Shane Edwards [merged]

[Damo]

stuff Shed, had enough of the idiot

he needs to retire and retire now

poo post Dan
You’re better than that

[Francois Jackson]

stuff Shed, had enough of the idiot

he needs to retire and retire now

poo post Dan
You’re better than that

Why. He served us well but I have had enough. Cotch has earnt another year, as has Jack due to not having many other  choices. This guy has not.
That’s a fact. We might as play with 2 less players in him and George.

He needs to retire and should not play on.

[TigerLand]

Bit rough of Shed, he is definitely done but he's still in our best 22. Would prefer to have the ball in Sheds hands kicking for goal than Castagna or Aarts.

[Damo]

stuff Shed, had enough of the idiot

he needs to retire and retire now

poo post Dan
You’re better than that

Why. He served us well but I have had enough. Cotch has earnt another year, as has Jack due to not having many other  choices. This guy has not.
That’s a fact. We might as play with 2 less players in him and George.

He needs to retire and should not play on.

Calling him “the idiot” for starters

[the claw]

Has been horrible all year and should not be getting games but hey you cant blame edwards if they cannot make hard calls and keep on playing him every week.

Its laughable the way some players just keep on getting games week after week and its just mindboggling that so many have such obvious weaknesses and nothing is ever done about them.

Imo Aarts and Castagna's skills just paper over other players poor skills as they become the targets for them.

Its almost as if in come Castagna and Aarts and we hit critical mass in the poor skills stakes and it becomes a farce.

[Broadsword]

Its almost as if in come Castagna and Aarts and we hit critical mass in the poor skills stakes and it becomes a farce.

Agree with this and well described.

[Mr Magic]

I've been his no 1 fan for a long time but despite all his incredible achievements, Shedda's genuinely limping towards the 300 game milestone.
Started like a house on fire versus the Suns yesterday but unfortunately like many games this season couldn't sustain the level required for long enough.
Despite many thinking he could play forever ala Burgoyne, he has never really recovered from the troublesome ankle injury last year & has aged quickly.
I hope the Champ gets to 300 & wins another flag but it's looking increasingly unlikely & I'll be surprised if he's on our list next season.

[georgies31]

His the perfect sub cannot run out games what's the obsession get him to 300 has go play on merit.

[Tiger Khosh]

His the perfect sub cannot run out games what's the obsession get him to 300 has go play on merit.

He’d get to 300 even as the sub. But give me edwards as a small forward even in the twilight of his career over the likes of Castagna and aarts any day of the week.

[georgies31]

His the perfect sub cannot run out games what's the obsession get him to 300 has go play on merit.

He’d get to 300 even as the sub. But give me edwards as a small forward even in the twilight of his career over the likes of Castagna and aarts any day of the week.

We got Clarke,  Cumberland and Stack options there.

[Tiger Khosh]

His the perfect sub cannot run out games what's the obsession get him to 300 has go play on merit.

He’d get to 300 even as the sub. But give me edwards as a small forward even in the twilight of his career over the likes of Castagna and aarts any day of the week.

We got Clarke,  Cumberland and Stack options there.

Stack is injured atm but agree he should get a chance. Not sure if he’s back this season.

I’d still probably take sheds ahead of the other 2 while we are still “contending”. Even in the avg form he’s in his output is the same as the other 2 and who knows maybe he’ll give us a vintage performance or 2 in the finals if we make it.

[Andyy]

This guy is so done it's embarrassing. Slowww, poor disposal, can't get to a contest let alone compete in one.

[Rampsation]

We could be giving games to Banks instead. Shane should retire now. Hes not earning games on merit imho.

[Broadsword]

I mean at this point he has to get one more. They're all danger games now though, so not sure which.

Hell, it doesn't matter--he'll be playing next week.

[TigerLand]

Should be doing a Murphy and playing as the sub. Can't run out games.