Who would you play on Judd?

[one-eyed]

Who would you ppls play on Judd - Sugar or someone else?

Captain Kane Johnson will be the man handed the job of marking Chris Judd in his first serious game for Carlton - Link.

[1965]

oops, you didn't miss it at all...


 

[LondonTiger]

Long time no replies from me.  Been reading most threads. 

I hope Kane has put up his hand for this one.  What better way to exorcise the demons from last year keeping Judd quiet. 

If its not working, play Newman on him.  Or even Jackson as third choice.

I think Judd will be the least of our problems in their midfield.  Murphy, Carazzo and Simpson are apparently in good form.  Will be very interested in who gets selected in our midfield.  Starter for 10, Tuck, Tambling, Johnson and Polo.

[Jacosh]

a half fit Judd and a full fit Johnson sounds about even to me.
Leave Newman and Jackson to run around with Murphy and Carazzo.

[tigersalive]

Put Jackson on him to pummel him at every opportunity. 

No one needs to tag Carrazzo.  He never does any real damage, didnt last year anyway.  Lots of possessions, lack of impact.

[julzqld]

Rebecca Twigley

[wayne again]

 I would like to see Cogs come onto the ground and run straight up to Judd and play on him at least 10 min a quarter. My way of thinking this would send a message to Cogs that the coach, club and players believe that he too is a champion footballer and just as good as Judd. I think it would be a suprise for Judd as well. It could help cogs come on to the big stage big time. 90.000 at the ground watching Judd and sh#T loads around the country watching Judd will see the forgotten Tiger Champ run all over him.
  Why not ?? 

[richmondrules]

I would like to see Cogs come onto the ground and run straight up to Judd and play on him at least 10 min a quarter. My way of thinking this would send a message to Cogs that the coach, club and players believe that he too is a champion footballer and just as good as Judd. I think it would be a suprise for Judd as well. It could help cogs come on to the big stage big time. 90.000 at the ground watching Judd and sh#T loads around the country watching Judd will see the forgotten Tiger Champ run all over him.
  Why not ?? 

Not a bad idea wa. They are both coming back from injury after all so neither will be at their best. The only concern I would have is that Cogs may not have the pace to go with Judd. Not many do, but pace has never been one of Cogs outstanding qualities.

[Son of Dad]

Cogs definately doesn't have the legs to run with Judd...I say put Sugar or Tivendale on him in the hope that while keeping Judd to few possessions  , neither of them get too many chances to make clangers

[Tigermonk]

Cogs definately doesn't have the legs to run with Judd...I say put Sugar or Tivendale on him in the hope that while keeping Judd to few possessions  , neither of them get too many chances to make clangers

you need a quick reflex type player to tag Judd.  someone who can lay a strong tackle & stop him from getting the ball off
would have to have good endurance also to run with him l'm sure his close to fitness
cant think of anyone for the job

[wayne again]

Cogs definately doesn't have the legs to run with Judd...I say put Sugar or Tivendale on him in the hope that while keeping Judd to few possessions  , neither of them get too many chances to make clangers

Good point i just think for 10 minutes a quarter, especially the first ten minutes of the game will be a great buzz for him. He deserves the chance to rotate on Judd with perhaps Tiv or Johnstone. I think he would rise to the challange and set him off and running for the year.

[Francois Jackson]

Cogs definately doesn't have the legs to run with Judd...I say put Sugar or Tivendale on him in the hope that while keeping Judd to few possessions  , neither of them get too many chances to make clangers

you need a quick reflex type player to tag Judd.  someone who can lay a strong tackle & stop him from getting the ball off
would have to have good endurance also to run with him l'm sure his close to fitness
cant think of anyone for the job

u crack me up. so true though!!

[Francois Jackson]

my left testy would have a better chance of stopping judd than our captain.

he is not even worthy of a starting 22 let alone to play on judd

[bluey_21]

I'd say Polo, but don't think he will even be in the side come rd 1

[Mr Magic]

Sugar gets the gig.

If he can't tag effectively he should retire.