Welcome to Tigerland - Jordan McMahon and Mitch Morton

[Little Jackie]

Bump! Where are you Blaisee

[Francois Jackson]

he wont comment jack. why because he is starting to realise that mcmahon is a dud.

i admit when im wrong about a given player but i get baffled when some on here have their mcmahon blinkers on and cant admit that this was the most terrible mistake that TW has made since coming to Punt road

[Little Jackie]

Anyone who watched "" on the couch "" last night would of seen the swipe Healy and Walls gave McMahon and showed a highlight sorry lowlight of Jordon walking away from contest while Harvey kicked as easy goal. It didnt look good

[blaisee]

Right here jack.


If the mark, that was a mark had been paid to Shultz, he would have been a hero, he didnt have his best game, but he has been very good this year as a strong bodied defender floating up forward and pinching goals.


As for Mcmahon, never said he was a champion, just said he wouldnt play 12 games for Coburg....big difference.

[Little Jackie]

Both players are a waste of space, tried and failed.
About time we played the likes of Cocchin, Connors and even Hughes.
Schulz never going to be any good.
As for McMahon, the vision that on the couch showed, summed him up beautifully. Its really good having all the camera shots as these we gutted players eventually get caught out as McMahon did last saturday night.
The proof was on TV

[Tigermonk]

Both players are a waste of space, tried and failed.
About time we played the likes of Cocchin, Connors and even Hughes.
Schulz never going to be any good.
As for McMahon, the vision that on the couch showed, summed him up beautifully. Its really good having all the camera shots as these we gutted players eventually get caught out as McMahon did last saturday night.
The proof was on TV

l seen that  his done it so many times he needs the flick

[blaisee]

Both players are a waste of space, tried and failed.
About time we played the likes of Cocchin, Connors and even Hughes.
Schulz never going to be any good.
As for McMahon, the vision that on the couch showed, summed him up beautifully. Its really good having all the camera shots as these we gutted players eventually get caught out as McMahon did last saturday night.
The proof was on TV

connors is in the vfl reserves
cotchin hasnt has a pre-season and has played 2 games for coburg
hughes playes in riewalts position

none of these players are ready/able to play in mcmahon or shutz position

[Little Jackie]

Both players are a waste of space, tried and failed.
About time we played the likes of Cocchin, Connors and even Hughes.
Schulz never going to be any good.
As for McMahon, the vision that on the couch showed, summed him up beautifully. Its really good having all the camera shots as these we gutted players eventually get caught out as McMahon did last saturday night.
The proof was on TV

connors is in the vfl reserves
cotchin hasnt has a pre-season and has played 2 games for coburg
hughes playes in riewalts position

none of these players are ready/able to play in mcmahon or shutz position

Wouldnt make in any difference. Schulz and Mcmahon are useless anyway
No harm in playing younger players in different positions is there.
Seen Cooney take 3 centre bounce ruck contests the other week and won all three.
Blaisee, you are a tool!

[Smokey]

Seen Cooney take 3 centre bounce ruck contests the other week and won all three.
Blaisee, you are a tool!

Also saw the Bulldog supporters take 3-4 years of calling for his head and lamenting a wasted #1 draft pick before they saw what those in charge did a few years prior.  Have some patience - you will end up looking a lot more insightful.

[rogerd3]

Seen Cooney take 3 centre bounce ruck contests the other week and won all three.
Blaisee, you are a tool!

Also saw the Bulldog supporters take 3-4 years of calling for his head and lamenting a wasted #1 draft pick before they saw what those in charge did a few years prior.  Have some patience - you will end up looking a lot more insightful.

good point.

[Little Jackie]

Seen Cooney take 3 centre bounce ruck contests the other week and won all three.
Blaisee, you are a tool!

Also saw the Bulldog supporters take 3-4 years of calling for his head and lamenting a wasted #1 draft pick before they saw what those in charge did a few years prior.  Have some patience - you will end up looking a lot more insightful.

For whats it worth , he had OP for nearly 18 months.
Schulz and McMahon have a different problem, lack of ability

[Smokey]

For whats it worth , he had OP for nearly 18 months.

Thats interesting.  He has missed 3 games in his 4+ years career so far - rounds 9, 15 and 16 in his first season - hasn't missed a game since.  Hardly what you would expect from a young player with OP, both from the players perspective of not being able to play well with it or from the clubs perspective of managing it.

[Little Jackie]

For whats it worth , he had OP for nearly 18 months.

Thats interesting.  He has missed 3 games in his 4+ years career so far - rounds 9, 15 and 16 in his first season - hasn't missed a game since.  Hardly what you would expect from a young player with OP, both from the players perspective of not being able to play well with it or from the clubs perspective of managing it.

Stop trying to bait me.
I have watched the bulldogs train for the past 4 years probably once every three weeks and can tell you that he OP and other groin issues during this time.
You know that I watched all clubs train so get over it
Can tell you he wasnt right, Likewise Ball from St.Kilda, he couldnt even run at training last year but they persiisted on playing him, anything else you wont to know.

[tigersalive]

For whats it worth , he had OP for nearly 18 months.

Thats interesting.  He has missed 3 games in his 4+ years career so far - rounds 9, 15 and 16 in his first season - hasn't missed a game since.  Hardly what you would expect from a young player with OP, both from the players perspective of not being able to play well with it or from the clubs perspective of managing it.

Stop trying to bait me.
I have watched the bulldogs train for the past 4 years probably once every three weeks and can tell you that he OP and other groin issues during this time.
You know that I watched all clubs train so get over it
Can tell you he wasnt right, Likewise Ball from St.Kilda, he couldnt even run at training last year but they persiisted on playing him, anything else you wont to know.

Correct.  He did have OP, not chronic to stop him playing, but enough to stop us seeing his best ability. 

But that doesnt shade the fact the supporters were still grilling him about underperforming and not being worth #1.

[Smokey]

I have watched the bulldogs train for the past 4 years probably once every three weeks and can tell you that he OP and other groin issues during this time.
You know that I watched all clubs train so get over it
Can tell you he wasnt right, Likewise Ball from St.Kilda, he couldnt even run at training last year but they persiisted on playing him, anything else you wont to know.

No, but my point still stands.  If he had OP and it was significant enough for you to trot it out as an excuse for his less-than-expected performance then I believe he wouldn't have played the number of consecutive games he has.  Unless...........he didn't have it - his performances were actually quite satisfactory and it was only impatient, knee-jerk supporters making all the noise OR his condition was not affecting his performance and the club was happy to continue playing him.  Either way, no excuse.  Schulz was only drafted 1 year before Cooney and Cooney has only stepped up this year.  Add to that being a KPP, development time lost through injury, playing under Richo's shadow and it all points to being a bit more patient with Schulz.  You might end up being right and he might not make it but lets not shoot ourselves in the foot pandering to the whingers before we know for sure.