Chris Yarran [merged]

[Stalin]

Impossible to police post career deals. In other words, Eddie (or rich sponsor) could offer employment post football career verbally with the players manager/solicitor present which then becomes a binding verbal contract. There is no record for the AFL to see. Nothing for them to investigate. Deal done. The only clue is that the player went for the seemingly worse deal because the "really want to play for Collingwood".........

Milne only got done, after the saints window was over

Funny that

[Andyy]

I seriously doubt Treloar is thinking about work after football. He's what, 22? And looking at making $4million over the next 6 years, with probably another 3-5 years of football after that.

The job offer to his girlfriend sounds shady and true, but I doubt that would sway him either. She wouldn't even need to work ffs.

I spoke to Miles' uncle (close family). Apparently he's still in touch with Adam and the bloke is just more of a Collingwood fan than Richmond.

[scjhammo]

I pretty much have moved on from Treloar Gale even mentioned on SEN that he is staggered that he wants to go to Collingwood at the end of the day if doesn't want to come then bring someone in that wants to come. I think we will get yarran as there were a few times we needed some one with a bit of c!!! specially even if someone went over and tried to break cotchins tag a bit to get him free I think yarran is the man to get our physical tioughness back in the right way thu.
Beneell I am leaning more and more to and hope we can get him I just hope his mind is on the job and in the right place if it works it would be a HUGE recruit for the tigers and if it doesn't well lets just say he can join the likes of fiora,JON,tambling, meyer well the list would just go on and on...
yarran,bennell and one more smokey would hold us in great stead for the season to come allows dids to stay up forward and even martin we could get 30 out of both of them looks damaging and with lennon on the up when he signs our forwards look dangers
HF:

[WA Tiger]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

So the only genuine distinction between complete fail and success is the recruitment of Yarran? Will you eat your hat if he stars for us next year?

[scjhammo]

yarran and bennell would be great pick ups for the tigers.. wishful thinking that we would get aish,redden smith.
yarran & HB would walk into our side yarran of the hbf which will allow nick to play in guts or on the wing to add some run and bennell in spin allows dids martin to stay at home more often. I think it would be great for the club to get them come on we have fringe players such as Gordon, llyold,morris getting games if those 2 arnt better then them well blow me down

[WA Tiger]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

So the only genuine distinction between complete fail and success is the recruitment of Yarran? Will you eat your hat if he stars for us next year?

Do you see Yarran as a "war chest" "big fish"???? do you see him as an x factor player that is the difference between winning that final or loosing??? I don't, with the players I have mentioned I believe that they are the differance. But watch the good old club just take Yarran and say how well they have done. Just like every year!!!

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

So the only genuine distinction between complete fail and success is the recruitment of Yarran? Will you eat your hat if he stars for us next year?

Do you see Yarran as a "war chest" "big fish"???? do you see him as an x factor player that is the difference between winning that final or loosing??? I don't, with the players I have mentioned I believe that they are the differance. But watch the good old club just take Yarran and say how well they have done. Just like every year!!!

Honestly I tend to agree with some of what your saying. Yarran wouldn't be sufficient if he was our only recruit during the trade F/A period BUT he's still potentially an absolute jet. If we snagged Yarran and Bennell I'd be pretty happy.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

So the only genuine distinction between complete fail and success is the recruitment of Yarran? Will you eat your hat if he stars for us next year?

Do you see Yarran as a "war chest" "big fish"???? do you see him as an x factor player that is the difference between winning that final or loosing??? I don't, with the players I have mentioned I believe that they are the differance. But watch the good old club just take Yarran and say how well they have done. Just like every year!!!

Honestly I tend to agree with some of what your saying. Yarran wouldn't be sufficient if he was our only recruit during the trade F/A period BUT he's still potentially an absolute jet. If we snagged Yarran and Bennell I'd be pretty happy.

Agree. Provides us with much needed run. I know we lost the contested ball against Norf, but time and time again players were looking up and had no one running to space meaning we had to kick to a contest and thus a contested situation.

[sdc01]

Eddie, Waite and Jeff have taken their games to new levels since leaving the blues so why cant Yaz???????????
not many at our club have his skils and pace

[Penelope]

Yaran and Bennel would be a complete fail.

Bennell, Aish and/or Redden and Zac Smith/ruckman and a backman would be successful.

So the only genuine distinction between complete fail and success is the recruitment of Yarran? Will you eat your hat if he stars for us next year?

Do you see Yarran as a "war chest" "big fish"???? do you see him as an x factor player that is the difference between winning that final or loosing??? I don't, with the players I have mentioned I believe that they are the differance. But watch the good old club just take Yarran and say how well they have done. Just like every year!!!

who gives a rats clacker if he is the messiah or not? He has class and if we can get the best out him he would be a good pick up. If not another whipping boy wouldnt go astray - it would break the monotony of the same olds for a while

[Stalin]

yarren isnt enough to more ahead

more so when others are getting trelors and dangerfeilds

[Penelope]

English please?

[Eat_em_Alive]

I'm hoping we can still get Treloar but if not...
Club needs to be bold and not only bolster our short term future but bring in high quality players that we be here for years to come.
Why not target Yager O'Meara and Dion Prestia, that's right both of them.
offer both first round picks 15,16 and a player that would help satisfy the deal.
Wasn't keen on Yarran before but I've come around, bring him in for  2nd rounder and we still need to find a ruckman.

I know it won't happen, but if we sacrificed quality to get quality in could end up long term success.
Imagine just those three players added to our best 22? 

[Gigantor]

just throwing this out there..WE appear to be making even small steps forward each and every year,If we continue on this path wouldn't logic say that in the not too distant future we will reach the pinnacle.