide how bad he's been majority of the year

Well aware of who we played, just like when we played GWS and St Kilda, players look great but I've said let's not get carried away with any of them 

[Yeahright]

He was rubbish yet again, get easy gaols but he was useless, poor skills again and thrown around like a rag doll.....STILL!!!

You have 0 credibility after that comment. Bang on as much as you want about how he's a dud and it's hard to defend but to say he was rubbish yet again proves you have blinkers on and can't admit he had a good game

[Tigers of Old]

It was only against Brisbane but he did play really well in a midfield role and to suggest otherwise is pretty silly.
Hopefully can follow it up against Port.

[Hellenic Tiger]

In a rich vein of form is Edwards , handling gate pill like its on a string and showing a clean pair of heels just quietly , PA wouldn't wanna take him lightly 

Sure is played his one good game for the year against inexperienced and weak opposition.
Trade now while the price is less skata than next week.

Expect his next game when he contributes in a meaningful way some time in mid 2015

[Chuck17]

He was rubbish yet again, get easy gaols but he was useless, poor skills again and thrown around like a rag doll.....STILL!!!

You have 0 credibility after that comment. Bang on as much as you want about how he's a dud and it's hard to defend but to say he was rubbish yet again proves you have blinkers on and can't admit he had a good game

I am convinced he didn't watch the game

[tony_montana]

Im not a fan but truth be told since he was made sub against Geelong he has been serviceable overall and deserving of his spot.. but prior to that, how he continued to get a game was perplexing to say the least. Like pettard, whilst im not a fan, they are both deserving of their place in our side as it currently stands, this time next year who knows but right now, there are players Id move before Shed and pettard.

[The Big Richo]

Got some stats to back that crap up?

Allan...

better give your sarcasm detector a tune up Bents.
thought the  may have been a give away....

Sorry,  got excited

Titch 

#1 for aboringalness too 

Is that you Dunc?

[WA Tiger]

Waste of space. 9 years of list clogging and listen to some of you lot, talking him up like he's the best in our team...

Unreal!!!!

[Chuck17]

Waste of space. 9 years of list clogging and listen to some of you lot, talking him up like he's the best in our team...

Unreal!!!!

No one is talking him up, they are just being honest and saying that he had a good game on the weekend, something you either did not or will not see.

[Smokey]

WAT's not going to agree with the coaches votes from last week then:

Richmond v Brisbane Lions
9 Shane Edwards (Rich)
7 Tyrone Vickery (Rich)
5 Alex Rance (Rich)
3 Brandon Ellis (Rich)
2 Justin Clarke (Bris)
2 Ivan Maric (Rich)
1 Trent Cotchin (Rich)
1 Pearce Hanley (Bris)

[Judge Roughneck]

Nine not ten... Wot

[Smokey]

Quiet thread this week, must have played ok.

He was rubbish yet again, get easy gaols but he was useless, poor skills again and thrown around like a rag doll.....STILL!!!

Did you actually watch the game WAT?

Shane Edwards produced his best performance of the season, kicking two goals and recording 27 disposals (13 contested), six inside 50s, three tackles and a team-high nine clearances.

http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2014-07-07/edwards-reaps-rewards