Josh Caddy has retired [merged]

[Chuck17]

If we would have lost the baying would be long and loud, don't let the emotion of the win cloud your judgement

[Heart of Darkness]

I thought he was very good, confirmed when I watched the replay. Not sure why there's so much hate for this bloke

Took some good grabs last night which is his strength as a mid. Better game but his lack of speed is such an obvious deficiency in the modern game.

[Owl]

He was very fumbly in the wet, so were others but he stood out more in crucial moments.  His 'redeeming' goal is just a bit of glen 20 over the turd of a game he had.  Hope he cleans it up.

[tony_montana]

Watch the replay he was very good and clean 

[(•))(©™]

He was very fumbly in the wet, so were others but he stood out more in crucial moments.  His 'redeeming' goal is just a bit of glen 20 over the turd of a game he had.  Hope he cleans it up.

Glen20 goal

[🏅Dooks]

I thought he was good.

[Go Richo 12]

So did i

[eliminator]

I thought he was good. He was clean in his ball use. Definitely his best game for the club.

[Tigeritis™©®]

I thought he was very good, confirmed when I watched the replay. Not sure why there's so much hate for this bloke

Took some good grabs last night which is his strength as a mid. Better game but his lack of speed is such an obvious deficiency in the modern game.

He is extremely slow, far too slow as an outside mid. He needs to use his strength more as an inside mid. I'd like to see him bust through the pack and boot it forwards more often a bit more like Dusty does. I think he's capable to do this.
It might be that I expected more and didn't realise he was so slow.

[Tigershark]

Still better than Tyrone.........that's what we effectively traded for him

[Owl]

He was garbage in the first half I thought, just my thought

[Cheese]

Downhill skier.
Does nothing then cue him for a final quarter goal to give his performane credibility.

[Yeahright]

Thought his game was alright

[Andyy]

I thought he was good and did plenty of grunt work in the first half personally.

And yes his goal at the end will keep him comfortably in the side. Stood his ground and kept his feet in the contest, as usual.

[one-eyed]

Recruit watch: How are your new players going?
afl.com.au
3 May 2017

Josh Caddy (six games): Numbers are down and hasn't hit his straps as a midfielder playing large periods forwards, but is helping the club's stars at stoppages in a selfless role.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-05-03/recruit-watch-how-are-your-clubs-new-players-going