funny how the problem is that others cant step up when the a graders are beaten.
nothing said about thee fact that the a graders were beaten, and beaten badly. That is the problem. good sides just dont have their a graders all beaten at the same time, and on the few occasions they are, that is the few times that these sides lose during the year.
but hey it couldnt be their fault because they are the skilled ones and skill is much more important than mental hardness and work rate
so what are you saying. deledio cotchin and martin are mentally weak i know lets just delist em despite the fact they perform to a high standard 98% of the time and are mentally strong for a simlar amount of time. yep lets just cut those hacks we dont want em. instead lets go with those who are deficient in so many areas that they are liabilities without more rounded players around them lets go with with em because they try real hard but are incapable of taking control of a game when others struggle.
its a bleeding heart mentality.
i have one simple question. based on performance can the current list win a gf????. no stuffing way is my answer.
my stance is to win a gf we have to start cutting into those clearly below standard players.
and dont be offended we have gone from having to cut out and out hacks to just having to cut ordinary players but either way we need to cut em. i want us to be more than a pee ant middling team. at the end of the say that is all we currently are. a MIDDLING TEAM.
You truly are off your rocker and have this great ability to twist things completely.
did i say delist the players you mentioned? HUH? A typical claw overereaction when someone disagrees with them.
Are they mentally week. well considering the amount of times they go missing as a collective unit, id say they are not as strong as required, at the moment.
Is that group of players equal in talent to any other group in the league?
Yes!!!!
do the top sides have their group of topline players go missing collectively as a unit as often as them?
No!
and what happens on the rare occasions they do?
They generally stuffing lose!!
We actually can generally cover one or two of our top line players going missing, but we cant cover the whole unit of them going AWOL. No side in the comp can.
But you seem to think its ok for top line players to not play to their best, as long as they dont have any deficiencies in their game , according to the word of claw that is, because in this alter reality you should have a team of A grade players.
We now have an insight into why you seem to always strive to have a team of 22 top notch players, because in your alter reality it doesn't matter if 4 or 5 of the best players go collectively missing, because there will be another dozen or so players who can magically step up and cover for this group.
meanwhile, while trying to assemble this super allstars team, other teams are winning premierships with a group of A graders that constantly bring their good game, backed up by a core of hard working, honest, solid, foot soldiers.
