Nick Vlastuin [merged]

[Lebowski]

yep was low impact 1 week fair, nowhere near the houli level imo

[Tigeritis™©®]

One week. Take it and run

[YellowandBlackBlood]

How did Buddy get off with a fine? He could have fractured Rance's larynx with that hit. Far more dangerous than what Vlastuin did.

[dwaino]

How did Buddy get off with a fine? He could have fractured Rance's larynx with that hit. Far more dangerous than what Vlastuin did.

Neck is also apparently treated the same as the head.

One rule for buddy, one rule for everyone else.

[Owl]

Disgusting, he hacked into his throat, unbelievable, who is this mug?  They have been giving Rance a lot of poo lately the umps

[Go Richo 12]

How did Buddy get off with a fine? He could have fractured Rance's larynx with that hit. Far more dangerous than what Vlastuin did.

Neck is also apparently treated the same as the head.

One rule for buddy, one rule for everyone else.

Buddy=Adam Goodes

[mat073]

I now know who our fifth best player is .

[Slipper]

Disgusting, he hacked into his throat, unbelievable, who is this mug?  They have been giving Rance a lot of poo lately the umps

What about the free Buddy got for diving in the first qtr!


If Rance had done that, it would have been front page news for the week.

[FooffooValve]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

[Go Richo 12]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

Na, he intentially threw the elbow back to make contact. He just didn’t intentionally mean to make contact with his 3KZ. One week is lucky.

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

He clearly didn’t intend to elbow Parker in the face. His actions afterwards are glaring proof of that. I’d take it to the tribunal.

[Go Richo 12]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

He clearly didn’t intend to elbow Parker in the face. His actions afterwards are glaring proof of that. I’d take it to the tribunal.

The action was intentional though.

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

He clearly didn’t intend to elbow Parker in the face. His actions afterwards are glaring proof of that. I’d take it to the tribunal.

The action was intentional though.

Hmm, okay. So his action was absolutely intended to elbow Parker in the face? Just asking the question...

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Both decisions fair. Buddy was open hand, Vlas elbow.
That's the difference between a suspension and fine

[the wasp]

Graded intentional. Reckon we might challenge that given he wasn't looking at Parker when he threw the elbow back. Could possibly argue that down to careless. Still, am happy it wasn't more than 1.

He clearly didn’t intend to elbow Parker in the face. His actions afterwards are glaring proof of that. I’d take it to the tribunal.

Based on the way the old and new MRP breakdown each action, I don't think it matters where it was intended for, just that it was intentional in its own right. Then they break down where the strike occurred, then grade the impact.

So then incident was Intentional+Head+Low Impact..... I reckon he was going to get 2 weeks, so lucky with one.

But using the same with the Buddy to Rance's throat incident.... Intentional+High+Low Impact (debatable)...  should have got a week if Chrisso wanted to be consistent with the gradings...