Jayden Short [merged]

[big tone]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

[Owl]

All I hear is loud noises

[Loui Tufga]

All I hear is loud noises

 

[WA Tiger]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

[🏅Dooks]

I love lamp. I love....table.....

[Penelope]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

agreed.

The use of the premierships played in stat to say that one player is better than another should only be used selectively and when it suits.

[the claw]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

LMFAO. I think if we are point scoring thats a knock out. Now as one of very few posters whose opinion on players i am prepared to trust to a degree !!!  where do you think Short sits in the scheme of things.

[Yeahright]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

The only idiot is the one who uses premierships medals as some sort of quantifier for a players abilities. The idiocy is only compounded by then claiming you can't compare two players by stats after they compared said players themselves.  Funny that I didn't make the distinction when I never compared Puopolo and Short to begin with

[big tone]

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

Well stuff I guess that makes Mitch Morton and anyone else with a premiership medal better than anyone on our team. Puopolo must be better than GAJ too

Only an idiot would make that comparison. So congratulations.
When you/others compare stats of players that play different rolls in their teams, especially 3x premiership players,  it's pretty senseless and pointless. Most with a brain would make that distinction but you being an idiot obviously didn't. So congrats again.

The only idiot is the one who uses premierships medals as some sort of quantifier for a players abilities. The idiocy is only compounded by then claiming you can't compare two players by stats after they compared said players themselves.  Funny that I didn't make the distinction when I never compared Puopolo and Short to begin with

You just proved yourself to be the idiot I think you are. I didn't compare the two players.  Go back and have a look and if you are any sort of a man you'll say you are an idiot and we can all move on with the conformation from the idiot that you are indeed an idiot. Congratulations 

[Owl]

My cock is bigger than yours

[YellowandBlackBlood]

My cock is bigger than yours

Owls don't have big ones. FACT.

[Yeahright]

You just proved yourself to be the idiot I think you are. I didn't compare the two players.  Go back and have a look and if you are any sort of a man you'll say you are an idiot and we can all move on with the conformation from the idiot that you are indeed an idiot. Congratulations 

Congrats and deserved short is next to jack as far as footy smarts go.....and his kicking

Is he as good as puopolo?
You are all dreaming if you think he is any good

Jayden Short.                             Paul Puopolo
20yo 16 games                           23yo    133 games
Height 177.   72kg.                     Height  173.    78kg
Averages.                                   Averages
Disposals 14.88                           Disposals 14.71
Kicks 11.81                                 Kicks 7.41
Marks 3.38.                                 Marks 2.41
Handballs 3.06                            Handballs 7.81
Goals 0.38                                  Goals 0.98


If it's Puopolo we're comparing with he's tracking along quite nicely....
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/J/Jayden_Short.html
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/P/Paul_Puopolo.html

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

There is your comparison right there you nuffer. So are you now man enough to admit you're in fact the idiot?

[🏅Dooks]

My cock is bigger than yours

Owls don't have big ones. FACT.

Man, its gonna be a long off season

You got anything you can prescribe doc?

[Chuck17]

You just proved yourself to be the idiot I think you are. I didn't compare the two players.  Go back and have a look and if you are any sort of a man you'll say you are an idiot and we can all move on with the conformation from the idiot that you are indeed an idiot. Congratulations 

Congrats and deserved short is next to jack as far as footy smarts go.....and his kicking

Is he as good as puopolo?
You are all dreaming if you think he is any good

Jayden Short.                             Paul Puopolo
20yo 16 games                           23yo    133 games
Height 177.   72kg.                     Height  173.    78kg
Averages.                                   Averages
Disposals 14.88                           Disposals 14.71
Kicks 11.81                                 Kicks 7.41
Marks 3.38.                                 Marks 2.41
Handballs 3.06                            Handballs 7.81
Goals 0.38                                  Goals 0.98


If it's Puopolo we're comparing with he's tracking along quite nicely....
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/J/Jayden_Short.html
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/P/Paul_Puopolo.html

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

There is your comparison right there you nuffer. So are you now man enough to admit you're in fact the idiot?

Just so it is clear to everyone my interpretation is as follows;

* Big Note didn't put up the initial comparison
* Big Note however did add to the initial comparison by adding another comparison factor ie premierships
* Big Note then went on to say because Puopolo was a premiership player x 3 that the other comparison factors where all stupid

To summarise Big Note has inferred by his posts that comparing Short and Puopolo is valid and the most material factor is premierships played.

If anyone else has a different interpretation of what has happened please advise.

[Go Richo 12]

You just proved yourself to be the idiot I think you are. I didn't compare the two players.  Go back and have a look and if you are any sort of a man you'll say you are an idiot and we can all move on with the conformation from the idiot that you are indeed an idiot. Congratulations 

Congrats and deserved short is next to jack as far as footy smarts go.....and his kicking

Is he as good as puopolo?
You are all dreaming if you think he is any good

Jayden Short.                             Paul Puopolo
20yo 16 games                           23yo    133 games
Height 177.   72kg.                     Height  173.    78kg
Averages.                                   Averages
Disposals 14.88                           Disposals 14.71
Kicks 11.81                                 Kicks 7.41
Marks 3.38.                                 Marks 2.41
Handballs 3.06                            Handballs 7.81
Goals 0.38                                  Goals 0.98


If it's Puopolo we're comparing with he's tracking along quite nicely....
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/J/Jayden_Short.html
http://afltables.com/afl/stats/players/P/Paul_Puopolo.html

There is a stat you missed- 3x Premiership player. Makes all the other numbers sound pretty stupid.

There is your comparison right there you nuffer. So are you now man enough to admit you're in fact the idiot?

Just so it is clear to everyone my interpretation is as follows;

* Big Note didn't put up the initial comparison
* Big Note however did add to the initial comparison by adding another comparison factor ie premierships
* Big Note then went on to say because Puopolo was a premiership player x 3 that the other comparison factors where all stupid

To summarise Big Note has inferred by his posts that comparing Short and Puopolo is valid and the most material factor is premierships played.

If anyone else has a different interpretation of what has happened please advise.

Can we then compare our interpretations?