Ivan Soldo traded to Port [merged]

[Andyy]

At least we know Nank is more useful in the F50.

Soldo I have to say has been good at kicking his obligatory goals from 20m out when he draws a free or takes a random mark (most recent volley aside), but beyond that I wouldn't want him anywhere near the goal square compared to Nank or Chol.

Previously wasn't in favour of the Nank/Soldo combo, but Soldo really has come along some this year. I've changed my mind and wouldn't mind trying it vs Carlton.

[yandb]

Except for what I said only two days ago in another thread:

Nank & Slomo in the same side 🐌🐌

Try again zippy.

Good to see you are still about Diode and have made an appearance on THIS thread.

[big tone]

Soldo is still just a “fill in” IMO.

He has been competitive in the ruck since coming in but let’s be honest he isn’t a footballers hole.

The sooner Nank is back the better.

Nank and Chol is the way forward.

[Diocletian]

Except for what I said only two days ago in another thread:

Nank & Slomo in the same side 🐌🐌

Try again zippy.

Good to see you are still about Diode and have made an appearance on THIS thread.

Slomo's still a slow, plodding dud regardless of what thread the fact is stated in...

[georgies31]

Our best tap ruckman and best option  to combat the monster rucks in the afl who always kill Nank and struggles with.

[Diocletian]

...and yet Gawn still slaughtered him and was the only Melbourne player to receive multiple coaches votes....

[Tigeritis™©®]

If Chol can get rid of his lay-down-sally routine late in games we wouldn’t be talking about Soldo at all unless as just a reserve ruckman.

[pmac21]

Keep Soldo and bring in Nank.  Nank can play the Chol role up forward better then Mabs.
Nank is a gun, be great to have him back. 

[Tiger Khosh]

Was fantastic today. I’m sure his detractors will still find something negative to point to.

Nank is still undoubtedly our no.1 ruck for me, but I’m now a lot less pessimistic over how we would go without him.

[Andyy]

Getting better and better. Keeps his spot

[mightytiges]

Ordinary first quarter to be honest which gave the Eagles a couple of soft goals. However, improved markedly after that and clearly had the better of Hickey especially after half-time. 12 disposals, 6 clearances, 40 hitouts & a goal (and robbed of another) if a top return from Ivan.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

He was immense today.

[Owl]

He is coming along nicely, just gotta watch where he is tapping it sometimes

[Willy]

He was immense today.

Agreed.

[Diocletian]

Yeah golf claps...until he costs us a final with his clumsy dopey crap...